22:4022:40, 13 April 2024diffhist−87
Mortimer Wheeler
several reasons not to include this: 1. we say he was "often criticized" for these things but in his time it appears he was not? perhaps he should have been but... 2: there isn't anything in the body of the article about harassment (accounts of dating his colleagues =/ harassment), 3. the accounts of his groping are unsubstantiated so we should at very least say "alleged", this presents it as if it's a fact: "criticized for bullying and sexually harassing..."
18:2118:21, 12 April 2024diffhist+543
Douglas Murray (author)
this is not a general consensus, but primarily a criticism levied against him by his political adversaries. If we say "is associated with" we need to say by who. And since this is not a clear consensus, we need to make clear that this is a disputed topic.
15:4815:48, 12 April 2024diffhist−468
Ghassan Hage
→Contributions: vast number of problems in this section, use of Wikipedia's voice to make the claims of the subject (ie. "highlights the importance of including the permanent processes...", "that became prominent", "an invitation to see racial/colonial", "highlights the critical anthropological task..."), also claims to a work being influential or being his "most important contribution to anthropology" would need to be referenced specifically.
15:2715:27, 12 April 2024diffhist−361
Abdelmalek Sayad
removing duplicated translations from bibliography and organizing by date, removing some more imperious claims to greatness from the lede (ie: "central to", "expert of the North-African community"), add back if there is a ref to support it.current
15:1115:11, 12 April 2024diffhist−514
Abdelmalek Sayad
→Sociology: a vast number of problems with this section, "double prism" is a nonsense term, much of it is written in Wikipedia's voice where it should be in the voice of the subject (ie "examined the difficult situation of migrants... forced into silence"), there would need to be a reference for the claim that he "renewed the approach of French sociology". Also claims to "importance" are so common through sociology articles that each ought to require a ref, and the last ref wasn't genuine.
09:5009:50, 25 March 2024diffhist−199
Go woke, go broke
"challenging the term's validity" is not neutral, that Barbie did well is a fact, how to interpret that fact should be up to the reader. likewise "challenged the premise of the slogan" is not neutral. "The phrase has seen mixed levels of success and applicability" is not exactly the right way to interpret the various analysis of it; analysts are not sure of the real impact, but that doesn't mean it's had "mixed success".
10:4010:40, 24 March 2024diffhist−10
Bill Burr
Bill Burr is not a producer. He has been an executive producer on a few projects, which is not the same thing as a producer, nor is it his profession.
08:2508:25, 24 March 2024diffhist+1,623
Haiti
→Caracol Industrial Park: completely re-writing this segment to reflect the reality today, this read as an advertisement for the Park, yet it in fact never materialized and failed the local Haitians that were displaced as a result of it!
23:4123:41, 17 March 2024diffhist−105
Thunderf00t
why are these here? nothing in the references for ties to "manosphere". He also was not part of the GamerGate controversy, making a video criticizing Sarkeesian surely doesn't qualify.current
8 March 2024
01:3601:36, 8 March 2024diffhist+17
Douglas Murray (author)
moving this from a statement about the subject to a statement made by others about the subject, as is the genuine context in the references.Tag: Reverted
04:5504:55, 2 December 2023diffhist−35
List of countries by literacy rate
I'm sure this will be reverted, but presenting no information is an improvement over presenting the misinformation of the North Korean state. There is significant enough concern with this in the talk page from others for this to be warranted.
12:0712:07, 22 February 2022diffhist−102
Jamal Edwards
He only wrote one ebook so cannot be considered an author, and directed only select few music videos, these two things weren't his professions. He was primarily an entrepreneur and DJ.
11:2611:26, 30 January 2022diffhist−1,224
Total Recall (1990 film)
→Government and corporations: In what way is a white protagonist saving the less well-off related to conservativism? Conservativism is a political desire to conserve institutions. All of this is the assessment of one largely unknown author, Jason P. Vest, and is clearly very uncharitable in its appraisal of the intentions of the filmmakers and is almost certainly an extremely minority opinion.Tag: Reverted
11:1111:11, 30 January 2022diffhist−2,047
Total Recall (1990 film)
This whole section is one criticism from a largely unknown Women's Studies author and would only be merited if multiple film critics have levied such complaints at it. There is nothing to justify "suggesting femininity is a source of moral or physical deformity" for example, which nobody could possibly take at face value as being either the aims of the writers or the views of critics of the film.Tag: Reverted