Daiun Sogaku Harada (原田 大雲祖岳, Harada Daiun Sogaku, October 13, 1871 – December 12, 1961) was a Sōtō Zen monk who trained under both
Sōtō and
Rinzai teachers and became known for his teaching combining methods from both schools.[citation needed]
Biography
Born in an area known today as Obama, Fukui Prefecture, he entered a Sōtō temple as a novice at age 7 and continued training in temples during his primary and high school years. Haunted by existential questions, at age 20 he entered
Shogen-ji, a well-known Rinzai monastery; it is reported that he experienced
kensho after two and half years there.[citation needed] In 1901 he graduated from
Komazawa University (then Sōtō-shu Daigakurin), the Sōtō university. He eventually studied under various
Sōtō-priests such as
Harada Sodo Kakusho,[1]Oka Sotan,
Akino Kodo,
Adachi Tatsujun,
Hoshimi Tenkai, and
Rinzai-priests such as
Unmuken Taigi Sogon and
Kogenshitsu Dokutan Sosan, with whom he completed koan-study. From the years of 1911 to 1923, Harada held a professor position at Soto-shu Daigakurin. A very strict
disciplinarian, he served as abbot at various Sōtō temples throughout Japan:
Hosshin-ji,
Chisai-in,
Bukkoku-ji,
Sōji-ji and
Chigen-ji. Until almost age 90, he conducted week-long sesshin at Hosshin-ji 6 times a year; he also held sesshin elsewhere.[citation needed]
Harada Roshi's teaching integrated the Rinzai use of
Kōan, a practice which was abolished in the Sōtō-school in the 19th century under influence of
Gento Sokuchu (1729–1807).[2] He also departed from the Sōtō conventions of his day by training lay persons with monks rather than separately.
A well-known heir in the West is
Hakuun Yasutani Rōshi, a Sōtō monk who he also trained in koan study. This led ultimately to the spread of combined Sōtō and Rinzai methods by the
Sanbo Kyodan, a lay Zen-community founded by Yasutani which became influential in the West. Harada himself, however, remained within the Sōtō sect. It is often claimed in the West that he received
Rinzai inka shomei (dharma transmission) from Dokutan Rōshi; he didn't, as he didn't want to leave the Soto-sect.[note 1]
Harada Rōshi may be viewed as an eclectically talented Sōtō teacher who did not abide by sectarian boundaries in regard to practice method.
Criticism
Harada has been criticized for his support of the Japanese War-endeavors.[3] A famous quote from Harada, cited in
Zen at War, is:
[If ordered to] march: tramp, tramp, or shoot: bang, bang. This is the manifestation of the highest Wisdom [of Enlightenment]. The unity of Zen and war of which I speak extends to the farthest reaches of the holy war [now under way].[4][5]
^* James Ford,
The Great Cloud Dies: Recalling Zen Master Daiun Sogaku Harada: "There is debate within the Zen community as to whether he [Daiun Sogaku Harada] actually received dharma transmission from Dokutan Roshi. I was told by Maezumi Roshi that while Dokutan Roshi considered Harada Roshi to have completed all necessary training with him to be an independent master of the koan way, there was no formal transmission. In that time and place such a formal recognition would have also had Harada leave the Soto school, something that he had no desire to do." * Barry Kaigen McMahon,
The Evolution of the White Plum. A short and incomplete history of its founders and their practice: "Maezumi Roshi told Mr. Yu Ohgushi, a Hannya Dojo roommate of mine and frequent visitor to ZCLA, that it was indeed doubtful if Harada ever actually received or accepted dharma transmission from Dokutan Sosan. The reason being that Harada had already received transmission in the Soto school and it would have been religiously/politically incorrect to get it in the Rinzai school at that time. As Maezumi Roshi did receive dharma transmission from Koryu Roshi perhaps it had become a non-issue after the war."
Tiltenberg (2002), Zen Without Dirty Hands? Report from a seminar and retreat at De Tiltenberg, Vogelenzang in the Netherlands July 17–22, 2001,
ISBN90-807042-3-7
Victoria, Brian Daizen (2006), Zen at war (Second ed.), Lanham e.a.: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.
