Jessica L. Bloom, 1988–1992 – First female mayor. Bloom was a former member of City Council. Was the chairwoman of Lycoming County Democratic Party until her death in 2023.
Phillip E. Preziosi, 1992–1996 – Former member of City Police Department. Second officer to win mayor's office.
Steven W. Cappelli, 1996–2000 – Resigned to become State Representative from 83rd legislative district, 2001–2009
Michael R. Rafferty, 2000–2004 – Served nine years on City Council, six years as council president.
Mary B. Wolf, 2004–2008 – Second female mayor. Wolf was a former member of City Council and a former college professor.