The result was keep. The article passes WP:GNG and is notable (non-admin closure) ~ Amkgp 💬 15:13, 28 August 2020 (UTC)
[Hide this box] New to Articles for deletion (AfD)? Read these primers!
I checked all the sources again after the previous nomination. Here’s a quick analysis: Source
№4 appears to be a paid press material (see ‘IBT does not endorse any of the above content’ tag; compare with
another random material that was written by internal editor), moreover, Indian Edition of the ibtimes.com site is a questionable source for a whole biography. Sources
№1 and
5 primarily discuss the scandal of Mitroshina being banned from entering Ukraine after her controversial statements. Article’s biography heavily relies on the source №1, while the biography segment in this source is a shortened copy of the source №4 (mentioned previously). Sources
№2
3,
6,
7,
8 primarily cover a social media flash mob aimed to bring attention to the domestic violence issues in Russia. Mitroshina is credited as a ‘campaign organizer’ alongside with another person, which basically stands for her being the first one on Russian Instagram to post a photo (which is present in the infobox at the moment) with a hashtag #IDidn’tWantToDie drawing attention to the matter. I want to note that this is neither a movement, nor an organization; for instance, Times indicates that was not the first or the only flash mob against domestic violence in Russia. All the accessible coverage of this flash mob is extremely limited by time and context, which, again, gives no cause to call it a significant movement. It is also important to point out that Mitroshina is mentioned among many other people who took initiative to stand against domestic violence in Russia. In a nutshell, 1) Mitroshina’s hashtag does not itself represent a significant movement against domestic violence in Russia, 2) There is no indication that this particular Instagram flash mob is notable enough to justify existence of this article. All the other present sources are either not reliable at all (gossip websites, promotional materials), or not independent. I couldn’t find any substantial coverage of Mitroshina’s activism - if we call her an activist; neither could I track any mentions of her notability in Russian culture in general - if we call her a writer or public figure. The article itself is written in an advertising manner (She gives lectures on mass media communications, blogging principles (Instalogy project) and fitness. In 2019, Mitroshina released the book "Promotion of personal blogs on Instagram: a step-by-step guide".) and I can’t see any reason to keep it on the English Wikipedia.
Juliette Han (
talk) 16:57, 17 May 2020 (UTC) struck due to votestack. See
Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Juliette Han/Archive
Spartaz
Humbug! 05:30, 21 August 2020 (UTC)
*Delete Blatant
WP:PROMO covered up by an experienced
WP:PAID editor from RuWiki. This
investigation and
this one on Russian Wiki say it all.
Tulpan64 (
talk) 10:22, 25 May 2020 (UTC) sock vote struck
Spartaz
Humbug! 05:30, 21 August 2020 (UTC)