The result was Keep. I did not perceive any policy-based arguments from the Delete voters that such a list should not exist at all. Provided that a list is not dominated by red links (suggesting it is not useful for navigation), a list like this ought to be allowed to exist if it is useful. It is easy to tell if something is a German-language film, so the list inclusion criterion is obvious. Saying that films are not here which ought to be is an issue that can be fixed in the normal editing process. Over time, this list could expand to include all the German-language films that have Wikipedia articles, which I believe would satisfy the 'comprehensiveness' requirement of the Featured List criteria. EdJohnston ( talk) 18:39, 23 May 2008 (UTC) reply
Indiscriminate list that will never be complete (according to imdb there are more than 30,000 German language films). The Category:German-language films serves already the purpose of making it easy to find German language films. Novidmarana ( talk) 22:35, 14 May 2008 (UTC) reply
*Delete as
content fork due to the
List of German films article already existing and listing notable German films.
Nk.sheridan
Talk 23:34, 14 May 2008 (UTC)
reply