"Comment te dire adieu" (
English: "How to Say Goodbye to You") is a French adaptation of the song "It Hurts to Say Goodbye". It was originally recorded by
Françoise Hardy in 1968.
"It Hurts to Say Goodbye" was written by Arnold Goland, probably best known for his co-operation with
Phil Spector, and the American producer and songwriter Jacob "Jack" Gold (1921-1992). In 1966 it was recorded by
Margaret Whiting on her album The Wheel of Hurt.[3] In 1967 a release by
Vera Lynn reached No. 7 on Billboard's
Adult Contemporary chart.[4][5]
These versions were interpreted in the style of a
ballad, as was the first French version of the song with lyrics by Michèle Vendôme titled "Avant de dire adieu" which was released by
Ginette Reno on her 1967 album Quelqu'un à aimer. More beat driven were the instrumental interpretations by Brazil's
Walter Wanderley, dominated by the
Hammond organ he is known for, and the Frenchman
Caravelli, who focused more on
strings, both published in the same year. The Jack Gold Orchestra & Chorus version, which was in a style similar to the Caravelli release, made No. 28 on the BillboardEasy Listening charts in 1969.
Françoise Hardy heard an "American instrumental version" of the song and her manager asked
Serge Gainsbourg to provide suitable lyrics for it.[6] The resultant "Comment te dire adieu" was combined with an arrangement relatively closer to the Caravelli version and included on Hardy's
1968 album. Hardy also recorded the song in
Italian ("Il pretesto", 1968) and
German ("Was mach' ich ohne dich", 1970; collected in the album Träume, 1970.) The French lyrics are notable for their uncommon rhymes in "ex", within the subject of the song having a sense of "ex" as in "ex-boyfriend".
A German version with new lyrics, titled "Ich sage dir adieu", was released by veteran Greek-German singer
Vicky Leandros on her 2010 album Zeitlos.
Formats and track listings
French SP
Production Asparagus/
Disques Vogue/Vogue international industries (V.45-1552), 1968.
A-side: "Comment te dire adieu" ("It Hurts to Say Goodbye"), (ad. lyrics from Jack Gold:
Serge Gainsbourg / music: Arnold Goland, arr. S. Gainsbourg) – 2:25
B-side: "L'Anamour" (lyrics and music: Serge Gainsbourg) – 2:14
A-side: "Comment te dire adieu" ("It Hurts to Say Goodbye"), (ad. lyrics from Jack Gold: Serge Gainsbourg / music: Arnold Goland, arr. S. Gainsbourg) – 2:25
B-side: "La Mer, les étoiles et le vent" (lyrics and music: Françoise Hardy) – 1:50
French EP
Production Asparagus/disques Vogue/Vogue international industries (EPL 8652), 1968.
A1: "Comment te dire adieu" ("It Hurts to Say Goodbye"), (ad. lyrics from Jack Gold: Serge Gainsbourg / music: Arnold Goland, arr. S. Gainsbourg) – 2:25
A2: "Il vaut mieux une petite maison dans la main, qu'un grand château dans les nuages" (lyrics: Jean-Max Rivière / music: Gérard Bourgeois) – 2:23
The song was covered in 1989 by former
Bronski Beat and
Communards singer
Jimmy Somerville, as a duet with
June Miles-Kingston. It was a hit in the UK, reaching number 14 on the
UK Singles Chart, helping Somerville's solo career take off. David Giles of Music Week deemed Somerville's cover as "a slightly housey version", adding: "The sheer vivacity of his performance sends the record soaring off the turntable, and the orchestral bits topped with spoken French are out of this universe".[7]
In 2016, Belgian dance singer
Kate Ryan covered the song and released it as a stand-alone single via
iTunes on 24 June 2016, under
CNR MusicBelgium. It was produced by Yves Jongen a.k.a. Yves Gaillard and Soufiane Amrani "Amro".[23]
A music video accompanied the song, premiered via
YouTube on 29 June 2016.[24]
Other cover versions
1967:
Walter Wanderley, a Brazilian organist, recorded an instrumental cover of the song on his album Batucada
1967:
Caravelli and his orchestra released an instrumental version on the album Eloïse