The result was delete. Martijn Hoekstra ( talk) 18:59, 6 March 2012 (UTC) reply
Author is (or has been) a "physics professor" at University of Regina. He is not listed on their website any more, but given that it was his first position after completing his postdoc, this was likely at the assistant professor level. the citation and publication data given in the article are, at first sight, stellar. This is deceptive, however: subject is first nor last author on any of the important ones, which have sometimes over 3000 (three-thousand!) authors. Apparently, Benslama was (is?) a member of several (very large) consortia and as is often the case in these mega physics projects, co-authors all papers coming out of it. However, there is no evidence that he had anything more than a very minor role. In conclusion, there is no real evidence of notability, does not meet WP:PROF. Hence: delete. Guillaume2303 ( talk) 19:37, 27 February 2012 (UTC) reply
Dear Guillaume,
You lost any credibility in this case. You went beyond your way to ask for the deletion of my article in wiki french, after I told you it is published in the french wiki. I think this speaks volumes about your unfairness. I think you are taking this case very personally and this is against the wiki recommendations. You simply violated the neutrality article of the editors of wikipedia. Therefore, I respectfully request that another admin. takes care of this case. You have expressed your opinion and now it is time not to interfere since you are taking things personally. In fact I find it lamentable, you went ahead and interfered in the french version, knowing that you are strongly involved in the English one. This is unacceptable! Kamalbenslama ( talk) 12:53, 4 March 2012 (UTC) reply