| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| 1. FC Lokomotive Leipzig |
rename all |
August 13
|
|
Category:1916 U.S. ballet premieres |
Merge |
August 23
|
|
Category:Abandoned cities in the Faroe Islands |
rename to
Category:Former populated places in the Faroe Islands. |
August 8
|
|
Category:Actors portrayed posthumously |
delete. — |
August 30
|
|
Category:Actress Damehoods |
Rename |
August 23
|
|
Category:African Methodist Episcopal Churches |
speedy rename per speedy criteria C2A and per category creator's consent |
August 29
|
|
Category:African-American culture |
keep. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Agricultural beneficial insects |
rename, same condition as the above discussion |
August 1
|
|
Category:Air defense artillery brigades of the United States Army and Category:Air Defense Artillery Brigades of the United States Army |
merge to
Category:Air Defense Artillery Brigades of the United States Army |
August 12
|
|
Category:Air Dispersion Model articles |
delete. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Air Squadron Member |
Delete |
August 23
|
|
Category:Ajith Kumar |
delete |
August 9
|
| Alberta municipal districts |
rename/merge all |
August 2
|
|
Category:Album types |
Keep and clean up |
August 11
|
|
Category:Albums produced by A.B. Quintanilla |
rename |
August 5
|
|
Category:Allis-Chalmers |
rename |
August 17
|
|
Category:Alternative energy economics |
rename to
Category:Alternative energy economy. These articles are all about economies, not economics |
August 4
|
|
Category:America's Next Top Model spin-offs |
rename |
August 4
|
|
Category:American architects by religion |
delete all |
August 18
|
|
Category:American baseball players by home state |
rename |
August 4
|
|
Category:American beauty pageant winners |
keep |
August 3
|
|
Category:American Christian sportspeople |
delete all |
August 7
|
|
Category:American Episcopalian architects |
merge. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:American German language newspapers |
rename. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:American servicemembers discharged for homosexuality |
rename. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Anatolian states in middle ages |
merge to
States in medieval Anatolia |
August 16
|
|
Category:Ancient Syria |
merge |
August 2
|
|
Category:Anti-Islam activists |
delete. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Applications of Telecommunication |
merge. — |
August 20
|
|
Category:Aquarium |
Rename per nom |
August 9
|
|
Category:Archie comic book covers |
merge |
August 5
|
|
Category:Archie Comics locations |
double upmerge |
August 5
|
|
Category:Armored Core Games |
rename to
Category:Armored Core. |
August 20
|
|
Category:Art Deco buildings in Connecticut |
delete, noting that the category is empty. — |
August 17
|
|
Category:Articles by Hunter S. Thompson |
rename. — |
August 15
|
|
Category:Atheist and agnostic heads of government |
Delete |
August 23
|
|
Category:Atomic Age of Comic Books |
delete. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:ATP Volvo International |
rename. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Australian Formula Two Championship drivers |
Rename to
Category:Australian Formula 2 Championship drivers |
August 19
|
|
Category:Australian Schoolboy players |
delete all |
August 8
|
|
Category:Avex albums |
rename |
August 3
|
|
Category:Aviation in Alaska |
keep. — |
August 25
|
| Awards and trophies |
rename all |
August 11
|
|
Category:Ballads by genre |
Keep |
August 20
|
|
Category:BAO albums |
rename |
August 3
|
|
Category:Ben Cardin |
delete. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Best engineering colleges in india |
DELETE,
WP:SNOW. |
August 20
|
|
Category:Big Boy |
Rename |
August 8
|
|
Category:Bioethanol producers |
Rename to
Category:Alcohol fuel producers |
August 9
|
|
Category:Biographies (books) about writers |
Rename as proposed |
August 21
|
|
Category:Biographies of multiple people |
Rename per nom |
August 22
|
| Biography articles without infoboxes |
rename. — |
August 26
|
|
Category:Biomechanics of intrinsic gravity |
speedy deleted
WP:CSD#C1 as a category unpopulated for over four days |
August 4
|
|
Category:Biota naturalised in Australia |
keep |
August 1
|
|
Category:Black sea western basins |
delete (category was empty at closing, BTW). |
August 10
|
|
Category:Blackouts |
rename to
Category:Electric power blackouts. — |
August 20
|
|
Category:British Superbike riders |
rename. — |
August 20
|
|
Category:British West India officers |
merge to
Category:West India Regiment officers. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Building projects |
Rename as proposed |
August 22
|
|
Category:Bulldogs Rugby League Football Club |
rename all |
August 6
|
|
Category:Business qualifications |
keep. — |
August 13
|
| Byzantine people |
rename both. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Canadian BDS Airplay number-one singles |
delete. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:Canadian Country Singles number-one singles |
delete both. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Carbon emissions trading schemes in the European Union |
merge as nominated, without prejudice to restructuring in the future. |
August 4
|
| Cartel (band) |
rename |
August 25
|
|
Category:Cedars-Sinai Medical Center |
delete |
August 17
|
|
Category:Celebrities with Criminal Records |
speedy deleted as re-created material (and per
WP:SNOW, for that matter): has been deleted squillions of times under various names |
August 20
|
| CfdAustralianCityCategories |
do not rename. The result for some of the specific categories nominated below might be better classified as a "no consensus", since not everyone's opposition applied to all the categories. If any of those below are renominated, I suggest having a separate CFD for each individual category to avoid the problem of a user favouring one change but opposing another. |
August 1
|
|
Category:Chairpersons of MMDA |
rename. — |
August 30
|
|
Category:Charities accused of ties to terrorism |
delete |
August 6
|
|
Category:Children of Elijah Muhammad |
delete. — |
August 17
|
|
Category:Chill-out drinks |
rename to
Category:Anti-energy drinks, a term which seems to be gaining traction |
August 16
|
|
Category:Chorus frogs |
merge
Category:Pseudacris into
Category:Chorus frogs |
August 13
|
|
Category:Christian anti-Zionism |
delete. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Cities in Cluj County |
rename as modified. — |
August 17
|
|
Category:Cities in Romania |
rename to
Category:Municipalities of Romania. — |
August 17
|
|
Category:Clarion Writers' Workshop |
keep. — |
August 27
|
|
Category:Classified documents |
keep. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:Coal mining companies of the United States |
merge |
August 4
|
|
Category:Cocktails with coffee liqueur |
keep |
August 3
|
|
Category:College and university band directors |
Rename |
August 22
|
|
Category:College football seasons with Heisman Trophy winner |
delete. — |
August 24
|
|
Category:College sports teams in the United States by college |
rename |
August 1
|
|
Category:Colleges and Universities on Long Island |
rename. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Columbia University Teachers College alumni |
rename. — |
August 30
|
|
Category:Compressed air vehicle manufacturers |
merge to
Category:Compressed air power and
Category:Vehicle manufacturing companies. |
August 4
|
|
Category:Contentious issues about the Boy Scouts of America |
Rename to
Category:Boy Scouts of America case law |
August 23
|
|
Category:Contributors to Bloggingheads.tv |
delete |
August 14
|
|
Category:Cosmetic chemicals |
rename |
August 18
|
|
Category:Countrywide Classic |
delete |
August 3
|
|
Category:Covers from Batman related titles |
Delete. (There category has been emptied.) |
August 10
|
|
Category:Critical Access Hospitals in the United States |
delete |
August 17
|
|
Category:Current sports as of August 2010 |
delete. These categories can be uncontroversially deleted either under
C1 or
G6. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Cuttings |
rename |
August 23
|
| Córdoba, Argentina (city) |
rename. |
August 5
|
|
Category:Dalit Monuments |
Rename, with no consensus reached towards deletion, and no prejudice against a following renomination towards deletion |
August 17
|
|
Category:Dalla |
Delete |
August 10
|
|
Category:Darius Danesh albums |
rename |
August 17
|
|
Category:Darius Danesh songs |
rename |
August 17
|
|
Category:Deborah Cox |
no consensus. If this discussion is any indication, after many years of this there still seems to be little consensus on "how much is enough" to justify eponymous categories for people. |
August 13
|
|
Category:Diamonds Are Forever (film) |
delete. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:DisneyMania albums |
rename |
August 7
|
|
Category:Drag queens |
consensus not to rename/merge |
August 12
|
|
Category:Dungeon graduates |
delete. — |
August 27
|
| E-mail |
rename all. — |
August 24
|
|
Category:Eclipse |
rename |
August 5
|
|
Category:Economic documentaries |
rename |
August 6
|
|
Category:Electric grid interconnections |
Keep |
August 19
|
|
Category:Electric vehicle motors |
rename to
Category:Wheel hub motors (adding an "s" to the suggested target) |
August 2
|
|
Category:Electricity generation |
rename. — |
August 20
|
|
Category:Electricity generators of the United Kingdom |
rename/merge as nominated |
August 2
|
|
Category:Electricity sector by country |
rename to
Category:Electric power by country. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Electricity transmission |
rename both — |
August 20
|
| Electricity |
rename all. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:Energy feedstocks |
merge |
August 4
|
|
Category:Energy in Connacht |
delete. — |
August 22
|
|
Category:Entertainers killed in airplane crashes |
Delete. |
August 23
|
|
Category:Eponymous categories |
no consensus. Lots of good points were made, but I can't mine a consensus to take any specific actions based on it. Now can some people help remove the CFD tag from all these categories? |
August 12
|
|
Category:Equatorial Guinea national football teams |
merge to
Category:Equatorial Guinea national football team. Also moving
Category:Equatorial Guinea women's national football teams to
Category:Equatorial Guinea women's national football team |
August 12
|
|
Category:Essex |
no consensus |
August 1
|
| Estonian politicians by party |
rename all |
August 4
|
|
Category:European Greens–European Free Alliance |
rename |
August 6
|
|
Category:Execration text places |
Listify to
List of Execration text places |
August 19
|
|
Category:Expatriate racecar drivers in the United States |
delete |
August 7
|
|
Category:Field hockey at the Commonwealth Games |
reverse merge. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Filmed accidental deaths |
keep |
August 23
|
|
Category:Films distributed by Madman Films |
delete all |
August 12
|
|
Category:Films set in San Fernando Valley |
rename. — |
August 24
|
|
Category:Financial aid |
rename |
August 12
|
| Finnish politicians |
rename. |
August 4
|
|
Category:First world countries |
delete |
August 6
|
|
Category:Flying Nun Records artists' albums |
delete |
August 7
|
|
Category:''Foo'' Army |
delete all. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Foreign-language newspapers published in the United States |
rename to
Category:Non-English-language newspapers published in the United States. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Former anti-Islam activists |
delete |
August 12
|
|
Category:Former drinking water reservoirs |
delete. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Formerly banned users |
delete request from creator. There was also strong support for deletion |
August 19
|
|
Category:Fossil fuel phase out |
delete |
August 4
|
|
Category:Fossil-fuel disasters |
delete |
August 4
|
|
Category:Four-String Banjo Hall of Fame Inductee |
delete. — |
August 17
|
|
Category:Fred Perry |
delete. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:French Socialist Party |
rename all |
August 7
|
|
Category:Frontier rebellion 1897-1899 |
rename |
August 2
|
|
Category:Gazette video releases |
rename. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Geothermal energy |
reverse merge. |
August 5
|
|
Category:GOD albums |
rename |
August 3
|
| Greek politicians |
rename all |
August 4
|
|
Category:Green electricity by country |
delete. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Green energy certification schemes |
rename. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:Harmony Records albums |
delete |
August 17
|
|
Category:Harris County Housing Authority, Texas |
Speedy deleted as spam |
August 23
|
|
Category:Harrisongs |
Delete |
August 19
|
|
Category:Hart |
Rename to
Category:Places in Hart (district). The deals with the disambiguation. I'm taking it on faith that |
August 23
|
|
Category:Health issues in pregnancy |
keep. — |
August 26
|
|
Category:Heavy metal instrumentals |
merge. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Hebrew giants |
Merge to
Category:Hebrew Bible people and
Category:Giants |
August 30
|
|
Category:Hemiphractinae |
rename, invoking
WP:SILENCE. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Hiram, Maine |
merge |
August 1
|
|
Category:Holdings of the Bibliothèque nationale de France |
Merge to
Category:Bibliothèque nationale de France collections. There is no consensus for the name of the category. Probably, a separate discussion should be held in order to find out a consensus as to how all such categories should be named |
August 19
|
|
Category:Hotels by year of establishment |
No consensus. The problem of underpopulation should be addressed before any future nomination |
August 13
|
|
Category:Humane societies |
rename and merge as nominated. "Organisations" will be used for the UK category instead of "organizations" for obvious reasons. — |
August 20
|
|
Category:Hybrid electric trucks |
merge |
August 4
|
|
Category:Hybrid electric vehicle manufacturers |
merge |
August 1
|
|
Category:Igbo writers by genre |
delete. — |
August 30
|
|
Category:Incomplete buildings and structures |
rename. — |
August 24
|
|
Category:Indian national agencies |
 Relisted on
Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2010_September_7 |
August 30
|
|
Category:Indian submissions for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film |
delete. — |
August 27
|
|
Category:Indonesian culture claimed by Malaysia |
delete. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:International venture capital firms |
delete all |
August 5
|
|
Category:Iona albums |
rename |
August 2
|
|
Category:IONA debating competitions |
delete; because somehow, this category is totally empty. |
August 2
|
|
Category:Israeli people by ethnic or national origin |
speedy rename based on the
19 July CFD result |
August 22
|
|
Category:Israeli people wounded in war |
delete |
August 13
|
| Ithomiinae |
C1 delete |
August 11
|
|
Category:Jihad satire |
delete. — |
August 30
|
|
Category:Junior College men's basketball players |
Rename to
Category:Junior college men's basketball players in the United States |
August 9
|
|
Category:Kentucky architecture and infrastructure |
rename. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:King Records albums |
rename |
August 3
|
|
Category:Kipling stories with 'uneducated' characters |
Delete |
August 23
|
|
Category:Kipling stories with characters from the administrative class |
delete. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Kipling stories with Strickland |
Upmkerge into
Category:Short stories by Rudyard Kipling |
August 16
|
|
Category:Kipling stories with supernatural elements |
merge. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Kit vehicles |
keep. I also put this under
Category:Do it yourself |
August 2
|
|
Category:Knights First Class of the Order of the Zähringer Lion |
No consensus |
August 24
|
|
Category:Knights First Class of the Order of the Zähringer Lion |
Relisted at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 August 24#Category:Knights First Class of the Order of the Zähringer Lion. — |
August 9
|
|
Category:Knights Second Class of the Order of the Zähringer Lion |
No consensus |
August 24
|
|
Category:Knights Second Class of the Order of the Zähringer Lion |
Relisted at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 August 24#Category:Knights Second Class of the Order of the Zähringer Lion. — |
August 9
|
|
Category:Knox College alumni |
Rename per nom |
August 9
|
|
Category:Kokomo |
Phoenix, Arizona all the way to Tacoma, Philadelphia, Atlanta, delete |
August 2
|
|
Category:Korean-language education and Category:Korean language education |
Merge
Category:Korean language education into
Category:Korean-language education |
August 12
|
|
Category:Languages included on the Voyager Golden Record |
delete. — |
August 22
|
|
Category:Las Vegas Stars players |
rename. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Laws of Shabbat |
keep |
August 6
|
|
Category:Lennon/McCartney songs not originally released by The Beatles |
delete. |
August 16
|
|
Category:Leptochilus |
merge. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Liberty Caucus members |
delete. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Light sockets |
delete, noting that the category is empty. — |
August 17
|
|
Category:List of People by name Sunil |
Delete |
August 23
|
|
Category:Lists of Mosques by Arab cities |
rename. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Little Poland |
rename |
August 12
|
|
Category:Live CD |
rename to
Category:Operating system distributions bootable from read-only media. — |
August 13
|
|
Category:Living animals |
delete |
August 6
|
|
Category:M.o.v.e. albums |
rename |
August 3
|
| [[:Category:Mad Men (TV series) --> Category:Mad Men episodes]] |
Rename as proposed |
August 27
|
| [[:Category:Mad Men (TV series) --> Category:Mad Men episodes]] |
Relisted at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 August 27#Category:Mad Men (TV series) --> Category:Mad Men episodes. — |
August 17
|
|
Category:Male porn directors |
merge
Category:Male porn directors as nominated, rename
Category:Female porn directors to
Category:Female directors of pornographic films. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Manicouagan hydroelectric project |
rename. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:Marimba players |
Relisted at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 September 6#Category:Marimba players. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Marti Pellow |
delete. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Media Blasters titles |
delete, but due to the later arguments, not the nominated rationale |
August 18
|
|
Category:Mediterranean port cities and towns in Cyprus |
no consensus on what to rename the category to. — |
August 18
|
|
Category:Mediterranean port cities and towns in Malta |
Close. Please, have a broader discussion |
August 19
|
|
Category:Mediterranean port cities and towns in Slovenia |
rename to
Category:Port cities in Slovenia. — |
August 18
|
|
Category:Mediterranean port cities and towns in Syria |
no consensus on what to rename the category to. — |
August 18
|
|
Category:Mediterranean Revival Style Buildings of Davis Islands, Tampa, Florida |
delete. — |
August 24
|
|
Category:Members of the Senate of Northern Ireland 1933–1938 |
rename. |
August 11
|
|
Category:Men known for their penis size |
delete. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Meritas members |
delete |
August 5
|
|
Category:Metropolitan boroughs established in 1974 |
delete, not a thing to merge. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Metropolitan Community Churches in London |
delete. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Michael Jackson images and files |
rename. Further splitting may be done as desired |
August 5
|
|
Category:Middle Atlantic Corporation |
rename |
August 10
|
|
Category:Miss Guatemala winners |
keep. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Mobile venture capital firms |
delete |
August 5
|
|
Category:Modern Creative ensembles |
delete all |
August 6
|
| More college sports |
rename all |
August 11
|
|
Category:Motorcycle racers who have driven F1 cars |
Delete |
August 9
|
|
Category:Museum places |
Keep |
August 24
|
|
Category:Music of Russian subdivisions |
Rename per nom |
August 24
|
|
Category:Music videos directed by Kristin Barlowe |
Deleted by PeterSymonds, non-admin closure. Ten Pound Hammer,
his otters and a clue-bat • ( |
August 19
|
|
Category:Music videos directed by Sherman Halsey |
delete |
August 17
|
|
Category:Musical compositions included on the Voyager Golden Record |
Delete |
August 22
|
|
Category:Muskingum College alumni |
rename. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Mustard Aficionados |
delete |
August 17
|
|
Category:NAACP Image Award Winners |
Delete |
August 23
|
|
Category:Naturalized flora of Alabama |
delete |
August 1
|
|
Category:Nazi sympathizers |
Delete. — |
August 7
|
|
Category:New Democratic Party activists |
Delete |
August 11
|
|
Category:New encyclopedism |
Delete |
August 23
|
|
Category:NFL Europa |
rename all. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:Nigerien National Assembly members |
rename |
August 11
|
|
Category:Noble houses |
Rename/merge per nom. If somebody wants to split the Celtic category, they can do this themselves |
August 23
|
|
Category:Noise music |
Keep |
August 21
|
|
Category:Non-Christian saints |
upmerge |
August 3
|
|
Category:North East India |
rename |
August 1
|
|
Category:Norwegian words |
Merge |
August 9
|
|
Category:Objectivism |
Keep |
August 25
|
| Obsolete Under-19 Cricket Categories |
deleted long ago by other admins. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Old requests for Cartoon Network peer review |
delete. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Online social networking |
rename |
August 17
|
|
Category:Open source games |
Do what Mike suggests |
August 11
|
|
Category:Open source games |
Relisted to 11 August's log |
August 3
|
|
Category:Order of the Stick characters |
merge to
Category:Webcomic characters. — |
August 30
|
|
Category:Organizations designated as terrorist in Africa |
delete |
August 18
|
|
Category:Oxychaeta |
delete. Empty, so nothing to merge |
August 13
|
|
Category:PAGES WITH INCORRECT FORMATTING TEMPLATES USE |
rename. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Palestinian history |
merge. — |
August 18
|
|
Category:Parapolitics |
delete. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:People accused of antisemitism |
speedy delete. Categories of very similar names have been deleted numerous times before, so this is essentially re-creation of previously deleted material. This tends to come up about once per year. See, eg,
here and
here, as well as the one pointed out by BrownHairedGirl below. I think it's also clear that articles about people should not be included in
Category:Antisemitism just because they have been accused of having made an antisemitic remark. |
August 12
|
|
Category:People by city district or neighborhood |
No consensus |
August 5
|
|
Category:People by province in Spain - Category:Provinces of Spain |
incomplete nomination. Nothing here was tagged, so no consensus can have been reached |
August 8
|
|
Category:People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals |
Keep. — |
August 5
|
|
Category:People from Cromer |
rename |
August 1
|
|
Category:People from Heywood |
rename |
August 1
|
|
Category:People from Hiram, Maine |
merge |
August 1
|
|
Category:People from Las Vegas, Nevada (city) |
rename |
August 7
|
|
Category:People from Newstead |
rename |
August 1
|
|
Category:People from Pickering |
rename |
August 1
|
|
Category:People from Richmond, Virginia |
keep and purge. This category should be for people from Richmond, and no one else. A Greater Richmond category is also welcome, for people from the Richmond area |
August 12
|
|
Category:People from Shannon County, South Dakota |
Renamed under G7. I saw this as the speedy and was willing to leave it there. No reason that I can see for a full discussion over a simple mistake. I changed the target to
Category:People from the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, South Dakota since that seems to read better |
August 16
|
|
Category:People prosecuted under anti-homosexuality laws |
Keep. I actually failed to understand the argument related to the BLP—almost all articles appear to be about people long dead |
August 19
|
|
Category:Persons convicted of Holocaust denial offenses |
rename as nominated. If anyone wants to discuss offence, they may do so at a new discussion without causing offense |
August 1
|
|
Category:Petersfield M.P.s |
merge |
August 9
|
|
Category:Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
keep. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Platforms of the SSP |
Closer's choice?. We'll go with rename for now, as the more conservative option, with leave to renominate for a dual upmerge if desired |
August 5
|
|
Category:Platinum Triangle (Los Angeles) |
delete. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Plots |
Rename |
August 23
|
|
Category:Plug-in hybrid electric vehicle organizations |
already done. |
August 19
|
|
Category:Populated places in Davachi Rayon |
rename. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Porn directors |
Rename
Category:Porn directors
Category:Pornographic film directors,
Category:Porn directors by nationality to
Category:Pornographic film directors by nationality,
Category:American porn directors to
Category:American pornographic film directors, all other nationality categories in the manner similar to Americans and, finally,
Category:Directors of gay porn to
Category:Directors of gay pornographic films |
August 21
|
|
Category:Porn films referring to well-known mainstream movies |
delete. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Pornographic films by country |
Keep |
August 21
|
|
Category:Port cities and towns of the Arabian Sea |
Relisted at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2010 August 27#Category:Port cities and towns of the Arabian Sea. — |
August 18
|
|
Category:Post-minimalist composers |
merge. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Post-Soviet Russia |
rename. — |
August 16
|
|
Category:Power centers |
rename. However, I agree this is marketing fluff, and if the article is merged, this should follow |
August 10
|
|
Category:Power transmission in India |
rename |
August 23
|
|
Category:Printed electronics |
delete |
August 4
|
|
Category:Production electric vehicles |
merge. — |
August 23
|
| Provinces of Belarus |
keep all. — |
August 11
|
|
Category:Provinces |
already done. The suggested approach of making the by-country cat as a subcat seems to have already taken place |
August 8
|
|
Category:Puerto Rican Political Prisoners |
Delete and merge to
Category:Puerto Rican prisoners and detainees. Categorization should be based on objective criteria, but none has been specified here. Also per past precedents |
August 24
|
|
Category:Railway cuttings in the United States |
rename. Whether the category should use "railway" or "railroad" can be dealt with in a future nomination. — |
August 27
|
|
Category:Razorback Records albums |
delete. — |
August 22
|
|
Category:RCA Victor Records artists |
rename |
August 3
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the White Elephant |
rename
Category:Recipients of the Order of the White Elephant to
Category:Knights Grand Cross of the Order of the White Elephant. I will leave it to |
August 12
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Royal Architectural Institute of Canada’s Gold Medal |
Delete |
August 25
|
|
Category:Recyclable materials |
delete. — |
August 20
|
|
Category:Reliance Crossing Finish Line.jpg |
Closing since not a category. Note there is also no file |
August 10
|
|
Category:Republican Liberty Caucus members |
delete. |
August 16
|
|
Category:Resistance fighters killed by Nazi Germany |
rename, with no prejudice against a future deletion discussion |
August 1
|
|
Category:Road cuttings |
Keep both |
August 27
|
|
Category:Road pollution pricing schemes |
delete |
August 4
|
|
Category:Road to... episodes |
merge |
August 3
|
|
Category:Rolling Stone Magazine's lists |
Relisted to 15 August |
August 6
|
|
Category:Rolling Stone Magazine's lists |
Rename to
Category:Rolling Stone magazine |
August 15
|
|
Category:Roman Catholic Church architects |
Rename to
Category:Architects of Roman Catholic churches |
August 17
|
|
Category:Rosario |
rename. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Royal Navy Post-ships and Category:Royal Navy post ships |
Merge to
Category:Royal Navy post ships |
August 12
|
|
Category:Russian noble houses |
merge, with no prejudice against a nomination to standardize these to one form going either direction |
August 14
|
|
Category:Rye, New York |
keep. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Scheduled spaceflights |
Relisted on
Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2010_September_3 |
August 18
|
|
Category:Scholars and leaders of nonviolence, or nonviolent resistance |
merge to
Category:Nonviolence advocates. — |
August 23
|
|
Category:Schools named after Martin Luther King, Jr. |
delete. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Second Life residents |
delete |
August 13
|
|
Category:SED members |
Rename per nom |
August 9
|
|
Category:Serbian actresses |
merge to
Category:Serbian actors. — |
August 26
|
|
Category:Sherwood Pictures |
keep. — |
August 2
|
|
Category:Sister cities in the United States |
rename. — |
August 25
|
| Skid Row |
rename all |
August 3
|
|
Category:Slavic American Jews |
delete. — |
August 31
|
| Slovak politicians by party |
rename all |
August 4
|
|
Category:Slovakian architecture |
merge. — |
August 24
|
| Songs based on other songs |
delete both. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Songs dealing with nuclear war |
Rename to
Category:Songs about nuclear war and weapons |
August 19
|
|
Category:Songs sampling previously recorded songs |
delete all. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Songs with a Bo Diddley Beat |
Delete |
August 2
|
|
Category:Songs with music by |
no consensus. |
August 12
|
|
Category:Songs written by JB Rudd |
delete. — |
August 29
|
|
Category:Songs written by Liam Howlett |
Withdrawn Ten Pound Hammer,
his otters and a clue-bat • ( |
August 29
|
|
Category:Songs written by Mike Dekle |
delete. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Soyfoods |
merge |
August 17
|
|
Category:Space Shuttle wake-up songs |
Speedy deleted G7 per author request. Non-admin closure |
August 21
|
|
Category:Speedway Defunct teams |
Relisted on
Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2010_September_7 |
August 20
|
|
Category:Spiritual theories |
delete. — |
August 25
|
|
Category:Square Co. |
rename. — |
August 24
|
|
Category:State University of New York at Stony Brook |
rename. — |
August 31
|
|
Category:Station hotels |
merge |
August 14
|
|
Category:Step Up |
rename |
August 6
|
| Stevenage F.C. |
rename all |
August 3
|
|
Category:Stoner metal musical groups |
merge. — |
August 26
|
|
Category:Straatligkinders albums |
delete. Can be recreated if we have articles again, but while we don't, no need for the category |
August 6
|
| sub-categories of Category:Carnivorans |
rename all |
August 5
|
|
Category:Submarine communications cables |
merge |
August 18
|
|
Category:Subtemplates of Template ft2 to m2 and Category:Subtemplates of Template Ft2 to m2 |
merge to
Category:Subtemplates of Template ft2 to m2 per the related
Category:Subtemplates of Template ft to m |
August 12
|
|
Category:Sudler Trophy |
Rename per nom |
August 9
|
|
Category:Sustainment brigades of the United States Army and Category:Sustainment Brigades of the United States Army |
merge to
Category:Sustainment Brigades of the United States Army |
August 12
|
|
Category:T*Witches |
rename. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Television sets |
speedy delete under
G5. — |
August 7
|
|
Category:Terrorist incidents in 2008 in India |
rename. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:The Beatles songs sung by George Harrison |
delete |
August 17
|
|
Category:The Bionic series |
rename as nominated. There really doesn't seem to be a perfect answer to this, but
Category:Bionic franchise is better than the other two options, as neither "series" nor "Man" is helpful in defining something that contains multiple series about men and women |
August 5
|
|
Category:The Gossip songs |
rename |
August 3
|
|
Category:The Movement albums |
rename. — |
August 27
|
|
Category:The Price Is Right pricing games |
merge |
August 3
|
|
Category:Tichborne baronets |
delete |
August 7
|
|
Category:Timbuk 3 music videos |
rename. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Transport museums in Alaska |
Keep |
August 25
|
|
Category:Trinity College (Connecticut) alumni |
rename. — |
August 27
|
|
Category:Trochilidae |
keep. However, a merge the other direction might gain more traction, as the Latin name seems to predominate in our taxonomy system |
August 12
|
|
Category:Tudorbethan architecture |
Merge per nom |
August 22
|
|
Category:Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment |
Delete |
August 23
|
|
Category:Union Square |
rename. — |
August 24
|
| United States designated terrorists |
Listify and partially upmerge |
August 26
|
|
Category:Units of magnetic induction |
no consensus |
August 11
|
|
Category:Universal CityWalk Orlando |
delete |
August 6
|
|
Category:Universities and colleges associated with the Transcendental Meditation Movement |
speedy rename (empty). |
August 19
|
|
Category:Universities and Engineering colleges in Telangana |
rename. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:University or college founders |
rename. — |
August 22
|
|
Category:US OFAC Specially Designated Global Terrorist |
rename to
Category:Office of Foreign Assets Control Specially Designated Global Terrorists. Spelling out acronym and pluralizing, and eliminating "US" in front (this is not part of the agency's name). No consensus exists for any other change, though the argument "We should have only one category for the U.S." is extremely compelling, and this might fare differently as part of a larger nomination |
August 4
|
|
Category:Userboxes by Farjad0322 |
speedy delete under
G7. Thanks to Farjad0322 for their swift action. — |
August 28
|
|
Category:Vietnam War photos |
merge both to
Category:Vietnam War photographs. |
August 11
|
|
Category:Volkswagen |
rename |
August 10
|
|
Category:Watchmaking companies (defunct) |
rename |
August 22
|
|
Category:Wesley Clark |
Delete |
August 31
|
|
Category:Wikipedia Featured Picture contributors and Category:Wikipedia Featured picture contributors |
Merge to
Category:Wikipedia Featured picture contributors |
August 12
|
|
Category:Wikipedia in the news |
G7 merge, per
[1] |
August 19
|
|
Category:Wikipedia In the news |
keep all, except
Category:Wikipedia in the news frequent administrators, which will be renamed to reflect proper capitalization. — |
August 19
|
|
Category:Wikipedian Service Award Level 15 |
Keep. Note tjhat I do not consider pointing out that the category was not empty as having participated in this discussion in a way that would prevent me closing this |
August 14
|
|
Category:Wikipedian Service Award Level 16 |
Keep |
August 14
|
|
Category:Wikipedian Service Award Level 17 |
Keep |
August 14
|
| WikiProject Bleach categories |
rename. All work group categories seem to be unlabeled with "Wikipedia" or "WikiProject," and while I agree that seems out of character for such articles, they are consistent in this approach. A larger nomination would be needed to address this |
August 8
|
| WikiProject Digimon categories |
Rename all |
August 9
|
| WikiProject Dragon Ball categories |
rename all. |
August 9
|
|
Category:Wine cocktails |
already taken care of. |
August 3
|
|
Category:Wireless venture capital firms |
delete |
August 5
|
|
Category:World Supersport riders |
Keep |
August 9
|
|
Category:World Supersport riders |
rename. — |
August 21
|
|
Category:Worms |
rename, which was taken care of by creator of category. I've converted the former into a disambiguation category. — |
August 26
|
|
Category:X-ray instrumentation |
keep. — |
August 10
|
|
Category:ZF transmissions |
rename |
August 4
|
|
Category:ZX Spectrum screenshots |
rename |
August 18
|
