Reynolds and Silver made their debut as a tag team in August 2011 for New York Wrestling Connection defeating Stockade and Apollyon.[2] In January 2012, Reynolds and Silver made their debut for
EVOLVE at
EVOLVE 10 where they were defeated by Scott Reed and
Caleb Konley.[3]
WWE (2019)
The Beaver Boys billed as Alex Keaton and Johnny Silver lost to Heavy Machinery (
Otis and
Tucker) in a squash match on the September 10, 2019 edition of Smackdown at
Madison Square Garden.[4][5]
All Elite Wrestling (2019–present)
Reynolds and Silver made their
All Elite Wrestling debut on the third episode of AEW Dynamite as enhancement talent losing to
Santana and Ortiz.[4][6] Over the following months vignettes aired of Silver and Reynolds getting recruitment messages from
The Dark Order eventually resulting in Reynolds and Silver joining the Dark Order as henchmen, thus establishing themselves as
villains. In December 2019, it was revealed that Reynolds and Silver had signed with All Elite Wrestling.[7][8][9] In August, it was revealed that Reynolds and Silver had signed long-term contracts.