The plot focuses on the fictionalised Davison, Baker and McCoy, who become disgruntled after discovering they haven't been invited to take part in the production of the Doctor Who 50th anniversary special. The trio become embroiled in misadventures as they attempt to sneak onto the set of the official Doctor Who 50th anniversary special.
In a park, actors
Sean Pertwee and
Olivia Colman discuss their upcoming projects. However, both reveal that they have not received calls about appearing in The Five(ish) Doctors Reboot, with Colman complaining as she believes that she is "usually in everything".
On Christmas Day 2012,
Fifth Doctor actor
Peter Davison watches "
The Snowmen" with his sons, Louis and Joel. They remark on the upcoming 50th anniversary special and speculate as to whether Davison will be invited to return or if it will simply feature the most recent two Doctors,
David Tennant and
Matt Smith. Davison has a dream where he is invited back and given special treatment, ending with a vision of
Janet Fielding telling him that none of the old Doctors will be asked to return. Over the next couple of months, he,
Sixth Doctor actor
Colin Baker and
Seventh Doctor actor
Sylvester McCoy desperately await a call inviting them to star in the special. A disillusioned Davison attends a convention, where he is unrecognised by a hotel receptionist and asked by fans if he has heard about appearing in the episode. He calls Doctor Who executive producer
Steven Moffat, who is more interested in playing with his action figures, and deletes his messages from Davison, as well as Baker and McCoy who have also called about appearing (McCoy mentions appearing in The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey and Baker mentions doing I'm a Celebrity...Get Me Out of Here!).
At another convention appearance, Davison, Baker and McCoy all eye
Eighth Doctor actor
Paul McGann suspiciously. They discuss inviting
Fourth Doctor actor
Tom Baker to help them get involved, but when they call him he is revealed to be stuck in the Time Vortex again. McGann, having received no Doctor Who news from his agent, says he wants in on their plans – "work permitting, obviously". After the convention, McCoy returns to
New Zealand to continue filming The Hobbit, but decides to return to England after director
Peter Jackson leaves him sitting around doing nothing. Davison's scheme is revealed to involve the three of them (McGann has
work commitments) protesting with picket signs outside the
BBC Television Centre in London. Meanwhile, back in New Zealand, McCoy's disappearance has ruined a scene with
Ian McKellen, though McKellen himself says to Jackson that the scene might be "a slight improvement" without McCoy. In London, a passing
John Barrowman informs the three actors that Doctor Who filming now takes place in
Cardiff. Barrowman abandons his secret wife and children to drive the trio there, singing
show tunes all the way and giving them each a copy of one of his
CDs.
The former Doctors enter the
Doctor Who Experience, steal their old costumes, and with the help of Tennant (Davison's son-in-law) are able to infiltrate
Roath Lock and get onto the set of the 50th anniversary special, "
The Day of the Doctor". They are initially unsure how to proceed with getting in the special, but end up taking the place of the three
Dalek operators after locking them in their room. After a close call with some security guards which leads to the trio having to hide back on the set, they manage to escape and catch a bus back to London. Davison receives a call and ignores it; it turns out to be former Doctor Who executive producer
Russell T Davies asking for a part in Davison's project, as he has also been left out of the 50th anniversary celebrations.
In the
coda, Moffat deletes the scene where the former Doctors play Daleks. However, when Moffat's editor reviews another scene, he sees the former Doctors evade the on-set security guards by hiding under shrouds in the undergallery set; the editor conceals this from Moffat, ensuring that the former Doctors appear in the special after all.
Cast
Most of the actors appear as themselves. The summary below lists their original connection to Doctor Who. This list features names in order of appearance
Nicholas Pegg – principal Dalek operator, writer and director of several Doctor Who audio plays at
Big Finish Productions and long-term partner of Barnaby Edwards
Nicholas Briggs – plays a Dalek operator. He is the voice artist of several Doctor Who monsters including the Daleks, director and writer of several Doctor Who audio plays (as well as the overall executive producer) at
Big Finish Productions.
Derek Ritchie – Doctor Who script editor from 2013 to 2016
Michael Houghton – plays a security guard. As Mike Houghton he was an editor in the Tom Baker and Davison eras, as well as on Davison's show A Very Peculiar Practice
Dan Starkey – originally played
Sontaran Commander Skorr in "
The Sontaran Stratagem", has played the character
Strax from 2011 to 2014 on television and since 2016 in Big Finish audios
Christian Brassington – actor who played Alfred Stahlbaum in the Doctor Who audio drama The Silver Turk, writing partner of
Georgia Tennant, and husband of Jennie Fava, who assistant directed the special and several series of Doctor Who.
Jemma Redgrave appears in the final scene on the computer monitor with Smith and Coleman.
John Hurt's voice can be heard through archive recordings from "The Day of the Doctor" with Smith and Tennant in the scene where Davison, Baker and McCoy arrive on set. Both are uncredited for these appearances.
Davison originally wrote a part for
Tom Baker. As Baker failed to respond to his emails, Davison used the same clip of unfinished Doctor Who story
Shada previously used in the 20th anniversary special The Five Doctors to jokingly explain his absence.[8]
Reviews
Ben Lawrence writing in The Telegraph gave the programme 4 stars (out of 5), describing it as "a sweet, often funny homage to the show," concluding that it "was both a satisfying in-joke for Whovians and a naughty dig at the neediness of actors."[3] Comparing the programme to the 50th anniversary special, Los Angeles Times Television Critic, Robert Lloyd, described it as "equally wonderful in its way".[2]
In June 2014,
Paul McGann stated that production had begun on a sequel to the special. No release date, plot or cast details were offered.[10] However, in July,
Colin Baker contradicted McGann's earlier statement by telling Flicks and the City: "All I know is when I last spoke to Peter [Davison], the reaction to Five-ish Doctors has been so positive that we discussed whether it was a good idea to do another one and we agreed that we didn’t want to do one that was a pale imitation of the first. That would be anti-climactic ... We have to come up with a really good idea first. There’s a couple of possibilities floating around, but nothing is set in stone. Clearly doing one about the 51st anniversary isn’t going to be interesting. It’s got to be about something else."[11] At a Doctor Who convention in March 2023,
Sylvester McCoy stated that there were plans to make a sequel for the show's 60th anniversary, but that the BBC would not allow it.[citation needed]