|
This evaluation is still ongoing. I've started this page, so I can log information once I get it. |
To add to the knowledge I've decided to do my own random page test,which was originally concocted by Ambi and later repeated by many.
March 1, 2006 batch of 25 articles
| Article data | Article Assessment scores | ||||||||||||
| Article | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to* | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Norm McFarlaneE (p) |
September 10
2004 9 edits |
none | none | 1 ref | 1 cat | 2 articles, 2 lists | STUB | 6 | 6 - occasional odd phrasing. | N/A | 1 - nothing to enhance article. | 6 | Reasonable stub |
| Richard Thaler (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Bridge Records, Inc.E (p) |
August 10
2005 4 edits |
none | none | 1 link | 4 cats | 4 articles, 1 redirect | STUB | 3 - major omissions | 8 - writing is fine | 4 - big "see also" | 1 - none | 5 | Ad-like but founder was Grammy nominee. |
| Ngo Dinh Can (p) |
December 24
2005 6 edits |
none | none | 1 (dubious) | 4 cats | 2 articles, 1 list | SUBSTUB | 3 - bad coverage. | 9 | 1 - none to speak of. | 1 - none | 4 | bad coverage, dubious ref. |
| Bruderheim, Alberta (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Mount Blackwelder (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Al McKibbon (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Mammoth Spring, Arkansas (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Belgian football league system (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| 1856 in South Africa (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Liu XiaoguangE (p) |
February 22
2006 1 edit |
minor ones in tables | 2 on scores | none | 4 cats | 2 articles | STUB | 4 - few facts, no refs | 4 - short partial sentences, occasional UE tone. | 6 - sufficient | 6 - has tables, does little to make it attractive. | 5' - lacks refs and looks | needs refs and copyedit |
| Eric Griffiths (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| George YongeE (p) |
August 25
2004 15 edits |
none | 4 succession boxes | 1 link (ref buried) | 8 cats | 13 articles, 1 redirect | GOOD STUB | 6 - good info, but ref hidden on site. | 6 - dull but sound. | 7 - no headers, but good use of templates. | 5 - boxes look good, but not much else. | 6 - reasonable stub | Refs should be given directly. Link to page; not domain. |
| Guildford Flames (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Indian Lake (Massachusetts) (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| HidingE (p) |
January 29
2005 4 edits |
none | none | none | 1 cat | 1 article | DISAMBIGUATION | N/A | 5 - wordy | 4 - bad format | 5 | 5 | wordy dab; fixable |
| Ctenacodon (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Espirito Santo Trophy (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Negros Occidental (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Uetikon am See (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Stony Cove Pike (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Widawa (p) |
September 11
2005 3 edits |
none | none | none | 2 cats | 1 article | SUBSTUB | 1 | 1 - no full sentence. | 1 - no structure. | 1 | 1 - abysmal | One sentence substub. |
| Jodi Benson (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Spun aluminum (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
| Multiple access (p) | Creation date | Images | Tables | Refs/links | Categories | Linked to | Status | Coverage/Facts | Writing | Structure | Aesthetics | Overall | Comments |
- excluding userpages.
I edited articles labelled E after evaluating them.
Images in stub tags and small flags aren't counted.
Results
Following the collection of data resulting from <number> random article searches, I have come up with the following statistics.
| Type of article | Percentage |
| Full articles | x% |
| Stubs | x% |
| Substubs | x% |
| Disambiguation | x% |
| Articles from public sources | x% |
| Rambot articles | x% |
| Charts | x% |
| Lists | x% |
| Requiring substantial cleanup | x% |
| Should be redirected | x% |
| Dubious articles | x% |
| Deletables | x% |