On March 24, 2012, The Baronis Brothers made their
Ohio Valley Wrestling debut in a dark match losing to the team of Raphael Constantine and
Sean Casey.[3] They continued to work various dark matches and televised matches until their final match with the promotion on June 7, 2012, in a dark match loss to the team of Jayce King and LMC.[4]
In 2015, The Tate Twins began going by the name The Boys joining
Dalton Castle as a stable. On September 18, 2015, at
All Star Extravaganza VII with the stipulations that if Castle lost,
Silas Young would get services of The Boys, while if Young lost, he would become one of Castle's Boys. Castle subsequently lost the match, with Silas Young getting The Boys.[6] Castle faced Young in another losing effort at
Final Battle, but despite The Boys seemingly siding with Young in the weeks prior to the event,[7] they rejoined Castle following the match.[8]
On February 4, 2020, The Tate Twins made their return to OVW defeating the team of AJZ and Tony Bizo.[15]
On November 7, 2020, The Tate Twins entered the 2020
Nightmare Cup Tag Team Tournament defeating three teams to win the tournament and moving onto the finals defeating The Legacy of Brutality (Ca$h Flo and Josh Ashcraft) to win the
OVW Tag Team Championships.[16]
On April 6, 2021, The Tate Twins unsuccessfully defended the
OVW Tag Team Championships against the team of
Jessie Godderz and Tony Gunn.[17] They would go on to defeat Godderz and Gunn in a rematch at OVW Defiance on May 22 to regain the OVW Tag Team Championships.[18]
On August 28, 2021, The Tate Twins lost the OVW Tag Team Championships in a six team ladder match to Darkkloudz (Deget Bundlez and Eric Darkstorm) at OVW Reckoning.[19]
On July 23, 2022, at
Death Before Dishonor of 2022, The Boys and
Dalton Castle reunited and once again reclaimed the ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Championships by defeating The Righteous (
Vincent, Bateman, and Dutch) in a six man tag team match making the Tate Twins and Dalton Castle two-time ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Champions. They lost the titles at
Final Battle to
The Embassy, ending their reign at 140 days.[24]
On the February 29, 2024 episode of Ring of Honor Wrestling,
Johnny TV defeated Castle in a custody match for The Boys.[25] In the next three weeks, Castle would hound Johnny TV and his wife,
Taya Valkyrie, to return The Boys until Johnny TV revealed that he had lost them in a bear attack on a mountain.[26] On April 1, The Boys were released from AEW and ROH.[23] AEW President
Tony Khan revealed that the release was due to the twins not showing up for work on multiple occasions.[27] The Boys responded on social media, disputing Khan's claims that they had not shown up for work. They also claimed there had been little to no communication from the company regarding their travel arrangements.[28]
^Kreikenbohm, Philip (November 7, 2020).
"OVW Southern Tag Team Championship". Cagematch - The Internet Wrestling Database. Retrieved February 12, 2021.