Producer
Arthur Freed wanted to create a film along the lines of the
Ziegfeld FolliesBroadway shows, and so, the film is composed of a sequence of unrelated lavish musical numbers and comedy sketches. Some of them, such as Pay the Two Dollars, originated in George White's Scandals.[6] Filmed in 1944 and 1945,[7] it was released in 1946 to considerable critical and box-office success.
The movie opens with the camera panning over a Heaven somewhere beyond the sky. The residences of great showmen gone to their eternal reward are shown:
Shakespeare, whose home looks like the
Globe Theater;
P.T.Barnum, whose residence in the afterlife resembles a circus Big Top; and
Florenz Ziegfeld, whose home's entrance is reminiscent of the theater where he staged the Ziegfeld Follies on Broadway.
Talking to the audience, Ziegfeld guides the viewers along a wall with three-dimensional paintings or shadow boxes containing dolls that look like the stars he cast in his Follies over the years. The film dissolves into a
stop-motion puppet sequence as Ziegfeld provides a
voice-over of the opening of one of his shows.
Following this, he steps out onto a balcony, musing how he wishes he could stage just one more Follies, with current and past stars in the cast. A Higher Power causes a cigar-sized crayon and a sheet of parchment to appear, and Ziegfeld begins to write. As he does so, the skits and performance numbers appear on the screen.
Cast
Fred Astaire as Fred Astaire/Raffles in “This Heart of Mine”/Tai Long in “Limehouse Blues”/A Gentleman in “The Babbit and the Bromide”
Dance director was
Robert Alton, Astaire's second-most-frequent choreographic collaborator after
Hermes Pan. All of Astaire's numbers were directed by
Vincente Minnelli. The movie's opening featured
William Powell as Ziegfeld, who does the prologue.
"Here's to the Girls/"Bring on the Wonderful Men": by
Roger Edens and Arthur Freed. Sung by Astaire with a short solo dance by
Cyd Charisse, followed by
Lucille Ball cracking a whip over eight chorus-girl panthers, and finally
Virginia O'Brien spoofs the previous scene by singing "Bring On Those Wonderful Men".
Van Johnson,
Fred MacMurray and
Mischa Auer are cited in the song as men she finds interesting.
"
This Heart of Mine": classic
standard by
Harry Warren and Arthur Freed and written specially for Astaire who sings it to Bremer and then leads her in an extravagantly romantic dance of seduction and power-play. The choreography integrates rotating floors, concealed treadmills and swirling dance motifs.
"
Limehouse Blues": conceived as a "dramatic pantomime" with Astaire as a proud but poverty-stricken Chinese labourer whose infatuation with the unattainable Bremer leads to tragedy. The story serves as bookends for a dream ballet inspired by Chinese dance motifs in a vast and
extravagant setting, as both Astaire and Bremer perform in
yellowface.
"The Great Lady Has an Interview": written by
Kay Thompson and
Roger Edens originally for
Greer Garson (she turned it down).
Judy Garland spoofs a movie star who can only be cast in
Oscar-winning dramas, but wants to play "sexy" roles (a la
Greer Garson, or
Katharine Hepburn) giving an interview to dancing reporters about "her next picture": a bio-pic of Madame Cremantante (the "inventor of the
safety pin"). Originally to be directed by Garland's friend
Charles Walters, Vincente Minnelli ended up directing the sequence (the two were dating at the time), and Walters was reassigned as choreographer.
"The Babbitt and the Bromide": Astaire and Kelly team up in a comedy song and dance challenge in three sections, to music and lyrics by
George and
Ira Gershwin. All choreography was by Astaire (third section) and Kelly (sections one and two). This was the only time Astaire and Kelly appeared on screen together in their prime. In spite of efforts by Freed and Minnelli, the two would not partner again on film until That's Entertainment, Part II in 1976.
"There's Beauty Everywhere": originally filmed as a balletic finale with tenor
James Melton singing and Fred Astaire, Cyd Charisse, and Lucille Bremer dancing in a melange of soap bubbles. But when the bubble machine malfunctioned (leaving only a fragment of the number filmed) and the formula flowed into the hallways of the soundstage, the number had to be restaged and the Astaire and Bremer part of this number was cut out altogether." Kathryn Grayson replaced Melton. Segments of the "bubble dance" with Charisse remain in the final film.
Surviving outtake of introduction
An early concept was to have the film introduced by a
stop motion animated puppet of
Leo the Lion. Although cut before release, this
outtake footage survives today.[10]
Reception
The New York Times: "The film's best numbers are a couple of comedy skits, especially one done by
Red Skelton.
Fanny Brice plays a
Bronx hausfrau quite funnily. Judy Garland is also amusing as a movie queen giving an interview. Ziegfeld Follies is entertaining – and that's what it's meant to be!" (
Bosley Crowther).
Newsweek: "At least three of the numbers would highlight any review on stage and screen. In A Great Lady has an Interview, Judy Garland, with six leading men, displays an unexpected flair for occupational satire. With Numbers PleaseKeenan Wynn demonstrates, once again, that he is one of Hollywood's foremost comedians. But the dance act for the archives is The Babbitt and the Bromide Fred Astaire and Gene Kelly trade taps and double-takes to a photo finish."[11]
Box office
According to MGM records, the film earned $3,569,000 in the US and Canada, and $1,775,000 elsewhere - but because of its large cost, it incurred a loss to the studio of $269,000.[1][12]
Accolades
1947 Cannes Film Festival Best Musical Comedy (Prix de la meilleure comédie musicale) Won[13]