The United States West Coast cities of Seattle, Washington and Portland, Oregon have a city rivalry going back over a century. According to various authors, the Portland–Seattle city rivalry is comparable to that of Charlotte and Atlanta, Cincinnati and Columbus, Cleveland and Pittsburgh, San Antonio and Austin, St. Louis and Chicago, or San Francisco and Los Angeles. [1]: 315 [2]: 159 [3]: 297 Bases for competition include city sports teams, food and drink, regional economic dominance, and even preference for local volcanoes. [notes 1]
19th century origins
Maritime trade
The West Coast's 19th-century economy was initially based on maritime trade, at first dominated by sailing ships with the San Francisco–East Coast trade, [5]: 26 but then joined by Portland and Seattle as they began to develop their own regional resources and contribute to a national economic network, with "intercity rivalry on the Pacific Coast [that] mirrored rivalries that had grown between other groups of cities at earlier dates" such as Boston, Philadelphia and New York. [5]: 27
Railroads
The advent of transcontinental rail transportation completed the break from San Francisco's dominance and strengthened the economic rivalry between Portland and Seattle:
[D]uring the last two decades of the nineteenth century Seattle and Portland merchants took over most of the trade with the interior of the Pacific Northwest. With the completion of the Northern Pacific and Great Northern Railroads, the businessmen of the two cities extended their reach into the countryside ... As they broke the hold of San Franciscans over the Pacific Northwest, Seattle and Portland business leaders came into conflict with each other. Portland merchants viewed Seattleites as brash upstarts invading what should be their natural trade territory -- most of the Pacific Northwest, including eastern Washington.
— Mansel G. Blackford, The Lost Dream: Businessmen and City Planning on the Pacific Coast, 1890-1920 [5]: 28
The Portland Oregonian newspaper compared Seattle unfavorably to a peaceful Portland when anti-Chinese riots erupted in the 1880s. Portland prided itself as a "model of civility and culture" based on "slow but steady growth" compared to Seattle. [6]: 82
If Portland was a transplanted New England dowager, Seattle was a rambunctious frontiersman who grew rich through a combination of drive, optimism, wit, and occasional good fortune.
Cultural institutions and physical infrastructure like paved streets and electrification were built by each city in conscious competition with the other. [6]: 83
20th century
A work published in 1920 cited the Seattle–Portland rivalry as a "well known" intercity rivalry in a chapter on sectional rivalry in the American West, putting it alongside Minneapolis-St. Paul, Dallas-Fort Worth and San Francisco-Los Angeles. [2]: 159
Sports teams
Twentieth-century sports team rivalries between the two cities include the Portland Trail Blazers– Seattle SuperSonics basketball rivalry (until the Sonics left Seattle in 2008), and the Portland Timbers–Seattle Sounders rivalry, called by one writer "America's best soccer rivalry". [7] [8]
Urban expansion and growth
A scholarly book on the growth of the American West stated "Examination of urban growth in the Pacific Northwest confirms that urban rivalry remains a fruitful topic for historians ..." [1]: 314
21st century
Hipster culture
Local and national media frequently compare the hipster culture of the two cities. [9] [10] A Slate piece examined how the 2010s comedy television show Portlandia exposed the divide in Seattle and Portland's hipster culture. [11]
Cuisine
Seattle and Portland have a competitive food culture, with local pride taken in the superiority of each city's beer and brew pubs, donuts, and street food including food trucks. [12] [13]
According to Seattle Metropolitan magazine, "Portland's long been known as the tiny-restaurant innovator, Seattle the land of the big boys." [14]
Drug laws
After marijuana legalization in both states (via I-502 in Washington and Measure 91 in Oregon) a 2015 Stranger magazine cover story worried that "Washington's pot connoisseurs might [start] smoking Oregon marijuana" and "savvy marijuana tourists will be going to Portland instead of Seattle". [15] [notes 2]
Sports teams
The 2013 start of the National Women's Soccer League (NWSL) introduced new teams in both cities, and in 2022 the Portland Thorns-Seattle Reign rivalry was called "the NWSL's biggest rivalry" by Sports Illustrated writer Molly Geary. [16]
Notes
- ^ CNN pitted Seattle against Portland in a 2012 city rivalries report, in which the Seattle correspondent extolled the virtues of 14,410 foot Mount Rainier on the Seattle skyline over Portland's much smaller Mount Hood. Portland's correspondent claimed Portland's lack of a sales tax made it a better shopping destination. [4]
- ^ The above-the-fold cover blurb was "Oregon's laws are better than ours"
References
- ^ a b Nugent & Ridge 1999.
- ^ a b Westgard 1920.
- ^ Abbott 1992.
-
^
Preskar, Ashley (May 9, 2012),
Destination USA—Seattle vs. Portland: Seattle 'like floating through a dream',
CNN,
Sorry Portland, but as much as we love our sister to the south, the fact is that Seattle has everything we could want and more ... it really is the gem of the Pacific Northwest.
(see also Portland) - ^ a b c Blackford 1993.
- ^ a b c Edwards 1986.
- ^ Brewer, Jerry (July 9, 2011). "Seattle vs. Portland: Two rivals shooting at the same goal". The Seattle Times. Retrieved September 3, 2011.
- ^ Steckenberg, Dan (July 8, 2012), "Portland Timbers vs. Seattle Sounders: Examining America's Best Soccer Rivalry", Bleacher Report (blog)
- ^ Soper, Taylor (September 20, 2012), "Seattle vs. Portland: Which city is more hip?", GeekWire
- ^ Rolph, Amy (September 20, 2012), "Seattle vs. Portland: Which is more hipster?", Seattle Post-Intelligencer
- ^ Thomas, June (6 January 2012), "What Portlandia Says About Portland: A Longtime Seattlite's View", Slate
-
^
Cassandra Callan (September 25, 2012),
"Seattle v. Portland: Which City Is More Hipster?", Seattle Metropolitan,
Do our microbrews and tech geeks trump their food trucks and tattoos?
- ^ Maria L. La Ganga (February 22, 2015), "Seattle vs. Portland: A doughnut's-hole view", The Los Angeles Times
- ^ Robinson, Kathryn (April 24, 2015), "35 Essential Seattle Dining Experiences", Seattle Metropolitan
- ^ Kiley, Brendan (August 4, 2015), "By This Time Next Year, Washington's Pot Connoisseurs Might Be Smoking Oregon Marijuana", The Stranger
-
^ Geary, Molly (April 26, 2022).
"The 10 Greatest Games in NWSL's History".
Sports Illustrated. Retrieved May 6, 2023.
The stakes for the NWSL's biggest rivalry were never higher than they were for this 2018 playoff semifinal—the first time in 20 meetings (and still only time) that they would clash in the postseason.
- Books and papers
- Westgard, A.L. (1920), Tales of a pathfinder, Andrew B. Graham Company (Riypol Classics reprint), p. 159, ISBN 9785871772621
- Edwards, G. Thomas (1986), Experiences in a Promised Land: Essays in Pacific Northwest History, University of Washington Press, ISBN 9780295963280
- Blackford, Mansel G. (1993), The Lost Dream: Businessmen and City Planning on the Pacific Coast, 1890-1920, Ohio State University Press, p. 27, ISBN 9780814205891
- Abbott, Carl (August 1992), "Regional City and Network City: Portland and Seattle in the Twentieth Century", The Western Historical Quarterly, vol. 23, no. 3, pp. 293–32
- Nugent, Walter T. K.; Ridge, Martin, eds. (1999), The American West: the reader, Indiana University Press, ISBN 9780253335302
 | ||
