Reason: The article is about a non-existant rivalry between two players who don't face off against one another. They have only played 4 games against one another at this point. The only other NFL player rivalry page I've seen is
Tom Brady–Peyton Manning rivalry, in which there were 17 games played by two all-time greats. Fails
WP:GNG and may be
WP:TOOSOON.
Reason: Fails
WP:GNG. None of the NFL stat websites show him ever catching a pass in the NFL, with the
2000 Denver Broncos season showing he did not make the roster. The
only stats I can find from his college days show that in his final season, "Fields caught 19 passes for 325 yards and two touchdowns in eight games". Does not appear notable for college or professional achievements.
Reason: Fails
WP:GNG and
WP:SIGCOV. He played 1 game in the NFL in which he did not start (according to Pro-Football-Reference). Significant coverage does not appear to exist for this player. While it does pass
WP:NGRIDIRON, a single appearance in a game in 1930 is not enough to indicate notability.
Reason: Fails
WP:GNG. He had 1 carry in the
NFL for the
Cincinnati Bengals in 1995, in which he rushed for a single yard. His
college career does not appear to be notable either, having finished with a total of 987 scrimmage yards after 4 years. He does appear to own a gym now, but that's all I'm finding in terms of notability for him, and even that's a stretch.
Reason: Not finding coverage of them. What's listed in their article, being a young translator, doesn't pass the bar of notability in my mind. I don't believe this passes
WP:GNG or
WP:SIGCOV.
Reason: It's tough to even really call it a rivalry at this point. This "rivalry" is just based on geography and, even then,
sports rivalries are not presumed notable. There have been 7 regular season meetings since 1997, the teams play in different conferences, and only meet every 4 years. They have never met in the playoffs. 7 games in 25 years with no meetings in the playoff is not a notable rivalry and should not have its own article.
Reason: The article is a single sentence for the lead ("A Cello Christmas is the fifth studio album by Tina Guo") and a track listing. Not shown to meet
WP:GNG or
WP:NALBUM at this point in time.
Reason: Very unlikely redirect. Cannot be nominated for R3 as it was part of a page move. It was neither the original location or the final destination, just a temporary page.
Reason: Very unlikely redirect. Cannot be nominated for R3 as it was part of a page move. It was neither the original location or the final destination, just a temporary page.
Reason: This is the name of an active YouTuber with 547 thousand subscribers. He did a series on the 2018 Pittsburgh Steelers season, but he's also done a LOT more. This is not an appropriate redirect and should be left red for the time being.
Reason: No mention in the article article of a Bobberson at the target article. Some searching hasn't explain why this redirect should point to Clint Black either. As such, nominating for deletion so it can be remade if there's ever an appropriate target.
Reason: Ambiguous title redirects to a specific genre when other genres also exist (such as
2023 in rock music and
2023 in country music. Proposing to delete the redirect until someone takes an interest in making a page similar to
2022 in music.
Reason: Non-notable song that does not need its own page. The official video only has ~512k views and the song itself fails to meet
WP:NSONG. The article itself only contains the YouTube video as a reference and the creator of the article removed the PROD tag without explanation.
Reason: Band does not appear to be notable and fails to meet
WP:BAND. Most of their YouTube videos have under 1,000 views and I'm not finding anything that helps to establish their notability. Previously tagged with PROD, but tag was removed by the creator of the article.
Reason: Rapper that doesn't appear to pass
WP:GNG or
WP:MUSICBIO.Though there is some coverage of them, a lot of what I'm finding is based on appearing on
MTV Hustle 2.0, which doesn't demonstrate notability based on point 2 of
WP:REALITYSINGER.
Reason: Unsourced
WP:OR since its creation. The page has been changed to a redirect on multiple occasions (to
Chinese people in Myanmar, a destination that has been argued is not appropriate) but the entirely unsourced article has repeatedly been restored.
Reason: This article is about an event (boxing match) that never took place and was cancelled less than a month after being announced. The content was originally included at
Jake Paul vs. Tommy Fury but it was forked by a user. I believe a trimmed version of this content should be at
Jake Paul vs. Tommy Fury and not as its own stand-alone article.
Reason: Fails to meet
WP:NSPORTS. Drafted to the NFL in the 12th round in 1991 but failed to ever make the roster. He was signed by an NFL Europe team, but never took the field for them either.
Reason: Doesn't appear to meet GNG after a WP:Before search. They've made a single appearance in a professional association football game, likely
WP:TOOSOON.
Reason: Appears to have been a weekly ranking of NFL teams that is now shut down (based on no rankings for the 2022 season). It's existed as a 2 sentence article with a single reference since creation in 2012. Doesn't appear to pass GNG or any other notability requirements that I'm aware of after a WP:BEFORE search.
Reason: Doesn't seem to meet
WP:SINGER or
WP:GNG. Not finding independent coverage or notability for this artist outside of their association with their childhood friend, Lil Xan, which is mostly passing mentions. Sources provided are not considered
WP:RS. 5 are to a media company named Lyrical Lemonade (a company/blog that produced videos for the artist), 1 to an interview on Genius, a passing mention on hiphopdx, and an interview posted on an apparel company's website. The performer's YouTube page also only has 1 video with over 500k views.
Reason:
WP:INDISCRIMINATE and
WP:OR. I tried to salvage this list article last week but the only source available is StatMuse. StatMuse is an AI tool which allows you to use "conversational search" to find statistics that match a question you enter (some have suggested this site functions like a chatbot).
Reason: Does not appear to meet
WP:NSPORT or
WP:GNG and lacks
WP:SIGCOV. Of the six references included, three of them are sports database entries, two are passing mentions (one of which is just them in a team picture), and one is inaccessible (a book).
Reason: Non-notable lobby group. Article has been unsourced for 17 years and a WP:BEFORE search turned up next to nothing. Lacks
WP:SIGCOV and fails to meet
WP:ORG.
Reason: The redirect title is inaccurate. The second generation of games (Gold, Silver, & Crystal) introduced 100 new Pokémon but the games also contained the original
first generation Pokémon as well. The target only contains a list of the 100 new Pokémon.
Reason: The redirect title is inaccurate. The second generation of games (Gold, Silver, & Crystal) introduced 100 new Pokémon but the games also contained the original
first generation Pokémon as well. The target only contains a list of the 100 new Pokémon.
Reason: The redirect title is inaccurate. The second generation of games (Gold, Silver, & Crystal) introduced 100 new Pokémon but the games also contained the original
first generation Pokémon as well. The target only contains a list of the 100 new Pokémon.
Reason: Counting the variation with a capital F for film, this is the third time this page has been re-created by a user. Based on the missing space between the title and the disambiguator, it's an improperly formatted title and unlikely search term.
Reason: Was never known as Dwayne Bowles. His father,
Rocky Johnson, was born as Wayde Bowles but legally changed his name to Rocky Johnson (which was the moniker he went by) before Dwayne was born.
Reason: Per point 8 of
WP:R#DELETE and
WP:RFOREIGN. Redirect in a language other than English that points to an article not directly related with the language.
Reason: Not mentioned at target. The pages that point to this redirect refer to Bulang as an ethnic group or as an island. Pointing to Brown University doesn't make sense. I think this page is better left as a red link until an appropriate article can be created.
Reason: Per point 8 of
WP:R#DELETE and
WP:RFOREIGN. Creator left an edit summary stating this is a colloquial Chinese name for the state. Redirect in a language other than English that points to an article not directly related with the language.
Reason: The redirect was created because Reddit was breaking a link to Wikipedia. It is not our job to fix broken links from external sites. Precedence exists based on prior MfD discussions, such as
this and
this.
Reason: Article is not written in an encyclopedic tone (written as an essay), non-neutral, and contains original research. I'm suggesting deletion based on
WP:NOTESSAY,
WP:NPOV, and
WP:OR.
Reason: Title conventions don't include quotation marks. Also not a helpful search term, as inputting this exact title in the search bar will point you to the article anyways.
Reason: The target for the redirect is the 47th Toronto International Film Festival, not the 48th.
1 The 2023 article, which would be the 48th, does not exist.
Reason: Per
WP:REDLINK and because targeting the redirect to the previous year doesn't make sense, as it occurred entirely in 2022. Alternatively, redirect to
Toronto International Film Festival and add the "with possibilities" redirect category.
Reason: Best left as a
WP:REDLINK. Those who may search for the 48th Saturn Awards would not expect to be redirected to the 47th. Alternatively, redirect to
Saturn Awards and tag with the "r with possibilities" redirect category.
Reason: Unclear why this term is meant to redirect to the city (not mentioned at target), but even if it is the city's motto it's, it's not a useful search term.
Reason: Redirect in a language other than English that points to an article not directly related to the language. I'm suggesting deletion based on
WP:RFOREIGN and point 8 of
WP:R#DELETE.
Reason: Unlikely search terms and not useful redirects. Note that 3 of these were recent creations while one (the 3rd redirect) has existed since 2007. Should probably be left as red links so that other similar redirects are not encouraged.
Reason: Article about a song which does not appear to meet
WP:NSONGS. Note that the article itself indicates that the song had a lack of commercial success.
Reason: Album does not appear to pass
WP:NALBUMS and redirecting was contested. A before search didn't find anything to indicate that this album is notable.
Reason: The emoji represents a couch and a lamp. I don't think the character has a clear and definite meaning matching the target, as plenty of other rooms in a home or other space may have a couch and lamp.
Reason: Redirect in a language other than English that points to an article not directly related with the language. Suggesting deletion based on point 8 of
WP:R#DELETE and
WP:RFOREIGN.
Reason: Redirect in a language other than English that points to an article not directly related with the language. Suggesting deletion based on point 8 of
WP:R#DELETE and
WP:RFOREIGN.
Reason: Fails
WP:NPOLITICIAN and lacks
WP:SIGCOV – local government elected members are not automatically notable. As per
WP:ANYBIO, requires significant coverage in multiple independent secondary sources, not just mentions in passing. Current sourcing is a city website and a BEFORE check only found local mentioned.
Reason: Fails
WP:NPOLITICIAN – local government officials are not automatically notable. There are plenty of local sources present in the article, but there's nothing to indicate that this person is notable beyond being part of a city council for a city with a population of ~33,000 people.
Reason: Appears to be a run of the mill high level but non-notable business executive who was also an ambassador-designate. He was nominated by Trump to serve as ambassador to Estonia, but never took office.
Reason: Ambiguous title. I'm finding a number of different murders that have taken place on Christmas when searching. Seems like a redirect that should be best left as a red link.
Reason: Forums and forms are not the same thing, though I understand the creator made the redirect with a misspelling in mind.
Google Groups features forums and Google also has a Google Play community forum, Google cloud learning forum, and a support forum.
Reason: Ambiguous title. I'm finding a number of different murders that have taken place on Christmas when searching. Seems like a redirect that should be best left as a red link.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search term which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 20+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Current mayor of
Bălți, Moldova. Based on the Russian & Romanian articles, they were also a city councillor as well as the vice-mayor. Not finding enough to pass
WP:NPOL or
WP:GNG, just routine coverage.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Ambiguous search terms which could refer to a number of different coaches. Based on a search of
Category:Coaches by sport, there are 15+ coaches with this last name.
Reason: Live album which does not appear to pass
WP:NALBUM. Based on a before search it does not appear to have charted, won an award, or received enough significant coverage for a stand alone article. Nominating to be redirected to
Humble Pie, the band who recorded the album.
Hey man im josh (
talk) 18:40, 14 August 2023 (UTC)
Reason: Past mayor of
Timmins, a town in Ontario with a population of ~41,000. The article is not written neutrally and the only source on the article (not counting the dead link) is just a passing mention. Fails
WP:NPOLITICIAN and lacks
WP:SIGCOV.
Reason: Actor who has appeared in more than just RoboCop. Doesn't make sense to target RoboCop when there are a number of other possible targets as well, such as
Lethal Weapon 4. Best left as a redlink for now.
Reason: Former mayor of
Santa Cruz de Lorica. As a local elected official, they are not considered inherently notable and the coverage that I'm finding all appears to be fairly routine. Does not appear to meet point 2 of
WP:NPOL or
WP:GNG.
Reason: This person is the sibling of
National Football League players
Amon-Ra St. Brown and
Equanimeous_St._Brown, as well as the son of
John Brown (bodybuilder) (Amateur Mr. Universe twice and Mr. World three times). None of the 3 family members make the most sense as the target, so I'd argue this is best left as a red link for the time being.
Reason: Mayor of
Sandy, Utah, a city with a population of about 96,000 people. Their claim to notability appears to be that they are the city's first female mayor. However, I don't think in of itself is enough to pass
WP:GNG and is not enough to pass
WP:NPOL.
Reason: Unreferenced bio of an association football player who does not appear to meet
WP:SPORTSBASIC or
WP:GNG. It looks like they've only played in lower level leagues and they lack
WP:SIGCOV.
Reason: Non-notable association football player. Article does not meet
WP:SPORTSBASIC or
WP:GNG and there does not appear to be
WP:SIGCOV on the subject. Played in the fourth level of the Argentine football league system and fifth level of the Chilean one.
Reason: Unreferenced non-notable association football player bio. Article does not meet
WP:SPORTSBASIC or
WP:GNG and there does not appear to be
WP:SIGCOV on the subject. Highest level of success appears to be minor playtime in the second tier professional football league in Paraguay (38 minutes) with a fair bit of play time in 2013 in the third tier of the Chilean system.
Reason: Very poorly sourced BLP with no signs of passing
WP:GNG or
WP:SPORTBASIC. Appears to have had 65 minutes of play time in 2012/2013 in the second division of the Argentine football league system.
Reason: Unreferenced non-notable association football player bio. Article does not meet
WP:SPORTSBASIC or
WP:GNG and there does not appear to be
WP:SIGCOV on the subject. Highest level of success appears playtime at the second level of the Chilean system and third level of the Argentine system.
Reason: Unreferenced non-notable association football player bio. Article does not meet
WP:SPORTSBASIC or
WP:GNG and there does not appear to be
WP:SIGCOV on the subject. Highest level of play was the second level of the Chilean system and third level of the Argentina system.
Reason: Very poorly sourced BLP with no signs of passing
WP:GNG or
WP:SPORTBASIC. Appears to have only had 90 minutes of play time in 2011/2012 in the second level of the Uruguayan football league system.
Reason: Fails
WP:NLIST and I don't believe it can get to a point where it would pass because historical records of teams in x week (week 1 in this case) are not typically discussed or covered. Up to date sourcing (not including the 2023 season) does exist and is created by the NFL, but it's amongst 800+ pages of records and facts that the NFL tracks
here. Not every stat is meaningful enough to merit its own list and I don't believe that there's enough coverage of this contextual stat to justify it.
Reason: I think anybody who would be looking up the IP would be doing so with the numbers instead of writing them out. I don't believe this to be a helpful or useful redirect.
Reason: I retargeted this to
France at the 2024 Summer Olympics and was reverted. I believe my suggested target makes more sense given that the 2024 iteration of the Olympics is marketed as "Paris 2024", and not "France 2024". If I were to search Country YYYY (Olympics), I would expect to be redirected to Country at the YYYY Olympics.
Reason: The
United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement has a mandated six-year review that's scheduled for 2026 (United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement#Sunset clause|Sunset clause]] section mentions this, but not explicitly the year). This, to me at least, was the expected result when I originally saw the redirect.
Reason: The
United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement has a mandated six-year review that's scheduled for 2026 (United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement#Sunset clause|Sunset clause]] section mentions this, but not explicitly the year). This, to me at least, was the expected result when I originally saw the redirect.
Reason: The
United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement has a mandated six-year review that's scheduled for 2026 (United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement#Sunset clause|Sunset clause]] section mentions this, but not explicitly the year). This, to me at least, was the expected result when I originally saw the redirect.
Reason: I redirected the page to
Moreau (surname) but was reverted. There are a number of artists at the target destination but another editor believes it's not ambiguous. Keep target or change?
Reason: Unlikely search term. It's based on a meme about
Latios and
Latias, each one having a different gender, and "Lati@s" apparently being a play on that. Even if that weren't the case, I'd nominate this as a l33tspeak redirect that's unehlpful.
Reason: "Qatar 2023" is not unambiguously affiliated with the
2023 AFC Asian Cup and I propose retargeting to
2023 in Qatar. I've tried to change the target, as has another editor (
Significa liberdade), and instead of edit warring I'm seeking feedback on this. It is my belief that "CountryName Year" redirects should be pointed to YYYY in CountryName. I made a similar nomination
here, where I nominated a number of CountryName Year redirects.
Reason: Per the
Atlanta Falcons themselves, they do not retire numbers, they honour them.
[1] This template misrepresents the reality of the situation.
Reason: (List of 6 previous RfDs cut out) Bringing this here based on a dispute with
Abhiramakella. Based on consensus in past discussions, including
one that resulted in the deletion of this redirect in the past, CountryName YYYY redirects are not unambiguously associated with events. Proposing to redirect to
2024 in France, which wasn't an option at the time this redirect was last deleted.
Hey man im josh (
talk) 16:39, 5 March 2024 (UTC)
Reason: Only a single article included in the navbox which makes it not useful for navigation. The number has also apparently unretired anyways.
WP:NENAN.
Reason: I believe this to be an ambiguous term and, as such, it should be redirected to
Superdome, where there are four stadiums that go by/have gone by this name. Bringing this here due to a dispute on the target with
Abhiramakella.
Reason: Appears to be a non-notable band that doesn't pass
WP:NBAND. Lot of non-neutral puffery and a before search didn't turn up enough to convince me that they're notable. Article was also created by Michaelxcrusty, who appears to be a member of the band based on the members listed.
Reason: Former mayor of
Cairns Region who does not meet point 2 of
WP:NPOL and does not appear to meet
WP:GNG. As a local elected official, they are not considered inherently notable and the coverage that I'm finding all appears to be fairly routine.
Reason: Another former mayor of
Cairns Region who does not meet point 2 of
WP:NPOL and does not appear to meet
WP:GNG. As a local elected official, they are not considered inherently notable and the coverage that I'm finding all appears to be fairly routine. This person also has a shortened term (4 months) compared to most mayors because they were appointed to the position to finish out the term of the retiring mayor and then lost re-election.
Reason: Fails
WP:NMUSICIAN. Claim to notability is winning a singing competition in 2003, as well as participating in another in 2014. Not seeing anything really outside of that, despite apparently releasing 3 albums.
Reason: Fails
WP:NMUSICIAN. Information I found in a
WP:BEFORE search seems to all be mostly related to their membership of the
Graham Bonnet Band. Anything else I found is still solely related to their membership of a band (see
WP:BANDMEMBER).