The result was Moved. Well, this could have been closed a few days earlier, as someone already moved it elsewhere. — fetch · comms 01:44, 30 July 2010 (UTC) reply
COMPLETELY unsourced, intricate, unuseful list. The description says "List of South Korean musical bands who have been called "teen idols" by the media; why do we need such a list? Anyway, it is coupletely unsourced, making it even worse. See wp:IINFO, WP:NOTDIR, WP:LSC, WP:SALAT, the relevant policies or guidelines. This list is interesting only to those who created it. Maybe we should create an article called South Korean teen idols or Teen idol music instead, or merge the relevant entries to other articles or categories. Maashatra11 ( talk) 12:31, 20 July 2010 (UTC) reply
Good Points | Bad Points |
---|---|
This list/article tells which band debuted in which year making it good for a comparison. This is unlike List of K-pop artists. In case of bands, categorizing is helpful. | It is a list (like a directory) while it should be an article. I suggest it should be moved because it only serves the purpose of List of K-pop artists (K-pop does not mean it would include rock and ballad Korean artists/bands). |
General knowledge like 'gender' and '# members' is NEEDED. Band is not only its name. There is a difference between a 3 member band and 13 member band. There is always a difference between Male and Female bands. They don't need to be sourced. It would be just dumb. As if Barack Obama is a male or a female (Prove it!). :P Use common sense. | Too much trivial (not general) knowledge which is unsourced. Columns like 'leader', 'breakup' and 'references and notes' should be removed. (Since none of them are sourced and would be present in the provided link to the respective band article anyway). 'Record Label' should be removed as well. |
All entries are notable since they have their own articles. The list contain not only K-Pop bands but as well as others like TRAX. This might conflict with List of Korean musicians or List of K-pop artists. But the content is similar. If it is possible to make another section in 'List of Korean Musicians' or 'List of K-pop artists' that only lists the bands (not solo artists), then I suggest merging of this article with either of them. | 'Teen Idols'? There is no criteria for being a teen idol. The title should be changed into "South Korean bands" only. |