The result was delete. JForget 21:54, 11 August 2009 (UTC) reply
Nomination on behalf of User:Andreasmperu, who does not believe the subject meets WP:PROF, writing that:
The Universidad Nacional Federico Villarreal (Lima) (where he teaches) is not considered even in the top 10 of the universities in Peru (you can see here it's at the 48th place), so I can't imagine what relevance has at a global level. The so-called publications aren't in scientific journals peer-rewiewed, but in student journals or other journals available to any person not necessarily academic. And he is not cited for anybody, he is not even well-known in the peruvian academic media. He had not received any award or recognition from any institution (less from a prestigious one). Worse, he hasn't earn any graduate degree in philosophy (not a master not a Ph.D.).
I declined the A7 on this in light of the article's several (unproven) claims to notability, but have no position on this debate. Skomorokh 08:36, 4 August 2009 (UTC) reply