The result wasWithdrawn by nominator while I still have concerns about notability, the sourcing is still incidental accounts in relation to John Howard the recent editing of the article by Sarah and Lester has removed the serious issues of it being a John Howard attack page and POV fork. Gnan garra 00:33, 2 September 2007 (UTC) reply
Lyall Howard the article says He is notable for being the father of current Australian Prime Minister, John Howard., notability isn't inherited. Additionally WP:BIO#Criteria for notability of people has 6 criteria for people, Lyall doesn't meet any of them. Lyall's service records shows no decorations or mentions in dispatches only that he was gased in france, as was tens of thousands of other soldiers he was discharged as a private so theres no rank to establish notability. Owner of a service station isnt notable, only the PNG plantation issue gets close, but that's WP:BLP1E and the use of dummies/proxies wasn't confined to just Lyall, which then has undue weight issues in that 2 of the 4 properties were purchased by Lyall's father Walter yet this article focus is on Lyall but includes Walter's property in every statement. Gnan garra 15:09, 29 August 2007 (UTC) reply