Caster and Bowens were initially performing individually on AEW programming in 2020.[1] Caster first appeared on
AEW Dark as a solo act, with Bowens being brought in a month later.[1] The idea of putting the two together as a tag team was conceived by
Tony Khan, who also named them the Acclaimed.[1] Their debut match as a team was against
Best Friends;[2] according to Bowens, Khan offered them full-time contracts immediately after the match,[3] on a 5-year deal.[4] On the
Holiday Bash special, the Acclaimed challenged
the Young Bucks for the
AEW World Tag Team Championship, but were unsuccessful.[5] Bowens has expressed that initially fan reaction to the team was more negative than expected, which led to him ironically declaring "everyone loves the Acclaimed" in promos.[6]
The Acclaimed competed in a Battle Royal to determine the number 1 contenders for the tag team titles on February 3, 2021, but lost to
Chris Jericho and
MJF of
The Inner Circle.[7] On April 22, 2021 they again competed in a #1 contendership match, this time a four way, where they were defeated by SCU.[8]
On the August 3, 2021 episode of Dark, while making his entrance, Caster rapped about subjects such as Olympic gymnast
Simone Biles' mental health issues, the
Duke lacrosse case, the validity of
PCR COVID-19 testing, and made a sexual joke about
Julia Hart. Caster was suspended for two months without pay for the incident, effectively putting the team on hiatus.[9][10][11] AEW owner
Tony Khan called the rap "terrible", said it should have been edited out of the show and announced that he would personally be taking over the editing of the show going forward.[12] He returned to action at Dark: Elevation on September 1.[13] After Caster returned from suspension, the Acclaimed challenged reigning champions the
Lucha Brothers for the tag team titles on the June 10, 2021 episode of
Rampage, but were unsuccessful.[14]
Beginning in 2022, the Acclaimed allied with the Gunn Club,
Billy Gunn his sons Austin and Colton. On Dark and Dark: Elevation, the alliance defeated
the Dark Order and later the team of
Lee Johnson,
Brock Anderson,
Lee Moriarty, and
Matt Sydal.[15] Although ostentisiably allies, the Acclaimed regularly disparaged Austin and Colton, with Billy Gunn showing unequal favour towards Caster and Bowens. The Acclaimed competed in a #1 contendership tag battle royal on March 3, 2022, although lost to the Young Bucks. They later challenged
Jurassic Express for the tag titles, but were unsuccessful.[16][17] In May 2022, Bowens underwent knee surgery, sidelining him for several months.[18] During this time Bowens still attended AEW shows and performed his regular promos, although did not wrestle and was confined to a wheelchair; Caster subsequently teamed increasingly with the Gunns.[19] Bowens returned from injury at the Blood and Guts edition of Dynamite.[20]
Their alliance with the Gunns broke down and turned into a rivalry in mid-2022, leading to a "Dumpster Match" in August 2022, which the Acclaimed won.[21] While Billy Gunn was initially caught between the two groups, his sons turned on him, having joined
the Firm, leading to him becoming the Acclaimed's manager.[22]
AEW World Tag Team Champions (2022)
In the latter half of 2022, the Acclaimed entered a feud with tag team champions Swerve in our Glory (
Swerve Strickland and
Keith Lee). At
All Out of that year the Acclaimed challenged for tag team championships, although Strickland and Lee retained.[23] The Acclaimed again challenged for the titles on the September 21 episode of Dynamite, winning the bout and becoming AEW World Tag Team champions for the first time.[24] Over the following months the team successfully defended the title against
Private Party and
The Butcher and The Blade in a triple-threat match,[25] the Varsity Athletes (
Tony Nese and
Josh Woods),[26] and a rematch against Swerve in Our Glory at November's
Full Gear.[27]
In early 2023, the Acclaimed resumed their feud with Austin and Colton Gunn. On the February 8, 2023 episode of Dynamite, the Gunns successfully beat the Acclaimed for the tag team champions, ending their reign at 140 days.[28]
AEW World Trios Championship (2023–2024)
As 2023 went along, the three members of the Acclaimed became focused on winning the
AEW World Trios Championship. This led to a match on the July 22 episode of AEW Collision, where reigning champions the
House of Black (
Malakai Black,
Brody King and
Buddy Matthews) defeated the Acclaimed, leading to Gunn—thinking he was the reason for the loss―taking his boots off and leaving them in the ring, seemingly signifying his retirement (as that is viewed as an established wrestling tradition).[29] In August, the House of Black threw Gunn's boots in a
trash compactor, leading to Gunn returning and rejoining Caster and Bowens. On August 27, 2023, at
All In, Gunn and The Acclaimed won the AEW World Trios Championship from
The House of Black (
Malakai Black,
Brody King, and
Buddy Matthews) in a "House Rules"
No Holds Barredsix-man tag team match.
On the January 20, 2024 episode of Collision, The Acclaimed joined forces with
Bullet Club Gold to form the "Bang Bang Scissor Gang".[30] At
Big Business, Bullet Club Gold turned on The Acclaimed, disbanding the "Bang Bang Scissor Gang". At
Dynasty: Zero Hour on April 21, 2024,
ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Champions Bullet Club Gold defeated Gunn and The Acclaimed for the AEW World Trios Championship in a
winner takes allchampionship unification match to unify the titles as the Unified World Trios Championship, ending their reign at a record 238 days.[31][32]
^Meltzer, Dave (February 2023). "February 2023 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Results of the 2022 Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards". Wrestling Observer Newsletter.