38°53′50″N 77°00′23″W / 38.89731°N 77.00626°W
The National Visitor Center was an ill-fated [1] attempt to repurpose Washington, D.C.'s Union Station as an information center for tourists visiting the United States Capitol and other Washington attractions. It opened for the Bicentennial celebrations in 1976, but it never was able to attract enough crowds to sustain its operating costs, and it closed in 1978. [1]
Conception and construction
As American railroad travel declined in the years after World War II, Union Station fell into financial and physical disrepair, losing much of its former glory [2] as "one of Washington's grandest public spaces" [3] and leading to discussion of alternative uses for the building. In 1958, the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad (B&O) and the Pennsylvania Railroad considered giving away the station or tearing it down and replacing it with an office building. In the early 1960s, government proposals for turning the station into a cultural center or railroad museum were rejected.
In 1967, the chairman of the U.S. Civil Service Commission expressed interest in using Union Station as a visitor center during the upcoming U.S. Bicentennial celebrations. The notion found a strong supporter in U.S. Representative Kenneth J. Gray. [2] In 1968, Congress passed the National Visitor Center Facilities Act toward this end. [2] President Lyndon B. Johnson signed the act into law to create a "central clearinghouse where a visitor can gather information about our many monuments, museums, and Government buildings". [4] On March 12, 1968, the center was authorized into the hands of the National Park Service. [5]
The original 1967 agreement provided that Union Station's owners would pay $16 million for the Visitor Center renovation and construction of the parking garage. When completed, it would then be leased to the government. In 1969 however the Washington, D.C. city planning commission proposed that facilities for an intermodel terminal - combining trains, intercity buses and local buses - should be included in the renovation. Years later this change was cited as the turning point for cascading construction delays: it was now impossible to complete the project for $16 million. [6] Progress was slowed by lawsuits, issues with contracts, and battles among Amtrak and the other railroads involved, Congress, the National Park Service, the Federal Railroad Administration, the Department of the Interior, and the Department of Transportation. [2] Construction finally began in May 1974, and was rushed due to being behind schedule. [2]
Features
Reconstruction of the station included outfitting the famous Main Hall, with its 90-foot ceilings, with a recessed pit to display "Welcome to Washington", an expensive slide show presentation. [7] This was officially the PAVE - the Primary Audio-Visual Experience, [8] produced by the joint output of 100 Kodak Carousel slide projectors behind 100 screens, [8] but was sarcastically referred to as "the Pit". [2] Ironically the chief architect had intended that this viewing area would "...not offend the integrity of the architecture." The visitor center was planned to have two levels. Visitors would enter at the basement level and pass through the theaters and exhibits. They would then transition upward by the Pit escalators to the main floor. Ultimately the basement level was never funded and a new architect had the basement walls closed in. The already-installed escalators were too expensive to remove and were left in place. [9]
The center also featured two 175-seat movie theaters, multilingual information desks, an exhibit on first ladies, a Hall of States, a new parking garage, and a bookstore. [2]
Opening and quick decline
The entire project was completed, save for the parking garage, and opening ceremonies were held on July 4, 1976. [1] But the expected large Bicentennial crowds failed to materialize. [2]
Time did not help; due to a lack of publicity and convenient parking, the National Visitor Center was never popular. To some, the problem was more basic; Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan said, "What is the point of looking at slides of the U.S. Capitol when you can walk out the front door and see it?" [2] By May 1978, the parking garage was still only half complete. [10] On some days there were only a few dozen tourists who used the center. [10] Two 175-seat movie theaters in the center played the film City Out of Wilderness to small handfuls of people. [10] Total National Park Service expenditures for the National Visitor Center eventually ran to over $100 million, [7] and some 20 congressional hearings were held about the project. [2] The Pit, whose slide show was by now frequently turned off, [10] became emblematic of the whole center's failure. [7]
The lack of crowds meant the center could not sustain its operation. [1] Financial considerations caused the National Park Service to close the theaters, end the slideshow presentation in "the Pit", and lay off almost three-quarters of the center's staff on October 28, 1978. [11]
Union Station afterward
With the visitor center closed, the physical condition of the structure got worse. The conversion had failed to address critical infrastructure within the 70-year old building such as its roof integrity and the electrical, plumbing, and heating systems. [2] Parts of the roof collapsed and rain damage ensued, toadstools grew inside the main hall, and the whole station was sealed shut in 1981. [1] [7] Congress decided to save it by act, and control over the entity was transferred from the National Park Service to the Department of Transportation on December 29, 1981. [5] Contractors soon covered over the unloved Pit, [7] completed and expanded the unfinished parking garage, and refurbished the basement movie theaters. Union Station was eventually restored, expanded, and viably reopened in 1988 as both a busy train station and a popular commercial retail area. [1] [12]
In retrospect, the National Visitor Center was viewed as a classic case of "federal tinkering" gone bad, [3] "one of Washington's major embarrassments" [7] and an idea that "failed miserably ... [and] closed in disgrace". [12] Along with the new parking garage, one National Park Service historian later wrote sardonically that the primary legacy of the National Visitor Center was "100 surplus Carousels". [8]
See also
References
- ^ a b c d e f "History of Union Station DC". Jones Lang LaSalle. Archived from the original on 2008-07-08. Retrieved 2008-07-18.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Maureen Dowd (1982-10-25). "In Washington, D.C.: Last Stop for Union Station". Time.
- ^ a b John Mintz (1988-09-25). "Now Boarding: The New Union Station; Renovation Invests Hopes in Revived Grandeur, Trendy Shopping". The Washington Post.
- ^ Woolley, John T.; Gerhard Peters. "The American Presidency Project". University of California, Santa Barbara. Retrieved 2008-03-11.
- ^ a b Barry Mackintosh (1995). "Former National Park System Units: An Analysis". National Park Service. Retrieved 2008-07-18.
- ^ "Statement of Jerome H. Stolarow, Deputy Director, Procurement and Systems Aquisition Division before the Subcommittee on Buildings and Grounds House Committee on Public Works and Transportation" (PDF). 23 February 1978. Retrieved 12 February 2024.
- ^ a b c d e f Paul Goldberger (1988-09-29). "Rail Station Ends Trip From Ruin to Renewal". The New York Times.
- ^ a b c Barry Mackintosh (2000). "Interpretation in the National Park Service: A Historical Perspective". National Park Service. Retrieved 13 February 2024.
- ^ Harden, Blaine (15 November 1980). "Union Station: Washington's Colossal Mess". The Washington Post. Retrieved 13 February 2024.
- ^ a b c d Steven Rattner (1978-05-08). "Now Washington Wants Its Station Back". The New York Times.
- ^ "Visitor Center Staff and Space to Be Reduced". The Washington Post. October 27, 1978. p. C1.
- ^ a b Sydney LeBlanc (2000). The Architecture Traveler: A Guide to 250 Key 20th Century American Buildings. W. W. Norton & Company. pp. 15. ISBN 0-393-73050-6.