Sir Alexander James Edmund Cockburn, 12th BaronetGCB (24 December 1802 – 20 November 1880) was a British
jurist and politician who served as the
Lord Chief Justice for 21 years. He heard some of the leading causes célèbres of the nineteenth century.
Cockburn was born in
Altona, in what is now
Germany and was then part of
Brandenburg,[2][3] to Alexander Cockburn and his wife Yolande, daughter of René Michel de Vignier de La Saline, vicomte de Vignier,[4] of
Santo Domingo.[1][5] His father served as British Consul to Hamburg and the Hanse towns and later as
envoy extraordinary and minister
plenipotentiary to
Württemberg and the Republic of
Colombia;[6] he was the fourth son of
Sir James Cockburn, 8th Baronet (born c.1729, died July 1804), his three elder brothers having succeeded to the baronetcy, but died without heirs.
He was initially educated largely abroad and became fluent in
French and familiar with
German,
Italian and
Spanish. He was educated at
Trinity Hall, Cambridge, gaining a first in
Civil law in 1824–5 and graduating in 1829 with an
LL.B. degree, and also being elected a
fellow, and afterwards an honorary fellow.[7] He entered the
Middle Temple in 1825, and was
called to the bar in 1829. He joined the western circuit and built up a substantial practice though he was sufficiently diffident about his success in London to devote little of his energies there, not even keeping his
Chambers open.[5]
As advocate (1832–1847)
Three years after his call, the
Reform Bill was passed. Cockburn started to practise in
election law, including acting for
Henry Lytton Bulwer and
Edward Ellice. In 1833, with William Rowe, he published a parliamentary brief on the decisions of election committees. In 1834, Ellice recommended Cockburn as member of the commission to enquire into the state of the corporations of England and
Wales. Through his parliamentary work Cockburn met
Joseph Parkes and himself became interested in politics as a profession in itself, not simply as a pretext for legal argument. Cockburn had become ambitious and in 1838 he turned down the offer of a judicial appointment in India with the sentiment "I am going in for something better than that". He became
Recorder of
Southampton and from that point started to reduce his election and parliamentary work in favour of more publicly notorious cases. In 1841 he was made a
Q.C.[5]
Trial of Dr Cockburn: In 1841 a charge of
simony, brought against his uncle,
William,
Dean of York, enabled Cockburn to appear conspicuously in a case which attracted considerable public attention, the proceedings taking the form of a motion for
prohibition duly obtained against the
ecclesiastical court, which had deprived Dr Cockburn of his office.[1]
Daniel McNaghten: Sir
Robert Peel's secretary,
Edward Drummond, was shot by
Daniel McNaghten in 1843. Cockburn, briefed on behalf of the
assassin, made a speech which helped to establish the
insanity defence in Britain for the next century.[5] At the trial, Cockburn had made extensive and effective use of
Isaac Ray's Treatise on the Medical Jurisprudence of Insanity. Cockburn quoted extensively from the book which rejected traditional views of the
insanity defence based on the defendant's ability to distinguish "right from wrong" in favour of a broader approach based on
causation.[8][9] Cockburn displayed a mastery of the scientific evidence and was an innovator in exploiting
forensic science in court.[10]
The winner of the 1844 Derby: In 1844, he appeared in Wood v. Peel to determine the winner of a bet (the
Gaming Act 1845 deemed bets unenforceable in law) as to whether the
Derby winner Running Rein was a four-year-old or a three-year-old. Running Rein could not be produced when the judge,
Baron Alderson, demanded, and as a result Cockburn lost the case, while his strenuous advocacy of his client's cause had led him into making, in his opening speech, strictures on
Lord George Bentinck's conduct in the case which should have been held back.[11][12]
Lieutenant Henry Hawkey: In 1846 Hawkey, an officer of the Royal Marines, was tried for murder at Winchester assizes after shooting
James Alexander Seton in a
duel; Cockburn secured Hawkey's acquittal. James Seton was the last British person to be killed in a duel in the United Kingdom.
The Achilli trial: During the short administration of
Lord Derby, Cockburn was engaged against
Sir Frederic Thesiger Attorney General at the time, and for
John Henry Newman, in the case of a friar named
Giacinto Achilli who had accused Newman of libel. The jury who heard the case under
Lord Campbell found that Newman's plea of justification was not proved except in one particular, a verdict which, together with the methods of the judge and the conduct of the audience, attracted considerable comment.[1]
As law officer of the Crown (1850–1856)
Lord John Russell appointed Cockburn as Solicitor-General in 1850, and as Attorney General in 1851, which latter post he held until the resignation of the ministry in February 1852. In December 1852, under
Lord Aberdeen'sministry, Cockburn again became Attorney General, and remained so until 1856, taking part in many celebrated trials.[1] In 1854 Cockburn was made
Recorder of Bristol.
Cockburn shepherded through Parliament the Common Law Procedure Act 1852[13] and the Common Law Procedure Act 1854.[14]
William Palmer: In his tenure as Attorney General from 1852 to 1856, he led for the crown in the trial of
William Palmer of
Rugeley in Staffordshire, an ex-medical man who poisoned a friend named Cook with
strychnine in order to steal from his estate. Cockburn made an exhaustive study of the medical aspects of the case and won a conviction after a twelve-day trial, again demonstrating his skill with forensic science.[1]
Cockburn always sought out the most sensational cases and was astute in rearranging his diary so that he could sit in any trial likely to attract the attention of the press.[16]
Several Prime Ministers offered to nominate Cockburn for a peerage, and he finally accepted the offer in 1864. However, Queen Victoria refused, noting that "this peerage has been more than once previously refused upon the ground of the notoriously bad moral character of the Chief Justice".[17]
In 1875, the three English common law courts (the Queen's Bench, the
Court of Common Pleas, and the
Court of the Exchequer) merged to become divisions of the new
High Court of Justice. The head of each court (Lord Chief Justice Cockburn, Chief Justice of the Common Pleas
Lord Coleridge, and Chief Baron of the Exchequer Sir
Fitzroy Kelly) continued in post. After the deaths of Kelly and Cockburn in 1880, the three divisions were merged into a single division, with Lord Coleridge as Lord Chief Justice of England.[18]
The
Tichborne Case: Cockburn presided over the civil case in which
Arthur Orton attempted to establish his identity as the missing baronet Sir Roger Tichborne. This trial collapsed after 103 days, the longest civil trial on record. Cockburn then presided over the subsequent trial of Orton for
perjury, a famous trial that lasted 188 days, setting a record for criminal trials, of which Cockburn CJ's summing-up occupied eighteen.[1][20]
The Alabama claims: He also played a role in the arbitration of the Alabama claims at
Geneva in 1872, in which he represented the British government. He dissented from the majority view as to British liability for the actions of British-built privateer ships. He prepared the English translation of the arbitrators' award and published a controversial dissenting opinion in which he admitted British liability for the actions of the
CSS Alabama, though not on the grounds given in the award, and discounted liability for the
CSS Florida and
CSS Shenandoah.[1]
The
Overend-Gurney fraud trial: the trial of the partners of Overend & Gurney, a bank that had collapsed in spectacular circumstances following precarious risks taken by the managers. In his summing up, Cockburn expressed the view that the
defendants had been guilty of nothing more than "grave error".[22]
Woodley v. Metropolitan District Railway Co.:[23] Woodley was set to repair a wall in a darkened railway tunnel in which trains continued to run, without warning or dedicated lookout, and with barely sufficient clearance between train and wall for the workman to make himself safe when a train passed. Woodley was seriously injured when he reached across the rail for a tool and was struck by a passing train. Cockburn CJ held that the employer was not liable, invoking the principle of volenti non-fit injuria.[24]
The trial of
Boulton and Park for transvestism and "conspiring and inciting persons to commit an unnatural offence".[27]
The trial of
Henry Wainwright for murder.[28] The crime, in which Wainwright was arrested in possession of the dismembered body of his victim, was given more publicity at the time than those of
Jack the Ripper.[29]
In personal appearance Cockburn was of small stature with a large head, but possessed a very dignified manner. He enjoyed
yachting and other sport, and writing (he wrote an unpublished novel). Something of an adventurer in his youth, he was fond of socialising and womanising, fathering two illegitimate children. He "was also throughout his life addicted to frivolities not altogether consistent with advancement in a learned profession, or with the positions of dignity which he successively occupied." He lived for many years in some state at
Wakehurst Place in Sussex. In his later years, he reminisced, "Whatever happens, I have had my whack". He once had to escape through the window of the
robing room at
Rougemont Castle,
Exeter, to evade
bailiffs.[1][5] Shortly before he became Chief Justice of the Common Pleas, Cockburn was walking in London's
Haymarket with fellow barrister
William Ballantine when he saw a
police constable roughly handling a woman. The pair stopped to protest but found themselves accused of obstructing a constable in the execution of his duty, arrested by the constable and conveyed to
Vine Street Police Station. At the station they met an acquaintance who explained to the inspector who they were and they were released.[30]
The arms which an advocate wields he ought to use as a warrior, not as an assassin. He ought to uphold the interests of his clients per fas, not per nefas. He ought to know how to reconcile the interests of his clients with the eternal interests of truth and justice.
— The Times, 9 November 1864
As a judge he did not have the highest reputation, with a joke within the legal profession being that he became a first rate judge only because he sat with
Lord Blackburn.[5]Charles Francis Adams, Sr., a fellow judge on the Geneva tribunal to resolve the
Alabama claims issue, felt that Sir Alexander's temper was so short that he seemed mentally unbalanced.[31]
Family and death
Although Cockburn never married, he had one acknowledged illegitimate son and one illegitimate daughter by the unmarried Amelia (Emily) Godfrey (17 September 1818, baptised 11 October 1818 All Saints' Church, Epping), the daughter of William Daniel Leake Godfrey (1788–1868) and his wife Louisa Hannah (née Dalley, 1791–1852):[5][32][33][34]
Louis Francis John Charles Raphael Cavendish (24 October 1864[38] – 31 December 1890[39]), who never married[40][41][42]
Alexander Cockburn Dalton or Alexander Dalton (Alex) Cockburn (
Sydenham bapt 10 Sep 1845 –
Westminster 16 July 1887[3] ), Capt. 2nd Regt Life Guards, who never married[42][43][44][45] and to whom Cockburn left the majority of his fortune.[5] His son did not succeed him as
Baronet of Langton, which became dormant.
Cockburn died on 20 November 1880,[1] of
angina pectoris at his house at 40
Hertford Street, Mayfair, London; he had continued working up until his death despite three heart attacks and warnings from his doctor.[5] As he never married, he produced no legitimate heirs, despite having a surviving male child. As a result, the baronetcy became dormant upon his death.[1] His remains were deposited in Catacomb A of
Kensal Green Cemetery.
Ancestors
Ancestors of Sir Alexander Cockburn, 12th Baronet[46]
^1851 Census for England – Barrister, aged 47, of Wakehurst Place, Ardingly, Sussex, with the mother (Louisa Hannah Godfrey née Dalley) and sister (Caroline Louisa Matilda Godfrey) of his partner Amelia (Emily) Godfrey – HO107/1642 f.115. p. 18
^
abc1861 Census for England – Lord Chief Justice, aged 58, visiting Chute Lodge, Wiltshire born Altona, with children: Louisa C. Cockburn aged 22 born Stratford, Essex; Alexander Cockburn aged 15 born Sydenham, Surrey – RG9/716 f.19 p. 3
^So styled in English sources and reference books, but the title seems correctly to be attributable to his eldest brother. See: www.ghcaraibe.org/bul/ghc158-159/p3839.rtf
^Towle, E. A., ed. Russell, E. F. (1890). Alexander Heriot Mackonochie: A Memoir. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trübner, & Co.{{
cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (
link)Chapter IX
^Nicholas Mander (2011). Borromean Rings: The Genealogy of the Mander Family. Owlpen Press. Pages 204-5.
^"Louisa Charlotte Cockburn born 1838". All Saints' Church, West Ham, Essex Baptism Register. Retrieved 23 August 2021. born 3 August 1838; bapt 16 June 1839; father = Alexander Edmund Cockburn; mother = Emily Cockburn
^GRO Register of Deaths – JUN 1869 2b 332 I WIGHT Aged 30
^GRO Register of Marriages – JUN 1863 1a 417 CHELSEA. Cavendish = Cockburn
^GRO Register of Deaths – DEC 1890 2b 409 I WIGHT Aged 68
^GRO Register of Births – DEC 1864 1a 242 ST GEO HAN SQ
^GRO Register of Deaths – MAR 1891 1a 445 WESTMINSTER Aged 26
^1871 Census for England: Aged 6 of Burlington Gardens, Westminster, London – RG10/137 f.31 p. 25
^1881 Census for England: Aged 16 of Charlemont, Spencer Drive, Chiswick, London – RG11/1178 f.43 p. 37
^1871 Census for England: Cavalry Officer, unmarried aged 26, of Cavalry Barracks, Clewer, Berkshire – RG10/1302 f.89 p. 1 – born Sydenham, Surrey
^1881 Census for England: Unmarried of no occupation, aged 35, of 24 James Street, Westminster, London – RG11/118 f.105 p. 41 – born Sydenham
^National Probate Calendar (Index of Wills and Administrations): Alexander Dalton Cockburn, Esq. ... formerly Captain in the 2nd Regiment of Life Guards who died 16 July 1887 at 59 Jermyn Street, London ...Probate 2 September 1887
Diamond, B. L. (1956). "Isaac Ray and the trial of Daniel M'Naghten". American Journal of Psychiatry. 112 (8): 651–656.
doi:
10.1176/ajp.112.8.651.
PMID13292555.
Diamond, Michael (2004). Victorian Sensation: Or, the Spectacular, the Shocking and the Scandalous in Nineteenth-Century Britain. Anthem Press.
ISBN1-84331-150-X.
Foulkes, N. (2010). Gentlemen and Blackguards: Gambling Mania and Plot to Steal the Derby of 1844. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. p. Ch.17–19.
ISBN978-0-297-84459-4.