The vanadium redox battery (VRB), also known as the vanadium flow battery (VFB) or vanadium redox flow battery (VRFB), is a type of rechargeable
flow battery. It employs
vanadium ions as
charge carriers.[5] The battery uses vanadium's ability to exist in a solution in four different
oxidation states to make a battery with a single electroactive element instead of two.[6] For several reasons, including their relative bulkiness, vanadium batteries are typically used for
grid energy storage, i.e., attached to power plants/electrical grids.[7]
Numerous companies and organizations are involved in funding and developing vanadium redox batteries.
History
Pissoort mentioned the possibility of VRFBs in the 1930s.[8] NASA researchers and Pellegri and Spaziante followed suit in the 1970s,[9] but neither was successful.
Maria Skyllas-Kazacos presented the first successful demonstration of an All-Vanadium Redox Flow Battery employing dissolved vanadium in a solution of
sulfuric acid in the 1980s.[10][11][12] Her design used sulfuric acid electrolytes, and was patented by the
University of New South Wales in Australia in 1986.[2]
One of the important breakthroughs achieved by Skyllas-Kazacos and coworkers was the development of a number of processes to produce vanadium electrolytes of over 1.5 M concentration using the lower cost, but insoluble vanadium pentoxide as starting material. These processes involved chemical and electrochemical dissolution and were patented by the University of NSW in 1989. During the 1990s the UNSW group conducted extensive research on membrane selection,[13][14] graphite felt activation,[15][16] conducting plastic bipolar electrode fabrication,[17] electrolyte characterisation and optimisation as well as modelling and simulation. Several 1-5 kW VFB prototype batteries were assembled and field tested in a Solar House in Thailand and in an electric golf cart at UNSW.[18]
The UNSW All-Vanadium Redox Flow Battery patents and technology were licensed to Mitsubishi Chemical Corporation and Kashima-Kita Electric Power Corporation in the mid-1990s and subsequently acquired by Sumitomo Electric Industries where extensive field testing was conducted in a wide range of applications in the late 1990s and early 2000s.[19]
In order to extend the operating temperature range of the battery and prevent precipitation of vanadium in the electrolyte at temperatures above 40oC in the case of V(V), or below 10oC in case of the negative half-cell solution, Skyllas-Kazacos and coworkers tested hundreds of organic and inorganic additives as potential precipitation inhibitors. They discovered that inorganic phosphate and ammonium compounds were effective in inhibiting precipitation of 2 M vanadium solutions in both the negative and positive half-cell at temperatures of 5 and 45 °C respectively and ammonium phosphate was selected as the most effective stabilising agent. Ammonium and phosphate additives were used to prepare and test a 3 M vanadium electrolyte in a flow cell with excellent results.[19]
Advantages and disadvantages
Advantages
VRFBs' main advantages over other types of battery:[21]
no limit on energy capacity
can remain discharged indefinitely without damage
mixing electrolytes causes no permanent damage
single charge state across the electrolytes avoids capacity degradation
safe, non-flammable aqueous electrolyte
no noise or emissions
battery modules can be added to meet demand
wide operating temperature range including passive cooling[22][23]
long charge/discharge cycle lives: 15,000-20,000 cycles and 10–20 years.
relatively poor energy-to-volume ratio compared to standard
storage batteries
having moving parts in the pumps that produce the flow of electrolyte solution
toxicity of vanadium (V) compounds.
Materials
A vanadium redox battery consists of an assembly of power
cells in which two electrolytes are separated by a
proton exchange membrane. The electrodes in a VRB cell are carbon based. The most common types are carbon felt, carbon paper, carbon cloth, graphite felt, and
carbon nanotubes.[25][26][27] The carbon-based electrode exhibits limited catalytic activity when interacting with vanadium species. To enhance its catalytic performance, several approaches have been employed, including thermal treatment, acid treatment, electrochemical modification, and the incorporation of catalysts.
[28][29]
Both electrolytes are
vanadium-based. The electrolyte in the positive half-cells contains VO2+ and VO2+ ions, while the electrolyte in the negative half-cells consists of V3+ and V2+ ions. The electrolytes can be prepared by several processes, including electrolytically dissolving
vanadium pentoxide (V2O5) in
sulfuric acid (H2SO4).[30] The solution is strongly acidic in use.
The most common membrane material is perfluorinated
sulfonic acid (PFSA or Nafion). However, vanadium ions can penetrate a PFSA membrane and destabilize the cell.[31] A 2021 study found that penetration is reduced with hybrid sheets made by growing
tungsten trioxide nanoparticles on the surface of single-layered graphene oxide sheets. These hybrid sheets are then embedded into a sandwich structured PFSA membrane reinforced with
polytetrafluoroethylene (Teflon). The nanoparticles also promote proton transport, offering high
Coulombic efficiency and
energy efficiency of more than 98.1 percent and 88.9 percent, respectively.[32]
Other useful properties of vanadium flow batteries are their fast response to changing loads and their overload capacities. They can achieve a response time of under half a millisecond for a 100% load change, and allow overloads of as much as 400% for 10 seconds. Response time is limited mostly by the electrical equipment. Unless specifically designed for colder or warmer climates, most sulfuric acid-based vanadium batteries work between about 10 and 40 °C. Below that temperature range, the ion-infused sulfuric acid crystallizes.[36] Round trip efficiency in practical applications is around 70–80%.[37]
Proposed improvements
The original VRFB design by
Skyllas-Kazacos employed
sulfate (added as vanadium sulfate(s) and sulfuric acid) as the only anion in VRFB solutions, which limited the maximum vanadium concentration to 1.7 M of vanadium ions.[38] In the 1990s, Skyllas-Kazacos discovered the use of ammonium phosphate and other inorganic compounds as precipitation inhibitors to stabilise 2 M vanadium solutions over a temperature range of 5 to 45 oC and a Stabilising Agent patent was filed by UNSW in 1993. This discovery was largely overlooked however and in around 2010 a team from
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory proposed a mixed sulfate-
chloride electrolyte, that allowed for the use in VRFBs solutions with the vanadium concentration of 2.5 M over a whole temperature range between −20 and +50 °C.[39][40] Based on the standard equilibrium potential of the V5+/V4+ couple it is expected to oxidize chloride, and for this reason chloride solutions were avoided in earlier VRFB studies. The surprising oxidative stability (albeit only at the state of charge below ca. 80%) of V5+ solutions in the presence of chloride was explained on the basis of activity coefficients.[41] Many researchers explain the increased stability of V(V) at elevated temperatures by the higher proton concentration in the mixed acid electrolyte that shifts the thermal precipitation equilibrium of V(V) away from V2O5. Nevertheless, because of a high vapor pressure of HCl solutions and the possibility of chlorine generation during charging, such mixed electrolytes have not been widely adopted.[42]
Another variation is the use of vanadium bromide salts. Since the redox potential of Br2/2Br- couple is more negative than that of V5+/V4+, the positive electrode operates via the
bromine process.[43] However, due to problems with volatility and corrosivity of Br2, they did not gain much popularity (see
zinc-bromine battery for a similar problem). A
vanadium/
cerium flow battery has also been proposed .[44]
Specific energy and energy density
VRBs achieve a specific energy of about 20 Wh/kg (72 kJ/kg) of electrolyte. Precipitation inhibitors can increase the density to about 35 Wh/kg (126 kJ/kg), with higher densities possible by controlling the electrolyte temperature. The
specific energy is low compared to other
rechargeable battery types (e.g., lead–acid, 30–40 Wh/kg (108–144 kJ/kg); and lithium ion, 80–200 Wh/kg (288–720 kJ/kg)).[citation needed]
Applications
VRFBs' large potential capacity may be best-suited to buffer the irregular output of utility-scale wind and solar systems.[21]
Their reduced self-discharge makes them potentially appropriate in applications that require long-term energy storage with little maintenance—as in military equipment, such as the sensor components of the
GATOR mine system.[45][21]
Companies funding or developing vanadium redox batteries
Companies funding or developing vanadium redox batteries include
Sumitomo Electric Industries,[60] CellCube (Enerox),[61]UniEnergy Technologies,[62] StorEn Technologies[63][64] in Australia, Largo Energy[65] and Ashlawn Energy[66] in the United States; H2 in Gyeryong-si, South Korea;[67] Renewable Energy Dynamics Technology,[68] Invinity Energy Systems[69] in the United Kingdom, VoltStorage[70] and Schmalz[71][72] in Europe; Prudent Energy[73] in China; Australian Vanadium, CellCube and North Harbour Clean Energy[74][75] in Australia; Yadlamalka Energy Trust and Invinity Energy Systems[76][77] in Australia; EverFlow Energy JV SABIC SCHMID Group in Saudi Arabia[78] and Bushveld Minerals in South Africa.[79]
^Alotto, P.; Guarnieri, M.; Moro, F. (2014). "Redox Flow Batteries for the storage of renewable energy: a review". Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews. 29: 325–335.
doi:
10.1016/j.rser.2013.08.001.
hdl:
11577/2682306.
^Chieng, S.C.; Kazacos, M.; Skyllas-Kazacos, M. (1992). "Preparation and evaluation of composite membrane for vanadium redox battery applications". Journal of Power Sources. 39 (1): 11–19.
Bibcode:
1992JPS....39...11C.
doi:
10.1016/0378-7753(92)85002-R.
^Chieng, S.C.; Kazacos, M.; Skyllas-Kazacos, M. (16 December 1992). "Modification of Daramic, microporous separator, for redox flow battery applications". Journal of Membrane Science. 75 (1–2): 81–91.
doi:
10.1016/0376-7388(92)80008-8.
^Sun, B.; Skyllas-Kazacos, M. (June 1992). "Modification of graphite electrode materials for vanadium redox flow battery application—I. Thermal treatment". Electrochimica Acta. 37 (7): 1253–1260.
doi:
10.1016/0013-4686(92)85064-R.
^Sun, Bianting; Skyllas-Kazacos, Maria (October 1992). "Chemical modification of graphite electrode materials for vanadium redox flow battery application—part II. Acid treatments". Electrochimica Acta. 37 (13): 2459–2465.
doi:
10.1016/0013-4686(92)87084-D.
^Zhong, S.; Kazacos, M.; Burford, R.P.; Skyllas-Kazacos, M. (October 1991). "Fabrication and activation studies of conducting plastic composite electrodes for redox cells". Journal of Power Sources. 36 (1): 29–43.
Bibcode:
1991JPS....36...29Z.
doi:
10.1016/0378-7753(91)80042-V.
^Tang, Ao; McCann, John; Bao, Jie; Skyllas-Kazacos, Maria (November 2013). "Investigation of the effect of shunt current on battery efficiency and stack temperature in vanadium redox flow battery". Journal of Power Sources. 242: 349–356.
Bibcode:
2013JPS...242..349T.
doi:
10.1016/j.jpowsour.2013.05.079.
^Spagnuolo, G.; Petrone, G.; Mattavelli, P.; Guarnieri, M. (2016). "Vanadium Redox Flow Batteries: Potentials and Challenges of an Emerging Storage Technology". IEEE Industrial Electronics Magazine. 10 (4): 20–31.
doi:
10.1109/MIE.2016.2611760.
hdl:11577/3217695.
S2CID28206437.
^Mustafa, Ibrahim; Lopez, Ivan; Younes, Hammad; Susantyoko, Rahmat Agung; Al-Rub, Rashid Abu; Almheiri, Saif (March 2017). "Fabrication of Freestanding Sheets of Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes (Buckypapers) for Vanadium Redox Flow Batteries and Effects of Fabrication Variables on Electrochemical Performance". Electrochimica Acta. 230: 222–235.
doi:
10.1016/j.electacta.2017.01.186.
ISSN0013-4686.
^Mustafa, Ibrahim; Bamgbopa, Musbaudeen O.; Alraeesi, Eman; Shao-Horn, Yang; Sun, Hong; Almheiri, Saif (1 January 2017). "Insights on the Electrochemical Activity of Porous Carbonaceous Electrodes in Non-Aqueous Vanadium Redox Flow Batteries". Journal of the Electrochemical Society. 164 (14): A3673–A3683.
doi:
10.1149/2.0621714jes.
hdl:1721.1/134874.
ISSN0013-4651.
^Mustafa, Ibrahim; Al Shehhi, Asma; Al Hammadi, Ayoob; Susantyoko, Rahmat; Palmisano, Giovanni; Almheiri, Saif (May 2018). "Effects of carbonaceous impurities on the electrochemical activity of multiwalled carbon nanotube electrodes for vanadium redox flow batteries". Carbon. 131: 47–59.
doi:
10.1016/j.carbon.2018.01.069.
ISSN0008-6223.
^Revankar, Shripad T. (2019). "Chapter 6. Chemical Energy Storage". In Bindra, Hitesh & Revankar, Shripad (eds.). Storage and Hybridization of Nuclear Energy – Techno-economic Integration of Renewable and Nuclear Energy. London: Academic Press. pp. 177–227.
doi:
10.1016/B978-0-12-813975-2.00006-5.
ISBN9780128139752.
S2CID189154686.
^M. Skyllas-Kazacos, M. Rychcik and G. Robins Robert, "All vanadium redox battery." 1986AU-0055562 1986-04-02.
M. Skyllas-Kazacos, "All-vanadium redox battery and additives." 1988WO-AU00472 1988-12-091989AU-0028153 1989-12-09.
M. Skyllas-Kazacos, M. Kazacos and C. Mcdermott Rodney John, "Vanadium charging cell and vanadium dual battery system." 1989AU-0028152 1989-12-09.
M. Kazacos and S. Kazacos Maria, "High energy density vanadium electrolyte solutions, methods of preparation thereof and all-vanadium redox cells and batteries containing high energy vanadium electrolyte solutions." 1996AT-0911853T 1996-05-031996AU-0054914 1996-05-031996US-08945869 1996-05-031996WO-AU00268 1996-05-031996NZ-0306364 1996-05-031996ES-0911853T 1996-05-031996EP-0911853 1996-05-031996DE-6030298 1996-05-031996CA-2220075 1996-05-031998HK-0110321 1998-08-312002US-10226751 2002-08-22
^Li, L.; Kim, S.; Wang, W.; Vijayakumar, M.; Nie, Z.; Chen, B.; Zhang, J.; Xia, G.; Hu, J.; Graff, G.; Liu, J.; Yang, Z. (2011). "A stable vanadium redox-flow battery with high energy density for large-scale energy storage". Advanced Energy Materials. 1 (3): 394–400.
doi:
10.1002/aenm.201100008.
S2CID33277301.
^Yang, Y.; Zhang, Y.; Tang, L.; Liu, T.; Huang, J.; Peng, S.; Yang, X. (September 2019). "Investigations on physicochemical properties and electrochemical performance of sulfate-chloride mixed acid electrolyte for vanadium redox flow battery". Journal of Power Sources. 434: Article 226719.
Bibcode:
2019JPS...43426719Y.
doi:
10.1016/j.jpowsour.2019.226719.
S2CID197352614.
^Vafiadis, Helen; Skyllas-Kazacos, Maria (2006). "Evaluation of membranes for the novel vanadium bromine redox flow cell". Journal of Membrane Science. 279 (1–2): 394–402.
doi:
10.1016/j.memsci.2005.12.028.