| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| category: Georgia (U.S. state) in the American Civil War |
not rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:"," |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:$1 |
speedied |
May 3
|
|
Category:-Class television articles |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:///seizethemoment. |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:1946 in Scotland |
keep. Bad faith POV nomination |
May 18
|
|
Category:1947 in Scotland |
keep. Bad faith POV nomination |
May 18
|
|
Category:1948 in Scotland |
keep. Bad faith POV nomination |
May 18
|
|
Category:1960s American cartoons + similar |
Rename |
May 14
|
|
Category:1963 black and white films |
upmerge 1963 and 1964 B&W films to both parent categories in each case |
May 30
|
|
Category:19th century Egypt |
rename |
May 24
|
|
Category:20th century hangings by the United Kingdom |
merge to both categories |
May 7
|
|
Category:20th century video games,
Category:21st century arcade games and
Category:21st century video games |
Keep. The reason is these categories go with the type of "X by year/decade/century" formula. |
May 14
|
|
Category:3rd Rock from the Sun |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:666 Satan (Manga) |
rename, and if the "religious, over-caffienated zealous [come] to complain", we'll tell them that Wikipedia is not censored |
May 12
|
|
Category:7th Heaven |
delete.
A simple headcount would suggest "no consensus" (3 !votes each way), but CfD is not a vote. The arguments to delete cite precedent and (implicitly)
WP:OCAT#Small_with_no_potential_for_growth and
WP:OCAT#Eponymous_categories_for_people, whereas reasons for the "keep" !votes are one
WP:USEFUL and Kingboyk's dislike of
WP:OCAT#Small_with_no_potential_for_growth. A guideline is not set in stone, but is supposed to be followed with the "occasional exception"; disliking the guideline may be grounds for seeking a change in the guideline, but it is not a reason to disregard the guideline in any individual case. So the deletes have it |
May 6
|
|
Category:8th & Ocean |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:A Country Practice |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:A Different World |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:ABC network shows |
Reame |
May 15
|
|
Category:Absolutely (TV series) |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Absolutely Fabulous |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Actors by film series |
speedy delete (empty). |
May 14
|
| Actors by series categories |
Rename |
May 14
|
|
Category:Adrenocortial cancer deaths |
delete |
May 27
|
|
Category:Affairs |
merge |
May 1
|
|
Category:African Beatboxers |
upmerge to
Category:Beatboxers |
May 31
|
|
Category:African Underground rappers |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:Agricultural Companies of Australia |
rename, as nominated |
May 23
|
|
Category:Albinos |
No Consensus |
May 1
|
|
Category:Alien (film series) films |
merge |
May 8
|
|
Category:Alleged girlfriends of Prince William |
delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Ally McBeal |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Amazonas |
rename |
May 2
|
|
Category:American actors by ethnicity |
keep all |
May 25
|
|
Category:American Dreams |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:American films shot in Japan and
Category:American films shot in Canada |
rename to
Category:Foreign films shot in Japan and
Category:Foreign films shot in Canada respectively |
May 24
|
|
Category:American heroes |
delete |
May 16
|
|
Category:American Internet celebrities |
rename, as a consequence of the debate one section down |
May 4
|
|
Category:American Inventor |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Americans who spent pre-adult years in Canada |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Analysts |
delete and
salt |
May 11
|
|
Category:Andy Barker, P.I. |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Anglican Primates of All Ireland |
merge as proposed |
May 8
|
|
Category:Anglican Primates of Ireland |
rename as proposed |
May 8
|
|
Category:Animanga images |
rename per nom |
May 19
|
|
Category:Anime and manga by genre |
as nominated |
May 20
|
|
Category:Anime and manga villians |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:Anime fandom |
rename |
May 21
|
|
Category:Anime games |
rename |
May 22
|
|
Category:Anime lists |
rename |
May 22
|
|
Category:Anime-related websites |
rename |
May 21
|
|
Category:Appennines |
redirect |
May 16
|
|
Category:Apple employees |
move/merge per nom, to avoid confusion with
Apple Records, of course. — |
May 28
|
|
Category:Applications which use Growl |
delete |
May 22
|
|
Category:Arab Israelis |
No Consensus |
May 15
|
|
Category:Arab people by occupation |
no renaming (keep) |
May 8
|
| Arcade games by year |
merge the lot of them |
May 22
|
|
Category:Archbishops of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Archdiocese of Changanassery |
Renamed |
May 15
|
|
Category:Archbishops of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Archdiocese of Kottayam |
Renamed |
May 15
|
|
Category:Architecture firms in the United States |
rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:Arimaa |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Arison family,
Category:Binion family,
Category:Bonds family,
Category:Bostwick family,
Category:Braxton family |
delete |
May 23
|
|
Category:Arkansas Razorbacks men's basketball coaches |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Armigers |
delete |
May 21
|
|
Category:Arrested Development (TV series) |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Art, Music |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Articles containing Indic text |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:Articles containing the old Invader Zim banner |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Articles needing Hangul |
that the category is already deleted |
May 28
|
|
Category:Articles needing Japanese script |
reverse merge
Category:Articles needing kanji to
Category:Articles needing Japanese script |
May 13
|
|
Category:Articles needing kanji |
merge
Category:Articles needing kanji to
Category:Articles needing Japanese script |
May 13
|
|
Category:Articles needing original script |
Merge to
Category:Articles needing non-English script or text |
May 18
|
|
Category:Articles related to Laredo, Texas |
merge |
May 17
|
|
Category:Articles with example Algol code |
delete |
May 16
|
|
Category:Articles with example Assembly code |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Articles with large trivia sections |
rename/merge as nominated |
May 30
|
|
Category:Artists who have performed at the High Sierra Music Festival |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:Asia Miles |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Astronomy institutes |
merge
Category:Astronomy institutes and
Category:Astronomical institutes and departments to
Category:Astronomy institutes and departments |
May 13
|
|
Category:Athletes to play in National Football League & Major League Baseball |
upmerge |
May 9
|
|
Category:Athletes to play in the National Basketball Association & Major League Baseball |
delete. — |
May 28
|
|
Category:Auf Wiedersehen, Pet |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Australian architecture firms |
rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:Australian test cricketers killed in action |
upmerge |
May 6
|
|
Category:Aventis Prize for Science Books |
delete |
May 17
|
|
Category:Aztec nobility |
don't merge. — |
May 28
|
|
Category:Bands Whose Names Are One Repeated Word |
delete |
May 20
|
|
Category:Bands Whose Names Have Animals in Them |
delete. — |
May 18
|
| Barbadian sportspeople |
rename footballers, no consensus on cricketers. However, the latter is an inconsistent state which should be considered in a group nomination later on. See for example
category:Scottish cricketers and
Category:Scotland cricketers. The Scotland category declares it is only for non-Scottish players who play for Scotland, while the Barbados category makes no such claim. Thus, it is possible that non-Barbadian players can be in this category, which would make it a difficult fit for
category:Barbadian sportspeople. Some global rename should be considered |
May 16
|
|
Category:Batman episodes, season 1 |
rename
Category:Batman episodes, season 1 to
Category:Batman (TV series) episodes |
May 30
|
|
Category:Batman: The Animated Series episodes |
withdrawn by nominator |
May 20
|
|
Category:Batman: The Animated Series title screenshots |
delete as empty |
May 20
|
| Battlefield 2 modifications |
No consensus on Battlefield 2 or Total War, as proposed names match naming convention but gathered enough opposition that the naming convention as a whole may need reconsidered. (I could not find a previous discussion on the issue.) Rename Quake 3 -> Quake III as it is a simple title correction which does not change the debated portion of the name. I am not an admin |
May 19
|
|
Category:Beans |
rename |
May 21
|
|
Category:Beck: Soundtracks |
rename |
May 22
|
|
Category:Belief systems |
delete (closed together with the Isms CfD) |
May 11
|
|
Category:Bewitched |
keep |
May 24
|
|
Category:Big 12 Conference head basketball coaches |
Delete |
May 14
|
|
Category:Big Brother presenters |
merge
Category:Big Brother presenters to
Category:Game show hosts |
May 28
|
|
Category:Black Legions band |
rename |
May 10
|
|
Category:Black Legions bootlegs |
rename |
May 10
|
|
Category:Black Legions Releases |
rename |
May 10
|
|
Category:BLAME! characters |
rename |
May 4
|
|
Category:BLAME! |
rename. Deletion should be discussed in a new nom, if desired |
May 4
|
|
Category:Bob Weir songs |
rename to
Category:Songs by Bob Weir |
May 6
|
|
Category:Bonanza |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Bone |
rename to
Category:Bone (comics) |
May 7
|
|
Category:Boroughs of New York City |
keep |
May 9
|
|
Category:Boston University Terriers head basketball coaches |
Rename |
May 14
|
|
Category:Brady family |
{{
listify}} |
May 29
|
|
Category:British early modern theatre companies |
rename as proposed |
May 8
|
|
Category:British India |
merge |
May 13
|
|
Category:British Influenced Conflict |
delete |
May 2
|
|
Category:British media |
no renaming. The consensus of the discussion is that 'British' is an acceptable adjective for the United Kingdom |
May 8
|
|
Category:British people of French descent |
Delete |
May 14
|
|
Category:British rugby league clubs |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:British software companies |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:British supervillains |
merge |
May 8
|
|
Category:British theatre companies |
no renaming. The consensus of the debate is that 'British' is acceptable as an adjective for the UK |
May 8
|
|
Category:Buddhist deities, boddhisatvas, and demons |
unclear. Suggest renomination with a clear suggestion to rename it to |
May 12
|
|
Category:Bullet hell |
merge. It may be a separate genre, but as stated here the difference is really not objectively definable, per
WP:OCAT. For instance,
Tyrian (computer game) may or may not be considered "bullet hell" depending on whom you ask and the difficulty level they're playing at |
May 4
|
|
Category:Business films |
no consensus |
May 10
|
| By-year subcats of Category:Natural disasters by year |
rename |
May 23
|
| By-year subcats of Category:Transportation disasters by year |
keep |
May 26
|
|
Category:Cable television stations in Belize |
merge |
May 3
|
|
Category:Cadet College Petaro |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:Canadian legislative buildings |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Canadian Parliament Buildings |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Canadians who spent pre-adult years in the United States |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:Cantabria international footballers |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Capoeira practitioners by nationality |
keep |
May 8
|
|
Category:Card video games |
merge both to
category:Card game video games. We have clear consensus to rename both, and two approximately equally supported choices. As we have a number of potential closers weighing in on this, I'll go with the one that seems clearer to me, with no prejudice if someone wants to renominate |
May 5
|
|
Category:Casserole dishes |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Casuarius |
keep as part of scientific classification hierarchy |
May 23
|
|
Category:Categories by province of Canada |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Categories by religion |
no consensus. |
May 7
|
|
Category:Category:Indian comic book publishers |
merge
Category:Indian comic book publishers to
Category:Comic book publishing companies of India |
May 27
|
| Categoy:Roman Catholic secondary schools in Omaha |
upmerge |
May 16
|
|
Category:Catholic primates not in communion with Rome |
no consensus |
May 29
|
|
Category:Celebration Arts |
delete |
May 16
|
|
Category:Celebrities in fiction |
delete |
May 1
|
| Central Florida athletics categories |
rename |
May 9
|
|
Category:CG Tasks |
delete (replaced by template) |
May 24
|
|
Category:Chaotic BattleZone |
Delete |
May 14
|
|
Category:Characters in Homer |
upmerge to
Category:Characters in epics |
May 24
|
|
Category:Charmed Powers |
Delete |
May 14
|
|
Category:Chicago Baseball |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Chicago Football |
rename |
May 25
|
|
Category:Child abuse victims |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Children's sport |
keep |
May 29
|
|
Category:Chinese fruit |
merge, per other discussion |
May 24
|
|
Category:Chinese Mausoleums |
Rename. I am not an admin |
May 19
|
|
Category:ChitraguptVanshi |
Delete, as already decided. -- |
May 10
|
|
Category:Chitranshi |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:Choral musical groups |
delete as empty |
May 20
|
|
Category:Christian LGBT people |
no consensus. This is precisely one of those issues on which an RFC might be useful |
May 5
|
|
Category:Christian right |
delete. The Christian Right is certainly notable, but not being objectively definable is problematic for a category. Note that there's already a list on the topic at
Christian right |
May 5
|
|
Category:Christmas-linked biology |
delete, not useful |
May 30
|
|
Category:CHUM Chart |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Church of Ireland archbishops |
delete |
May 27
|
|
Category:CIS |
rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:Classical tubists |
No Consensus |
May 1
|
|
Category:Closed regional railway stations in Victoria |
no consensus |
May 28
|
|
Category:Closed Victoria railway stations |
rename
Category:Closed Victoria railway stations to
Category:Closed railway stations in Victoria |
May 29
|
|
Category:Clubs formed by a merger |
delete. Not generally good practice for a renaming discussion to be closed as a delete but in this particular instance it's justified |
May 9
|
|
Category:CNN newsreaders and journalists |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Coats of arms of Poland |
rename/merge as nominated |
May 24
|
|
Category:Coats of arms of Tonga |
rename per nom |
May 23
|
|
Category:Coffeeshops |
rename to "houses" as suggested. If necessary, create cats for the other things that "coffeeshop" disambiguates to |
May 22
|
|
Category:Coloreds |
rename
Category:Coloreds to
Category:Cape Coloureds |
May 29
|
| Comedy troupes |
Keep |
May 15
|
|
Category:Comic operas |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Command and General Staff College alumni |
rename/merge to
Category:Non-U.S. alumni of the Command and General Staff College |
May 31
|
|
Category:Companies headquartered in Tokyo |
rename |
May 8
|
|
Category:Companies Headquartered in Troy, Michigan |
rename |
May 25
|
|
Category:Compositions by Gioacchino Rossini |
Rename to
Category:Compositions by Gioachino Rossini |
May 18
|
|
Category:Computation |
upmerge as nominated |
May 30
|
|
Category:Concert Organist |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Congolese musicians |
rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:Congolese short story writers |
rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:Congolese singers |
rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:Congolese writers |
rename |
May 26
|
|
Category:Conservation areas of South Africa |
rename |
May 9
|
|
Category:Country Studies |
Delete. There is clear consensus for deletion and retaining the template |
May 8
|
|
Category:Counts of Urgel |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Court TV shows |
keep |
May 9
|
|
Category:Courtroom dramas |
Keep |
May 14
|
|
Category:Creators who do not acquiesce to fan fiction |
listify & delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Critics of Freud |
delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Cruisers of the United States |
keep |
May 29
|
|
Category:Crumb family |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:Cuisine of Kentucky |
rename for consistency. — |
May 23
|
|
Category:Cult film stubs |
withdrawn by nominator, to allow discussion to be moved to
WP:SFD. See
Wikipedia:Stub types for deletion#.7B.7BCult-film-stub.7D.7D_.2F_Cat:Cult_film_stubs |
May 8
|
|
Category:Cult science fiction films |
merge |
May 8
|
|
Category:Cupid (TV series) |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Curb Your Enthusiasm |
no consensus |
May 11
|
|
Category:Current Albums |
delete. — |
May 23
|
|
Category:Current British MPs |
Judgment call here. Generally we don't subcategorize members of some office between "current" and "former"; indeed, the current members of a parliament are best covered in a list, which gives a lot more context and could be sortable by e.g. party or origin or both. It would seem that most objectors here do not want the information to be lost - but in fact changing a category to a list doesn't lose the information, and may well make it more comprehensive and/or accessible. Of course, canvassing (both at the article and a dozen or so talk pages) to obtain a bunch of "me too" votes really doesn't help matters. And yes, we will be here until christmas, and yes, sortable lists work as advertised these days. So the end result is Listify |
May 22
|
|
Category:Current Top 40 |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Daniel Defoe |
rename |
May 20
|
|
Category:Daredevil Villains |
delete and protect against recreation |
May 31
|
|
Category:Dark Lords |
nuked as it had been before; protected from recreation— |
May 13
|
|
Category:Daugavpils airport |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Dave the Barbarian cast members |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Dave the Barbarian |
delete; given the low amount of articles and categories on this show, this supercat does not appear to be necessary |
May 12
|
|
Category:DC Comics heroes, non-superpowered |
merge to
Category:DC Comics superheroes |
May 27
|
|
Category:DC Comics villains, non-superpowered |
merge |
May 26
|
|
Category:Debian-based distributions |
keep |
May 2
|
|
Category:Defunct department stores of the United States |
merge |
May 5
|
|
Category:Delegates to the U.S. House of Representatives from Alaska Territory |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:Deol family |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Deprecated templates |
keep |
May 7
|
|
Category:Designing Women |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Developers |
rename per Honbicot |
May 4
|
|
Category:Diagnosis: Murder |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:DiMera family |
listify |
May 29
|
|
Category:Disney's Nine Old Men |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Disturbing tha Peace artists |
Listify & Delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Dominionist parties |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Dreamgirls |
delete. There was little support for keeping the category, and some support for creating a
Category:Dreamgirls songs as a sub-category of
Category:Songs from musicals, where there are a dozen or so similar sings-by-musical categories). If that category is to be created, it does not need CfD approval, and is better created from scaratch rather tan as renaming of this category |
May 21
|
|
Category:Drive (TV series) |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Dromaius |
keep as part of scientific classification hierarchy |
May 23
|
|
Category:Dynasty |
keep |
May 11
|
|
Category:Earthless science fiction |
delete |
May 9
|
| Eastern Rite Catholic primates |
rename/merge/keep as proposed by |
May 9
|
|
Category:Eastern Rite Catholicism |
Rename |
May 14
|
|
Category:ECO codes |
delete |
May 7
|
|
Category:Economic problems |
Keep, category has been populated and refined to address objections. I am not an admin |
May 19
|
|
Category:Effects of the 2003 Iraq conflict |
Merge. Consensus is there to not keep. I decided that merging was better then deleting given the various suggestions on the table |
May 15
|
|
Category:Egg |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Elected Hereditary Peers in UK House of Lords |
rename |
May 22
|
| Election(s) templates |
rename/merge to
Category:Election years templates and
Category:Election results templates |
May 30
|
|
Category:Electronic (band) |
Delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Electronic albums by artist |
merge |
May 5
|
|
Category:Ellen (TV series) |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Emacs users |
delete. — |
May 18
|
|
Category:Enderverse characters |
rename to
Category:Ender's Game series characters |
May 22
|
|
Category:Enderverse novels and short stories |
rename to
Category:Ender's Game series novels. A rename is clearly favored by everyone, and Enderverse does seem to be a fan construction, so I went with what I believe to be the least controversial option |
May 6
|
|
Category:Enderverse |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:English Secretaries of State |
rename to
Category:Secretaries of State of the Kingdom of England |
May 11
|
|
Category:English-speaking countries |
rename (to make more inclusive). — |
May 23
|
|
Category:Entertainers by age upon death |
Speedy deleted as recreation |
May 13
|
|
Category:Entertainers by age upon death |
salt |
May 15
|
|
Category:Entertainment Weekly Entertainer of the Year |
Delete |
May 19
|
|
Category:Envelopes |
no consensus |
May 18
|
| Equatoguinean-Spaniard |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Esoteric templates |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:Ethnic Hungarian politicians outside of Hungary |
merge to
Category:People of Hungarian descent |
May 6
|
|
Category:Ethnographic villages in Lithuania |
no consensus |
May 18
|
|
Category:Euroasian history |
merge
Category:Euroasian history to
Category:Eurasian history |
May 29
|
|
Category:European Royal families |
Merge
Category:European Royal families to
Category:European royal families |
May 10
|
|
Category:Evangelicals who teach Abstinence from Alcohol |
delete |
May 16
|
|
Category:Everybody Loves Raymond |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Ex-atheists/agnostics |
rename
Category:Ex-atheists/agnostics to
Category:Former atheists and agnostics |
May 30
|
|
Category:Ex-gay people |
no consensus |
May 26
|
|
Category:Ex-Islamists |
merge to "Islamists", as Otto says we don't generally categorize people by current/former status, as everyone becomes a "former <whatever>" upon death. No objection to creating a category for "islamists who have renounced islamism and started counteracting it" or something better titled than that, but said cat has a narrower scope than this one |
May 21
|
|
Category:Executions by country |
rename all to "X" executions. This was a mightily confusing nomination, and I do think there were some procedural errors made in how information was presented, both in the nominations and the debate. But it is all capable of being sorted out, and when it is, the tide is clearly in favor (12 to 3) of the shortened format, which avoids the problem of whether a state or nation committed the execution. This should not have been taken to DRV, as there was no impropriety in the closing rationale per se. It is simply a change of group will. (Side note: There were several errors in the wordings of the nominations. "Romanian" was misspelled, "Russia" should have been "Russian," "Italian" and "Irish" were conflated, and "in Germany," while mentioned above, was not on the list below. As they would clearly have been supported by the consensus, I have smoothed out these problems on the Working page. I also added
Category:People executed by Mexico, which was not in any form of this nomination, but is clearly in line with this conclusion.) |
May 21
|
|
Category:Extras (TV series) |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Extraterrestrials |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:F. C. Unirea Valahorum Urziceni players |
rename both to
Category:FC Unirea Valahorum Urziceni players |
May 11
|
|
Category:F. C. Unirea Valahorum Urziceni |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Families of Rome |
rename per nom |
May 19
|
|
Category:Family Matters |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:Fantastic Children |
delete |
May 11
|
| Fashion |
keep and rename, respectively |
May 2
|
|
Category:Fathers of the House |
delete, no objection to a list |
May 3
|
|
Category:Fauna of Northern Canada |
delete |
May 17
|
|
Category:FC Spartak Vladikavkaz players |
rename x2 |
May 21
|
|
Category:Female empowerment songs |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Female superheroes |
delete. Yes, they are often designed with sex appeal in mind (but then, so are some of the male superheroes), but that doesn't mean this is useful categorization. Roughly half of superheroes these days are female, and it's simply false to consider "male" and "female" two different species. In most cases we don't subcategorize people by gender. Instead, I would suggest writing an article depicting the female role in fiction, from damsel-in-distress
Dale Arden to hapless teammate
Invisible Girl (as first written) to powerful protagonist
Buffy Summers |
May 21
|
|
Category:Fertilizer Producers |
rename
Category:Fertilizer Producers to
Category:Fertilizer companies |
May 27
|
|
Category:Fictional albinos |
No Consensus |
May 1
|
|
Category:Fictional band members |
merge |
May 6
|
|
Category:Fictional bowlers |
Delete |
May 15
|
|
Category:Fictional characters who are left-handed |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:Fictional characters with sand powers |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Fictional characters with telekinesis |
listify. if it's "difficult to define" as Piemanmoo suggests, then it is not a "valid category", but should be a list instead - see also
unclear inclusion criterion. Aside from that, it is indeed a problem that this category attracts characters with "nebulous do-anything powers", as Sean states - for these people, telekinesis is not a defining characteristic. Since it requires an explanation why a character does or does not "have telekinesis", this should be a list rather than a category, as suggested by both
WP:CLS and
WP:OCAT. I'll reiterate that changing a category to a list is not a loss of information |
May 12
|
|
Category:Fictional coffeeshops |
per the below |
May 22
|
|
Category:Fictional computers |
keep |
May 24
|
|
Category:Fictional conspiracy theorists |
keep |
May 24
|
|
Category:Fictional drug users |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Fictional Fighters |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Fictional fugitives |
Delete. Categories with unclear inclusion criteria are considered not such a good idea (the
overcategorization guideline has some thoughts on that). There are a number of fictional characters for whom being fugitive has a clear and continuous impact on the story (e.g. "The Fugitive" from the series), but there are also many for whom "being on the run" is mentioned in their backstory but isn't really important throughout the story, and there are many for whom the "fugitive status" is a temporary plot point that is resolved in the next chapter. Aside from that, the categorized characters really don't have all that much in common. Contrary to what Petri says, in general fictional characters are categorized by their fictional characteristics, not by plot elements |
May 25
|
|
Category:Fictional gamblers |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Fictional geniuses |
speedy delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Fictional gingers |
deleted— |
May 13
|
|
Category:Fictional henchmen |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Fictional junk dealers |
Keep |
May 9
|
|
Category:Fictional magic users |
listify. The problem with "is a user of magic in any way whatsoever" and "depending on
artistic license" is that it groups a lot of characters that are not meaningfully related, given that "magic" means very different things in different settings.
Merlin's powers are entirely diffent from
Gandalf's, and both are different from
Khelben Blackstaff.
Rincewind is a wizard who is incapable of using magic, and in
Isaac Asimov's books, the "magic user" is actually an alien with high-level technology - does that mean all high-tech aliens are magic users? Why or why not? A second problem is that in some settings, the term "magic" is ill-defined. Are the metas from
Julian May's books "magic users"? Why or why not? What about
Corwin of Amber and family, or the Witted from
Robin Hobb's books? And whether divine intervention qualifies as magic depends on whom you ask. Since it requires an explanation why a character is or is not considered a "magic user", this should be a list rather than a category, as suggested by both
WP:CLS and
WP:OCAT. I'll reiterate that changing a category to a list is not a loss of information |
May 12
|
|
Category:Fictional morphine addicts |
Speedy delete as CSD G4 |
May 14
|
|
Category:Fictional ninja |
Withdrawn |
May 27
|
|
Category:Fictional ninja |
rename. With both plurals being correct, the weight goes to the one most editors support. Also, the rename is less likely to encourage people to create categories like "fictional firefighter." |
May 28
|
|
Category:Fictional schoolgirls |
rename
Category:Fictional schoolgirls to
Category:Fictional students |
May 24
|
|
Category:Fictional Science Fiction Ground Vehicles |
No Consensus |
May 13
|
|
Category:Fictional sociopaths |
delete as recreation, and per the below |
May 28
|
|
Category:Fictional swimmers |
Delete. It seems that much of the support for keeping was to clean this category up based on some defining characteristic. I think it is better to delete this and then once a clear set of defining characteristics is defined then the category can be recreated. It would also be better if the name was changed to reflect the defining character of the new category so that it does not resemble a catchall category as the current name does |
May 15
|
|
Category:Fictional universes |
delete |
May 5
|
|
Category:Filipino people |
Merge to
Category:People of the Philippines |
May 18
|
|
Category:Films about filmmaking |
keep |
May 24
|
|
Category:Films about mental illness |
Delete |
May 14
|
|
Category:Films by topic |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Films containing graphic female rape |
delete |
May 20
|
|
Category:Films directed by Christopher Nolan |
withdrawn by nominator. -- |
May 30
|
|
Category:Films released on Special Edition DVD Sets |
delete |
May 19
|
|
Category:Films with a medical theme |
Relist |
May 17
|
|
Category:Films with a medical theme |
Rename - However, since there doesn't seem to be a consensus on what the target name should be, I'm relisting the discussion |
May 10
|
|
Category:Films with a medical theme |
Rename. Support was clearly in favor of renaming and keeping. Since there was no real objection to the proposed name I consider that consensus for this proposed name that had the most support from the previous discussion |
May 25
|
|
Category:Films with a rape theme |
delete |
May 23
|
|
Category:Films written by Charlie Kaufman,
Category:Launder and Gilliat films and
Category:Suzan-Lori Parks screenplays |
hippocratic rename to "Screenplays by (X)," without prejudice to deletion later. Since lots of potential closers have commented on this nomination, I'll close it with Radiant's last suggested solution, since there is a clear desire to do something. If after these are renamed, the pro-deletion people want to reopen it, this shouldn't be used as precedent to deny that course of action |
May 2
|
|
Category:Final albums |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Finland Russians |
rename |
May 2
|
|
Category:First Bundesliga footballers |
relist at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 May 21 |
May 11
|
|
Category:First Bundesliga footballers |
no consensus |
May 21
|
|
Category:Flags of Nepal |
Keep, both by a clear supermajority of participants and per
WP:OCAT#Small_with_no_potential_for_growth, which deprecates small categories "unless such categories are part of a large overall accepted sub-categorization scheme". This category clearly is part of such a scheme:
Category:Flags by country |
May 20
|
|
Category:Flowers of Mexico |
merge |
May 22
|
|
Category:Food Network Canada personalities |
delete |
May 24
|
| Fooian vegetables |
delete. Suggest adding information on particular specific veggies to the articles about Fooian Cuisine for comprehensiveness |
May 21
|
|
Category:Footballers from Birmingham |
Merge to
Category:People from Birmingham, England/
Category:People from Manchester and
Category:English footballers per consensus and precedent |
May 1
|
|
Category:Forever Knight |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:Formula 1 Designers |
Rename, along with
Category:Formula_One_Designers, to
Category:Formula One designers |
May 14
|
|
Category:Foundations of Belgium |
merge |
May 12
|
|
Category:Fountain pen ink manufacturers |
rename/merge as nominated, no redirect |
May 30
|
|
Category:Free hex editors |
merge |
May 10
|
|
Category:Free University of Brussels |
Delete,
CSD G7 by creator request. -- |
May 21
|
|
Category:French Colonial Governors |
Rename to
Category:French colonial governors and administrators |
May 18
|
|
Category:French crime novelists |
rename. — |
May 23
|
|
Category:Gabriel García Márquez |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:Galactophilia |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:Game Theory |
speedy close |
May 29
|
|
Category:GameTap Games |
delete, advertorial and non-defining |
May 13
|
| Gangs and criminal organisations |
no consensus |
May 9
|
|
Category:Gay Nazis |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:Gay Neo-Nazis |
no consensus |
May 6
|
|
Category:Generals whose names sound like car brands |
speedy delete |
May 16
|
|
Category:Georgian articles |
rename to WikiProject Georgia (country) articles |
May 26
|
|
Category:Get Smart |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Ghostwriter |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Glyphic serif typefaces |
rename/merge as nominated and add articles to
Category:Serif typefaces |
May 30
|
|
Category:Good Times |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Governor General's Academic Medal Winner |
delete as
overcategorization by award or honor |
May 20
|
|
Category:Gralo |
speedied,
WP:CSD#G7 |
May 24
|
|
Category:Grand Companions of the Order of Logohu |
keep |
May 8
|
|
Category:Grand Theft Auto songs |
delete |
May 29
|
| Great Britain and stamps |
rename |
May 8
|
|
Category:Greater Binghamton |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:Greater Syracuse, New York |
rename
Category:Greater Syracuse, New York to
Category:Syracuse, New York |
May 31
|
|
Category:Greek and Roman astrologers |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Greek mythological people |
merge |
May 16
|
|
Category:H1B dependent companies |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:Haitian Churches |
delete |
May 22
|
|
Category:Happy Days |
rename to spin-offs |
May 25
|
|
Category:Happy5214 |
delete. I see no reason to send this to
WP:UCFD as it will be deleted anyway, and this should have been speedied from the beginning. THis is for the betterment of Wikipedia per
WP:IAR. If anyone has a problem with this, they can always do a deletion review. -- |
May 14
|
|
Category:Have I Got News For You |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Hawaii native flora |
rename
Category:Hawaii native flora to
Category:Endemic flora of Hawaii |
May 24
|
|
Category:Health Promotion |
no consensus, since there was no clear proposal |
May 12
|
|
Category:Heartbeat (TV series) |
delete. "There is material" is not grounds for keeping a cat. "There is no material" is grounds for speedy deletion, so nearly all cats on CFD have "material" |
May 26
|
|
Category:Heavy metal Greek keyboardists |
rename per nom and per convention |
May 23
|
|
Category:Hee Haw |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Hell's Kitchen (TV series) |
delete. Note for this and all further noms: Musicpvm's statement (found at the bottom of the page) is an empty argument (paraphrased, "I object to this mass nom ... find the cats useful ... and don't understand why they're being deleted"). In essence he is objecting to several dozen nominations on procedural grounds, not bothering to give an argument to the actual content |
May 26
|
|
Category:Henry Iba Coaching Tree |
Delete |
May 14
|
|
Category:Heroes of the Christian Church in the Anglican Communion |
listify and delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:High schools in Germany |
not to rename |
May 25
|
|
Category:High schools in Los Angeles County |
no consensus |
May 13
|
|
Category:High schools |
merge |
May 18
|
|
Category:Hills of Karnataka |
merge, as parent cat is empty, without prejudice against subcategorizing if and when this parent cat becomes too large |
May 5
|
|
Category:Historical board games |
nomination withdrawn |
May 14
|
|
Category:History of the Democratic Republic of Congo |
merge |
May 2
|
|
Category:Hockey grounds in Pakistan |
Rename to
Category:Field hockey venues in Pakistan |
May 18
|
|
Category:HolbyBlue |
delete |
May 26
|
| Hollywood families - A |
delete |
May 2
|
| Hollywood families - B |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Home and Away |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Home Improvement TV Shows |
merge |
May 11
|
|
Category:Horton family |
listify |
May 29
|
|
Category:Hot Food |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:House (TV series) |
no consensus |
May 13
|
|
Category:How to |
delete |
May 5
|
|
Category:Human pest insects |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:Humanists by nationality |
withdrawn and relisted by nom see
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 May 31#Category:Humanists |
May 31
|
|
Category:Humanists |
merge all into
Category:Church of BHG. Or keep due to not a whole lot of consensus |
May 31
|
|
Category:Hurricane Preparation, Safety, and Awareness |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:I Love Lucy |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:In Living Color |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Indiana Jones artifacts |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Indigenous Australian sports people |
rename |
May 21
|
|
Category:Indigenous peoples of Asia |
all kept, except for the one which never existed. — |
May 23
|
|
Category:Influences on Sigmund Freud |
delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Insect vectors of plant disease |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:Instant Star |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:International days |
delete |
May 21
|
|
Category:Internet celebrities |
merge. Since arguably there is a difference between a celeb and an internet celeb, it may not actually be helpful to consider the entire tree |
May 4
|
|
Category:Introduced Species |
delete both because nearly all common species have been "introduced" somewhere |
May 23
|
|
Category:Invader Zim locations |
already speedy deleted by |
May 7
|
|
Category:Iron Chef |
Listfy cast and crew and then Delete. Consensus was clearly there for deletion when discussions ended. The very late keep vote does not raise any reason to not follow the precedent on recent similar closing saying delete or listify are the consensus action. The issue of adding the links to multiple article can be resolved with the template included in the discussion |
May 13
|
|
Category:Iron Man Villains |
delete and protect against recreation |
May 31
|
|
Category:Islamic science |
Rename to
Category:History of Islamic science. There seems to be consensus for a rename to the "History of ..." form |
May 15
|
|
Category:Isms |
delete |
May 9
|
| Italian dukes |
no consensus |
May 21
|
|
Category:Italian lake navigational boxes |
Speedy delete as empty and requested by creator |
May 15
|
|
Category:Jaina mathematics |
delete |
May 21
|
|
Category:Jay Wolpert game shows |
delete |
May 16
|
|
Category:Jazz tubists |
No Consensus |
May 1
|
|
Category:Jeeva Cinematographed Films |
delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Jeeva Directed Films |
rename |
May 13
|
|
Category:Jericho Images |
rename |
May 6
|
|
Category:Jerusalem culture |
no consensus. Suggest making a standardization proposal for the entire parent cat |
May 19
|
|
Category:Jewish Americans |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:Jewish communities destroyed in 1948 |
Delete both. The "Deletes" outnumber the "Keeps", and I spent some time seeing if the "Keep" arguments stood up to scrutiny |
May 14
|
|
Category:Jewish mathematicians |
|
May 14
|
|
Category:Jimmy Kimmel Live |
keep |
May 9
|
|
Category:Jiu-Jitsu practitioners by nationality |
speedy delete by |
May 2
|
|
Category:Joey (TV series) |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Junk Science |
delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Keeping Up Appearances actors |
Delete |
May 19
|
|
Category:Korean honorifics |
delete |
May 19
|
|
Category:Kosovo politicians |
no obvious consensus, note that we have many categories with "Kosovo" in their name, would suggest new discussion in a group nomination |
May 19
|
|
Category:Kyle XY |
nomination withdrawn |
May 6
|
|
Category:Lacking non-English text |
merge and rename/merge subcategories |
May 18
|
|
Category:Lao Monarchy |
rename
Category:Lao Monarchy to
Category:Laotian royalty |
May 31
|
|
Category:Latter Day Saint scientists |
delete |
May 10
|
| Law firms |
Rename all, to X of <country> convention |
May 27
|
|
Category:Law of the British Virgin Islands |
rename |
May 1
|
|
Category:Legislatures of subnational entities |
Rename |
May 14
|
|
Category:Leidsevaart |
no consensus |
May 4
|
|
Category:LGBT academics |
delete |
May 22
|
|
Category:LGBT physicians |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:LGBT sportspeople |
keep for now, but I suspect there isn't truly a consensus here and it will be relisted in a month or so |
May 22
|
|
Category:List Of Number One Singles |
delete |
May 31
|
|
Category:List of secular states |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:List of Tall Men |
delete |
May 17
|
|
Category:Lists of fictional characters in comedy |
No consensus - For the future, perhaps consider whether
Category:Fictional characters by genre should exist. (Though most of the members so far seem to be television
situation comedies.) |
May 10
|
|
Category:Lists of films with features in common |
keep |
May 24
|
|
Category:Lists of ministers |
move as suggested — |
May 24
|
|
Category:Lists of number-one songs on the virgin radio airplay chart |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Lists of structures |
Rename |
May 15
|
|
Category:Literature protagonists |
merge. |
May 15
|
|
Category:Literature protagonists |
voided by closure of other nomination. |
May 22
|
|
Category:Little Red Riding Hood |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Live-action/animated films |
delete |
May 22
|
|
Category:Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman |
merge |
May 25
|
|
Category:Lou Gehrig Memorial Award |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Love music albums |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Loyalists in the American Revolution |
reverse merge, per Kevin |
May 5
|
|
Category:Lucky Louie |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Lucky Louie |
no consensus |
May 9
|
|
Category:Lutheran Primates of Sweden |
Rename |
May 9
|
|
Category:Madurai |
delete |
May 17
|
|
Category:Mafia associates |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Main characters of Pokémon |
rename |
May 11
|
| Malaysian people by state |
rename all to "People from Foo" |
May 23
|
|
Category:Malcolm in the Middle |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Maps and
Category:Cartography |
keep |
May 9
|
|
Category:Marvel Comics characters with Spider-powers |
delete |
May 2
|
|
Category:Marvel Comics heroes, non-superpowered |
merge |
May 27
|
|
Category:Marylebone |
merge to westminster & delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Massacres by Mormons |
delete |
May 22
|
|
Category:Match Game |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Matlock (TV series) |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Mayors of places in New York |
no rename |
May 9
|
|
Category:Melrose Place |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Memon Personalities |
Rename to
Category:Memon people |
May 18
|
|
Category:Mercader Saülo |
delete |
May 30
|
| Merge into Comics conventions |
merge
Category:Comic conventions into
Category:Comic book conventions |
May 27
|
|
Category:Messianic Judaism important figures |
hippocratic rename to
Category:People in Messianic Judaism, with no prejudice to a later merge. |
May 7
|
|
Category:Metro-Goldwyn-Meyer musicals stars |
speedy deleted |
May 24
|
|
Category:MGM musical actors |
delete |
May 7
|
|
Category:Miami Vice |
"Delete". As Otto says, all the categories are interlinked and all the subcategories are part of hierarchies that do not need this category. It serves no navigational purpose, so just tends to clutter the parent categories with listings that are less useful than the eponymous article. I think the OCAT guideline about Eponymous categories for people has not yet been extended to TV shows and other things, but discussions on that page attacked eponymous people categories first, because they were the most obviously egrigious. Brown HairedGirl seems to make a good argument for deleting the category and extending the OCAT guidelines. I don't understand why she said "keep". So I don't see any convincing argument to keep and I do see reasons to delete. --
☑ |
May 24
|
|
Category:Mid winter flowers |
listify. Since this requires explanation (e.g. of climates and temperate zone), as well as "guesstimates", it is really better covered in a list |
May 17
|
|
Category:Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Military of Wales |
rename |
May 23
|
|
Category:Millersville Marauders men's basketball coaches |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:Mills |
rename as proposed |
May 8
|
|
Category:Ministers of the Universal Life Church |
delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Monastic Lineage |
rename |
May 4
|
| More Anglican primates |
Rename |
May 9
|
|
Category:Mortal Kombat Conquest |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Mortal Kombat television series |
merge |
May 25
|
|
Category:Movies filmed in Oregon |
rename to to
Category:Films shot in Oregon |
May 8
|
|
Category:MPs of the United Kingdom House of Commons, by Parliament |
keep. I am most swayed to keep based on arguments by BHG and Sam as well as the unwieldy size of categories were these to be collapsed |
May 9
|
|
Category:Mr. Show |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Municipalities in Arauca |
rename |
May 6
|
|
Category:Muppet people |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Music by A. R. Rahman |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Music in Skins |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Music print publishers |
merge to
Category:Publishers of sheet music |
May 7
|
|
Category:Music Video-Promotional screenshots |
Rename to
Category:Screenshots of music videos |
May 18
|
|
Category:Musical artists who died at the age of 27 |
rename to
Category:musicians who died between 6:03 AM and 7:12 AM. No, I'm kidding. Delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Musician politicians |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Musicians who had no.1 Billboard R&B hits |
delete. Note that since the main objection to this category was category clutter rather than unverifiability, I have created a list to replace the category, at
List of musicians who had no.1 Billboard R&B hits. If anyone feels that the list is inappropriate, you know where
AFD is |
May 1
|
|
Category:Muslim musicians |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Muslim travel writers |
Rename to
Category:Islamic travel writers. Personally I remain unconvinced by the arguments for retention— |
May 17
|
|
Category:Myst comics |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Mythical Creatures |
Merge with
Category:Legendary creatures. I am not an admin |
May 19
|
|
Category:Mythological ships |
keep |
May 27
|
|
Category:Nashville Star |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Native American Chiefs of Pennsylvania |
rename to "natice Americans" which is the most commonly used form |
May 4
|
|
Category:Native American people and
Category:Native American people of the Indian Wars |
no renaming |
May 9
|
|
Category:Natural disasters in 1138 |
keep, part of a valid categorisation scheme, and per precedent of other "by <period>" cats |
May 22
|
|
Category:Natural family planning |
delete
Category:Natural family planning and
Category:Fertility awareness, as they were both empty; I think that takes care of everything; let me know if not. |
May 31
|
|
Category:Negro League teams |
merge |
May 16
|
|
Category:Neighbourhoods of Thailand |
Rename, as nominated and per convention |
May 27
|
|
Category:New York rappers |
merge |
May 17
|
|
Category:Newspapers by publication frequency and one layer of subcats |
Keep |
May 14
|
|
Category:Newsradio |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Night Court |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Noh Matta Wat! |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Non-ruling Austrian royalty |
merge |
May 22
|
|
Category:None-language films |
rename to
Category:Films without speech. There is clearly consensus for some kind of rename. In my opinion, "words" isn't specific enough, and dialogue is too specific, so I'm going with the middle ground |
May 30
|
|
Category:North America exclusive video games |
delete . — |
May 29
|
|
Category:Northeastern University, Boston |
Reverse Merge
Category:Northeastern University (Boston, Massachusetts) to
Category:Northeastern University, Boston per |
May 15
|
|
Category:Northern Exposure |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Norwegian Champions League winners |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:Notable Shastris |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Notable Tall Men |
delete |
May 19
|
|
Category:Novels by author |
no consensus, would suggest RFC given the scope of this suggestion |
May 4
|
|
Category:NYPD Blue |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Obsolete groups of creatures |
rename, to alternative and clearer title
Category:Obsolete taxonomic groups |
May 21
|
|
Category:Octagon-Shaped Buildings |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:October Road (TV series) |
no consensus |
May 11
|
|
Category:Odense BK players |
rename per nom |
May 23
|
|
Category:Ohio Bobcats basketball coaches |
rename
Category:Ohio Bobcats basketball coaches to
Category:Ohio Bobcats men's basketball coaches |
May 13
|
|
Category:Old Blues |
rename to
Category:Christ's Hospital Old Blues |
May 20
|
|
Category:Opening season television episodes |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Operas by Gioacchino Rossini |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Order of Logohu |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Organ transplant recipients |
No Consensus |
May 1
|
|
Category:Orson |
merge the two cover art categories to
Category:Orson (band) images, keep albums and songs, no consensus on the parent category |
May 9
|
|
Category:Orthodox Judaism by city |
keep. The argument for deletion that a category is unpopulated should always be deferred to allow time for the category to be populated; and I don't see any other substantial argument for deletion |
May 8
|
|
Category:Over There (TV series) |
delete |
May 9
|
|
Category:Oxyrhynchus manuscripts |
merge per nom |
May 20
|
|
Category:Oz (TV series) |
keep |
May 11
|
|
Category:Pages with special characters |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:Pakistani |
Merge to
Category:Pakistani people |
May 18
|
| Palestine to Palestinian territories renames |
rename |
May 25
|
| Palestine-related CFRs |
rename per amended proposals (specifically, splitting "Archaeological sites" and "Monasteries" categories) |
May 11
|
| Palestininian territories to Palestinian National Authority rename |
no consensus |
May 25
|
|
Category:Palindromic places |
Listify and Delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Pampanga Festivals |
Rename to
Category:Festivals in Pampanga |
May 18
|
|
Category:Panchira |
merge |
May 20
|
|
Category:Parish |
rename (see {{
UK Parish}} for details) |
May 13
|
|
Category:Parishes in Lancashire |
merge, as duplicate and for consistency with similarly-scoped category names |
May 22
|
|
Category:Parishes on the Isle of Wight |
merge, as duplicate and for consistency with similarly-scoped category names |
May 22
|
|
Category:Paul is dead |
deferred to the AFD. If the AFD results in deletion, this cat can be deleted as empty. If not, keep it per this debate |
May 4
|
|
Category:Peace treaties of the Ottoman Empire |
keep. There may be something to be said for merging this to "treaties" in general, but that should be discussed for the tree as a whole, in a new nom |
May 19
|
|
Category:Peak Tram |
delete |
May 5
|
|
Category:Peole from Nuneaton |
Speedy deleted
CSD G7 |
May 30
|
|
Category:People associated with Dark Shadows |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:People by city in Northern Ireland |
rename x3 |
May 16
|
|
Category:People from Mexico City, Mexico |
merge |
May 17
|
|
Category:People from Mexico |
redirect |
May 17
|
|
Category:People from Naples |
egrem |
May 16
|
|
Category:People of Grenadian origin |
rename |
May 3
|
|
Category:People of Irish descent in Great Britain |
keep |
May 11
|
|
Category:People of Jewish descent |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:People of Philippine descent |
no consensus |
May 10
|
|
Category:People opposed to apartheid |
delete |
May 27
|
|
Category:People who have at some stage claimed they are not gay |
speedy delete. I know that this exact name hasn't been on CFD before, but I still believe that this is recreated content |
May 27
|
|
Category:People who have declined a British honour |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:Perfect Strangers |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Pericope Adulteræ |
delete. |
May 23
|
|
Category:Periodic abstinence |
Delete. A lot of discussion, but no discernible conclusions have emerged. However category is empty so eligible for deletion per
WP:CSD#C1 |
May 13
|
|
Category:Philippine Christian School |
merge |
May 5
|
|
Category:Philippine Festivals |
Rename to
Category:Festivals in the Philippines |
May 18
|
|
Category:Piergiorgio Lucidi albums |
speedy delete (empty) |
May 31
|
|
Category:Pilgrim route |
rename |
May 19
|
|
Category:Pirates of the Caribbean locations |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Pirates of the Caribbean ships |
merge
Category:Pirates of the Caribbean ships to
Category:Fictional ships |
May 28
|
|
Category:Pittsburg Steelers players |
speedy delete (empty) |
May 10
|
|
Category:Places in Brunei |
upmerge (and since this category is empty, that means delete) |
May 27
|
|
Category:Plant diseases |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:Pogroms |
rename/merge as nominated; if when complete, someone wants to create a jewish specific category, please do so |
May 29
|
|
Category:Polish operas |
Merge |
May 15
|
|
Category:Polish primates |
Rename |
May 9
|
| Political parties in the UK |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:Population groups of mixed ancestry |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Portland millennial art renaissance |
delete |
May 25
|
| Prelates |
rename or delete per nomination |
May 27
|
|
Category:Prestige vehicles |
Delete |
May 18
|
| Pretender categories |
keep |
May 28
|
|
Category:Pretenders to the Egyptian throne |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:Primates (bishops) |
rename |
May 13
|
|
Category:Primates of Independent Catholic Churches |
no real consensus, except perhaps for a renom of all cats |
May 30
|
|
Category:Primates of the Anglican Church of Southern Africa |
Rename |
May 9
|
|
Category:Primates of the Assyrian Church of the East |
keep |
May 9
|
|
Category:Primates of the Catholicosate of India of the Malankara Syriac Orthodox Church |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Primates of the Catholicosate of the East and Malankara Metropolitanate of the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church |
merge into
Category:Catholicoses of the East |
May 24
|
|
Category:Primates of the Catholicosate of the Holy See of Cilicia |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Primates of the Catholicosate of the Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin and All Armenians |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Primates of the Catholicosate Patriarchate of Babylon of the Holy Apostolic Catholic Assyrian Church of the East |
rename
Category:Primates of the Catholicosate Patriarchate of Babylon of the Holy Apostolic Catholic Assyrian Church of the East to
Category:Catholicos Patriarchs of the Assyrian Church of the East |
May 30
|
|
Category:Primates of the Chaldean Catholic Patriarchate of Babylon |
rename |
May 1
|
|
Category:Primates of the Coptic Orthodox Patriarchate of Alexandria and of All Africa |
rename |
May 25
|
|
Category:Primates of the Eritrean Orthodox Tewahdo Church |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Primates of the Georgian Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Catholicosate Patriarchate of All Georgia |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Primates of the Maronite Catholic Patriarchate of Antioch and the Whole East |
rename |
May 1
|
|
Category:Primates of the Patriarchial Catholicosate of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church and All Ethiopia |
merge into
Category:Patriarchs of Ethiopia |
May 24
|
|
Category:Primates of the Roman Catholic Church of Ireland |
delete. See top of the page |
May 17
|
|
Category:Primates of the Russian Orthodox Patriarchate of Moscow and All Russia |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Primates of the Syriac Orthodox Patriarchate of Antioch and All the East |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:Prince-Bishoprics of Estonia |
keep |
May 2
|
|
Category:Prisoners convicted of white-collar crimes |
rename to "white collar criminals" |
May 26
|
|
Category:Procedure law |
rename to
Category:Legal procedure |
May 11
|
|
Category:Processed tomato products |
rename per nom |
May 24
|
|
category:Procol Harum Musicians |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Programming typefaces |
Delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Prominent Sherbro Families |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Protected species in Hong Kong |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:Psychodynamic psychotherapy |
already merged to
Category:Psychodynamics. This appears to have occurred without consensus, so this is closed with no prejudice toward recreation |
May 8
|
|
Category:Public intellectuals |
Delete |
May 7
|
|
Category:Pubs in Cheshire |
merge |
May 5
|
|
Category:Quality Guru |
rename |
May 6
|
|
Category:Quantum Leap |
delete |
May 16
|
|
Category:Quebec films |
Rename to
Category: Quebecois films |
May 15
|
|
Category:Queen (band) songs |
keep |
May 30
|
|
Category:Queens (NY) rappers |
Replaced by a more complete nomination above |
May 17
|
|
Category:R. Kelly |
delete |
May 23
|
| Railroad museums and tourist lines in the United States |
no consensus, because it is unclear what the nominator intended |
May 12
|
|
Category:Rapper/actors |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Pacem in Terris Peace and Freedom Award |
delete, as overcategorisation |
May 21
|
|
Category:Redirects for names |
rename. BHG is right: the category shouldn't be deleted unless the template is. But it should be named to match the template |
May 6
|
|
Category:Redirects from New York City area bus labels |
rename to
Category:Redirects from New York City area bus routes |
May 6
|
| Referendums by country |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:Referendums |
withdrawn |
May 3
|
|
Category:Reichmann family |
delete. That we have categories for some families is not a priori an argument for having a category on this family, especially if the cat has only a handful of family members and the rest is about buildings. That the family is notable is grounds for keeping the article. The comparison with the Rothschilds lacks several orders of magnitude |
May 16
|
|
Category:Resident Commissioner of Puerto Rico |
egrem |
May 16
|
|
Category:Retro fiction anime |
Delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Rhythmic contemporary musicians |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:RiffTrax movies |
keep. |
May 22
|
|
Category:Rivers in Ettelbruck |
rename |
May 12
|
| Rivers in Foo |
rename all to Rivers of Foo per nom |
May 19
|
|
Category:Rivers in London |
rename |
May 12
|
|
Category:Roberts family |
{{
listify}} |
May 29
|
|
Category:Roman admirals |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:Roman Catholic Primates of All Ireland |
delete. See top of the page |
May 17
|
|
Category:Roman Catholic Primates of Ireland |
delete both |
May 17
|
| Roman Catholic Primates |
merge |
May 20
|
|
Category:Roman jurists |
Rename
Category:Roman jurists to
Category:Ancient Roman jurists |
May 10
|
|
Category:Roman multiple people |
Rename to
Category:Ancient Roman multiple people |
May 18
|
|
Category:Roman officers surviving Cannae |
delete |
May 20
|
|
Category:Roman priests |
Rename
Category:Roman priests to
Category:Ancient Roman priests |
May 10
|
|
Category:Romani people |
redirected |
May 16
|
|
Category:Romantic interests of Elliott Smith |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:Romantischen Opern |
keep |
May 1
|
|
Category:Rosicrucian Enlightenment |
delete |
May 22
|
|
Category:Royal ranks and titles |
Rename to
Category:Royal titles |
May 18
|
|
Category:Rugby in the Isle of Man |
rename |
May 25
|
|
Category:Russian and Soviet Screenwriters |
rename to
Category:Soviet screenwriters |
May 18
|
| Ryan Mappin |
speedy close, there is no such category; nomination appears to refer to the article
Ryan Mappin, which has been speedd deleted |
May 9
|
|
Category:Sabit İnce |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Sadistic horror films |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Scary Movie films |
Delete due to existing navigation template, (per
WP:CLS). If there was more to the category than just the 5 eponymous articles, this would probably have been No consensus, per Otto4711, et al |
May 10
|
|
Category:SCTV |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Secondary schools by country |
rename |
May 18
|
|
Category:Secularism |
delete |
May 22
|
|
Category:Seiyū management companies |
rename |
May 12
|
| Serif typeface classifications |
Reame |
May 15
|
|
Category:Set index articles |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Settlements established in 1890s |
speedily deleted per author request |
May 30
|
|
Category:Sex and the City |
no consensus |
May 11
|
|
Category:SFC Terriers men's basketball coaches |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:Shared IP cats |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:Shorty McShorts' Shorts |
Delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Sigma Alpha Epsilon |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Sigma Phi Epsilon brothers,
Category:Pi Lambda Phi brothers,
Category:Phi Sigma Kappa brothers,
Category:Lambda Chi Alpha brothers,
Category:Delta Kappa Epsilon brothers,
Category:Alpha Tau Omega brothers,
Category:Alpha Kappa Psi brothers and
Category:Alpha Delta Phi brothers |
delete all |
May 10
|
|
Category:Siniestro Sin |
Delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Sitcoms in Canada |
rename |
May 24
|
|
Category:Sivaji: The Boss songs |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:Sivaji: The Boss |
delete. The songs category is to be deleted, rendering Tim's opinion moot |
May 13
|
|
Category:Sixty Years' War |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Sketch comedy shows in Canada |
rename
Category:Sketch comedy shows in Canada to
Category:Canadian sketch comedy shows |
May 24
|
|
Category:Skins actors |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:Skins |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Sleeper Cell (TV series) |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:Snakes of the Korean Peninsula |
merge
Category:Snakes of the Korean Peninsula to
Category:Reptiles of Asia |
May 24
|
|
Category:Snow Wikis |
delete |
May 2
|
|
Category:Songs by composer |
rename |
May 7
|
| Category:Songs by songwriter |
insufficient participation to overturn last week's debate. Suggest wider advertising and/or deletion review |
May 17
|
|
Category:Songs by songwriter |
keep (no rename) |
May 18
|
|
Category:Sophomore albums |
delete along with
Category:Second albums |
May 7
|
|
Category:Sort algorithms |
rename, as nominated |
May 24
|
|
Category:South American writers |
"no consensus (keep)". The category has been greatly reshaped since it was nominated. I suggest that those still concerned continue discussions on the categories talk page if there are still issues. --
☑ |
May 14
|
|
Category:South Korean Drama on Philippine TV |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:Southwestern Dinosaurs |
delete |
May 2
|
|
Category:South_American_historians |
rename |
May 2
|
|
Category:Soviet crimes |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Soy products |
egrem |
May 22
|
|
Category:Space: 1999 - First Series Episodes |
merge
Category:Space: 1999 - First Series Episodes to
Category:Space: 1999 episodes |
May 30
|
|
Category:Space: 1999 vehicles |
No Consensus. No appetite to keep, but no clear view has emerged as to exactly where this should be merged |
May 13
|
|
Category:Spanish language novels |
Keep. The reason is this category belongs to its
Category:Spanish-language media. |
May 14
|
|
Category:Spanish-language writers |
Keep. The reason is this category is a subcat of
Category:Writers by language. Suggest the nominator should bring the categorization structure for discussion. |
May 14
|
|
Category:Spay/neuter organizations |
merge |
May 23
|
|
Category:Species native to Hong Kong |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Spooks episodes by series |
merge to
Category:Spooks episodes |
May 25
|
| Spooks episodes |
merge |
May 25
|
|
Category:Spooks locations |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:Spooks series by episode |
merge per above |
May 25
|
|
Category:Sport by continent |
keep |
May 29
|
|
Category:Sport Car Racing infoboxes |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Sports Administrators |
merge |
May 2
|
|
Category:Sports in Houston |
merge |
May 11
|
|
Category:Stade Français footballers |
not CfD business, no action needed |
May 24
|
|
Category:Star formation |
keep |
May 6
|
|
Category:Star Trek behind the scenes |
delete |
May 19
|
| State treasurers of the United States |
Rename except for Florida |
May 13
|
|
Category:Static Shock |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Statistics of India |
merge |
May 20
|
|
Category:Stop motion-animated films |
rename to
Category:Stop-motion animated films |
May 22
|
|
Category:Structures celebrating the third millennium |
rename |
May 12
|
|
Category:Super Robot Monkey Team Hyperforce Go! |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Super Smash Bros. fighters |
no consensus. Note that the
TfD discussion on the template also ended without consensus, so this issue may need further discussion |
May 23
|
|
Category:Super Smash Bros. games |
merge
Category:Super Smash Bros. games to
Category:Super Smash Bros. |
May 28
|
|
Category:Superheroes by race and subcats |
no consensus |
May 24
|
|
Category:Supporters of apartheid |
delete, no prejudice against creation of "activist" category |
May 30
|
|
Category:Supporters of the 2003 Iraq conflict |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:Suzuka Files |
rename
Category:Suzuka Files to
Category:Suzuka (manga) |
May 13
|
|
Category:Symbols of Poland |
Rename |
May 15
|
|
Category:Syncretic Faiths |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Talossa |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Tanner '88 |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:Television shows set in Los Angeles |
withdrawn |
May 14
|
|
Category:Television stations |
keep, except rename
Category:Israeli television channels to
Category:Television channels in Israel |
May 30
|
|
Category:Television writers by series |
Rename |
May 15
|
|
Category:Templates for deletion |
rename |
May 12
|
|
Category:Ten-pin bowling movies |
merge
Category:Ten-pin bowling movies to
Category:Films about bowling |
May 10
|
|
Category:Thanksgiving films |
Delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:That '70s Show |
Merge |
May 11
|
|
Category:The 10th Kingdom |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:The 72 names on the Eiffel Tower |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:The A-Team |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:The Amanda Show |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:The Apprentice |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:The Batman episodes |
withdrawn by nominator |
May 20
|
|
Category:The Beatles films |
listify and delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:The Beatles places |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:The Beatles with Tony Sheridan |
delete |
May 5
|
|
Category:The Beatles' children |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:The Critic |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:The Drew Carey Show |
delete |
May 12
|
|
Category:The Football League players |
keep
Category:The Football League players, no consensus on
Category:The Football League players (current) |
May 11
|
| [[:Category:The Goodies (TV series) ==== ]] |
Withdrawn |
[[Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2007 May 11#Category:The Goodies (TV series) ==== |May 11]]
|
|
Category:The Goodies episodes |
no consensus |
May 13
|
|
Category:The Honeymooners |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:The Jeffersons |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:The Man Show |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:The Naked Brothers Band |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:The Nanny (TV series) |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:The Nick Cannon Show |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:The Nine (TV series) |
Rename |
May 13
|
|
Category:The O.C. Media |
rename |
May 11
|
|
Category:The O.C. |
keep |
May 11
|
|
Category:The Peak |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:The Practice |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:The Quarrymen |
delete. |
May 4
|
|
Category:The Red Green Show |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:The Restless Years |
Delete |
May 13
|
|
Category:The Simple Life |
delete |
May 30
|
|
Category:The Twilight Zone writers |
Delete |
May 15
|
|
Category:The Ultimate Fighter |
delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:The Wire (TV series) |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Thor Villains |
delete and salt |
May 31
|
|
Category:Three Point Play |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Too Few Viewpoints |
rename |
May 25
|
|
Category:Tough Enough |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:Toy makers |
keep as {{
categoryredirect}}s |
May 20
|
|
Category:Treaties of Native Americans |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:Trickjumping |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:Trinidadian artists |
merge |
May 20
|
|
Category:Trinidadian painters |
merge |
May 20
|
|
Category:Trollz |
delete |
May 24
|
|
Category:True vipers - Common names |
rename, as per above |
May 5
|
|
Category:True vipers - Synonymy |
rename, and yes, we have an automated way of doing this. I suppose it should be "synonyMs" rather than "synonyNs" |
May 5
|
|
Category:Tucker Family |
"delete" --
☑ |
May 14
|
|
Category:Turkish people of Azeri descent |
merge
Category:Turkish people of Azeri descent to
Category:Azerbaijani Turkish |
May 28
|
|
Category:Tux |
delete. Would suggest dropping the pictures in
Category:Linux |
May 4
|
|
Category:Types of resort |
rename
Category:Types of resort to
Category:Resorts by type |
May 13
|
|
Category:UIC Flames men's basketball players |
keep as is |
May 24
|
|
Category:UK Liberal Party |
merge
Category:UK Liberal Party to
Category:Liberal Party (UK) |
May 10
|
|
Category:Uncials |
Rename to
Category:Greek New Testament uncials |
May 16
|
|
Category:Unicode script |
delete |
May 3
|
|
Category:United States Delegates from Dakota Territory |
rename |
May 16
|
|
Category:United States elections, 1997 |
merge |
May 4
|
|
Category:United States Navy cruiser subtypes |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:United States Navy heavy cruisers |
delete |
May 28
|
|
Category:University and college namesakes |
delete |
May 11
|
|
Category:University Associations |
merge
Category:University Associations to
Category:University associations and consortia |
May 13
|
|
Category:University of Chattanooga alumni |
rename |
May 2
|
|
Category:University of Ghent alumni |
rename, as nominated |
May 20
|
|
Category:University of Illinois alumni |
keep |
May 1
|
| University presidents |
rename everything to "presidents of": |
May 9
|
| University presidents |
rename all |
May 27
|
|
Category:Unsuccessful U.S. House of Representatives candidates |
delete |
May 8
|
|
Category:Urban history |
merge |
May 16
|
|
Category:Users names that are Vancyon |
speedy delete as empty and as nonsense |
May 22
|
| Various categories about African Americans |
keep-all. I mean keep all. |
May 31
|
|
Category:Vegetarians and subcats |
no consenus, although a narrow majority (but not a
supermajority) of editors preferred keeping the categories. One view holds that vegetarianaism is purely a dietary choice and hence is not a defining characteristic, but that argument is countered by the view that
vegetarianism is often an ethical or philosophical choice as well as dietary one. The counter-argument is that since vegetarianism is the norm within some religions, it is not a defining characteristic of, e.g. a Hindu (see
Vegetarianism#Motivations_and_benefits); that argument sounds persuasive, but it doesn't address the question of vegetarians who are not motivated by the strict dictates of a particular religion. A further discussion may want to consider religious vegetarianism separately from secular vegetarianism |
May 24
|
|
Category:Verified Federally Recognized Tribes |
delete |
May 20
|
|
Category:Video games based on Disney Cartoons |
Merge |
May 15
|
|
Category:Video games based on wrestling |
merge per nom |
May 19
|
|
Category:Villages in Lubartów County |
merge
Category:Villages in Lubartów County to
Category:Villages in Lublin Voivodeship |
May 29
|
|
Category:Villages in Oxfordshire without Lamp Posts |
Speedy delete nonsense |
May 23
|
|
Category:Villages in Saddleworth |
merge
Category:Villages in Saddleworth to
Category:Villages in Greater Manchester |
May 28
|
|
Category:Villages of Teslić, Bosnia and Herzegovina |
merge
Category:Villages of Teslić, Bosnia and Herzegovina to
Category:Villages in Bosnia and Herzegovina |
May 1
|
|
Category:Visions |
Delete |
May 18
|
|
Category:Visitor attractions in Key West, Florida |
one of the categories already speedied |
May 10
|
|
Category:Volcanoes by height |
delete, suggest creating a
List of volcanoes by elevation similar to the one for mountains |
May 20
|
|
Category:Vox Humana 8'/Photos |
delete. Can't userfy a category |
May 21
|
|
Category:WABC-TV |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Walker, Texas Ranger |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:Waterfalls of Karnataka |
keep |
May 2
|
|
Category:Waterloo Road |
No Consensus - Feel free to renominate for further discussion once the potential members become more stable (as articles or redirects or whatever) |
May 10
|
|
Category:Wealthy fictional characters |
No Consensus |
May 15
|
|
Category:Weapons and items from The Legend of Zelda series |
merge |
May 22
|
|
Category:Webcasters in California |
speedy deleted |
May 26
|
|
Category:Webcasters in north america by country |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Webcasters in united states by state |
delete |
May 26
|
|
Category:Webcasters in united states |
speedy deleted |
May 26
|
|
Category:Websites running the LiveJournal engine |
delete |
May 6
|
|
Category:Welsh dragon |
delete |
May 17
|
|
Category:Western Illinois Leathernecks men's basketball coaches |
rename. Rationale makes sense and no objection has been raised. — |
May 19
|
|
Category:Western Lakes Confederacy |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:Whaling stations of South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands |
delete. This category is effectively an end-run around the debate on May 13, to rename the other cat to this one, and which does not appear to have consensus to rename |
May 17
|
|
Category:Whaling stations of South Georgia |
Rename to
Category:Whaling stations of South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands per discussion and for consistency with parent category |
May 13
|
|
Category:What I Like About You |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:What's Happening!! |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Wife of Malaysians Prime Minister |
rename
Category:Wife of Malaysians Prime Minister to
Category:Spouses of the Prime Ministers of Malaysia |
May 31
|
|
Category:Wikipedia games |
lack of consensus. I would suggest that a better way of tackling this would be by dropping the actual game pages on
WP:MFD; if consensus is to delete those, this category should be deleted as empty |
May 12
|
|
Category:Wikipedia rquested photographs in the British Virgin Islands |
speedy delete as a user requested deletion. - |
May 30
|
|
Category:Wikipedia Temples Created By User:ISOLA'd ELBA |
deleted per
WP:SNOW as an obvious misuse of the category namespace. Allow me to introduce you to
Special:Prefixindex |
May 17
|
|
Category:Wikipedians by alma mater: Queen's University |
moved to
WP:UCFD |
May 27
|
|
Category:WikiProject Color articles needing infobox sources |
keep |
May 27
|
| Wikiproject Georgia (country) articles |
rename all. — |
May 28
|
|
Category:WikiProject Invader Zim members |
delete |
May 4
|
|
Category:WikiProject Irish Music participants |
moved to
WP:UCFD |
May 22
|
|
Category:WikiProject Religion pages |
merge to
Category:WikiProject Religion articles |
May 22
|
|
Category:WikiProject Stargate templates |
merge |
May 16
|
| Wild 'N Out |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Will & Grace |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Wilt Chamberlain |
delete |
May 21
|
|
Category:Women obsessed characters |
"Delete" --
☑ |
May 14
|
|
Category:Wonder Showzen |
delete |
May 10
|
|
Category:Works by Andrew Lloyd Webber |
rename |
May 20
|
|
Category:Works by artist |
keep |
May 2
|
|
Category:Works by Germaine Tailleferre |
speedy rename |
May 8
|
|
Category:Works by Phidias |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:Works of Polyclitus |
rename |
May 5
|
|
Category:World Cup cricketers of East Africa |
delete |
May 25
|
|
Category:World Cup of Baseball |
Rename |
May 14
|
| World music WikiProject rename |
rename as nominated, but with importance decapitalized |
May 29
|
|
Category:World of Warcraft instances |
delete |
May 13
|
| World War memorials |
rename |
May 25
|
| Wrong title categories |
delete |
May 29
|
|
Category:Xenu |
no consensus. Would suggest a new nomination to debate the suggested rename |
May 22
|
|
Category:Xeric grant winners |
listify and delete |
May 10
|
| Years of the 17th century in the United Kingdom |
delete |
May 1
|
|
Category:Yonkers (NY) rappers |
Replaced by a more complete nomination above |
May 17
|