YOU MIGHT BE ON THE WRONG PAGE. This page is not meant for general questions, nor discussions about specific articles.
This page is only for discussions about the Wikipedia page
Help:Archiving a talk page. To discuss an article, please use that article's talk page. To ask for help with using and editing Wikipedia, use
our Teahouse. Alternatively, see
our FAQ.
This page is within the scope of the Wikipedia Help Project, a collaborative effort to improve Wikipedia's help documentation for readers and contributors. If you would like to participate, please visit
the project page, where you can join the
discussion and see a list of open tasks. To browse help related resources see the
Help Menu or
Help Directory. Or ask for help on your talk page and a volunteer will visit you there.Wikipedia HelpWikipedia:Help ProjectTemplate:Wikipedia Help ProjectHelp articles
Feedback: Archiving in the context of a page that uses level-one headings as dividers
Please see
this discussion about a proposal to enable archiving of level-two discussions at a page (like
WP:Help desk) that uses level-one headings to group atomic discussions by date.
Mathglot (
talk) 19:03, 9 January 2024 (UTC)reply
Unclear whether "lowest number" means 0 or 1
I.e. "where N is the lowest number for which no archive exists." under
Manual archiving.
Ybllaw (
talk) 17:35, 4 June 2024 (UTC)reply
Normally archives will begin at 1, so /Archive 1, /Archive 2, etc. If there's no archives, you'll want to start at 1.
Aidan9382(
talk) 18:05, 4 June 2024 (UTC)reply
When to archive a talk page
So I've recently been having this very strange interaction with
JayBeeEll, now ending with
[1] - it's a talk page that is over 30 KB long and has a thread from 10 years ago, but this user doesn't want to let me enable archiving that. Is this normal? Am I crazy? :D --
Joy (
talk) 19:39, 6 June 2024 (UTC)reply
Um, no, that's not what's happening. You want to archive all discussions except the most recent. JayBeeEll wants to archive all discussions except the most recent five (which is the default). Just leaving one does seem over-aggressive.
Dan Bloch (
talk) 20:48, 6 June 2024 (UTC)reply
So there's 15 threads there now. Leaving up to 5 will leave discussions from mid-2020 there, which is already 4 years ago. Are these actually relevant? What's the aggressive part? --
Joy (
talk) 12:22, 7 June 2024 (UTC)reply
5 is pretty typical, even when there are years-old threads. It lets people easily see if what they came in to discuss has been discussed recently -- whatever that means for that talk page -- and whether new threads even typically receive any responses. I recently came into a talk with a concern about something and saw there'd been a discussion three years earlier, so I knew who to ping. I'll even manually archive newer discussions to prevent the archiving of older ones if the older ones seem more helpful.
Valereee (
talk) 13:33, 7 June 2024 (UTC)reply
I agree with
Danbloch and
Valereee. Archiving has a benefit as the solution of a particular problem (the unnavigability of large talk-pages) but it also has costs (it makes it hard to see past discussions and the conclusions that they reached). Fast (90 days on lightly-used pages) or aggressive (leaving only 0 or 1 threads) archiving settings increase the costs without providing any extra benefit. --
JBL (
talk) 18:37, 7 June 2024 (UTC)reply
Guys, I'm sympathetic to these general arguments, but I feel like you didn't actually have a look at the context of this particular
Talk:Jon Entine page... even once the bot archives the 10-year-old threads, and even if we let it archive the 4-year-old threads, it's still going to take 7 PageDowns to get to the discussion from March last year. That talk page already provides so much context that it's actually borderline unwelcoming. --
Joy (
talk) 08:54, 8 June 2024 (UTC)reply
No, I looked at it. I'd say the answer is set up typical archiving (generally I default to 90 days and 5 threads kept), then manually archive any threads you think are not worth keeping.
Valereee (
talk) 11:38, 8 June 2024 (UTC)reply
Updates
Based on discussions at
Template talk:Archives, I plan to update this page soon. Feel free to join in the conversation there or to offer any feedback on things that should be fixed. Regards,
Rjjiii (
talk) 00:40, 14 June 2024 (UTC)reply