This editor's record of completed 4Award reviews with rationale and supporting links.
Completed 5 January 2015.
1. Did the editor contribute to the transition between a redlink and the article's very first encyclopedic content?
2. Was the editor involved in the DYK nomination achievement? Just being involved in the nomination is not sufficient. Evaluate the editorial contributions.
==
3. Did the editor help the article through the GA promotion process?
4. If DYK and GA overlap significantly...(not applicable)
5. With the evolution of DYK to longer review periods... (not applicable)
6. Did the editor help the article during its FA promotion process? Look at the FAC discussions, peer reviews and the article history. The credit is a determination of the editorial activity that raised the quality from the GA level to the FA level.
Note that these four stages are very strict. An example of an article that is ineligible is Morotai Mutiny for which the GA nomination stage is not creditable to the "main editor" according to the talk page edit and the GAN edit.
Completed