Lidz was a novice reporter at the weekly Sanford Star, where he wrote a column and covered police and fire beats. He left Maine to become a crime reporter and write a column called "Insect Jazz" for an alternative newspaper in
Baltimore.[34] He later became an editor of Johns Hopkins University Magazine.[35]
In 1980, he joined the staff of Sports Illustrated,[36][37][38][39][40] even though he had never read the magazine[41] and had covered only one sporting event in his life – a
pigeon race in
Shapleigh,
Maine.[42][43][26] Lidz remained on the writing staff for 27 years.[44] In 2007 he jumped to the short-lived business monthly Conde Nast Portfolio, and then
WSJ. magazine[45] before landing at Smithsonian in 2012. His first feature story in The New York Times, on making the second descent of the
Zambezi River, appeared on January 30, l983.[46]
Unstrung Heroes is about Lidz's childhood, with his mother, father and his dad's four older brothers.[26][64][65] He had previously written about two of the uncles in Sports Illustrated.[66][67]
In his review of Unstrung Heroes in the New York Times,
Christopher Lehmann-Haupt called the memoir "unusual and affecting... a melancholy, funny book, a loony tune played with touching disharmony on mournful woodwinds and a noisy klaxon."[68]Jonathan Kirsch of the Los Angeles Times likened the memoir to a "miniature Brothers Karamazov. There's not a false moment in the book, and that is high praise indeed."[69]The Village Voice called Unstrung Heroes: "Astonishing, hilarious, angry, poignant, always pointed."[70]
In 1995, Unstrung Heroes was adapted into
a film of the same title.[19] The setting was switched from
New York City to
Southern California, and the four crazy uncles were reduced to an eccentric odd couple. Asked what he thought of the script, Lidz said: "It's very neatly typed".[71] He was unhappy with the adaptation, but was prevented by his contract from publicly criticizing it. "My initial fear was that
Disney would turn my uncles into
Grumpy and
Dopey," he told
New York magazine. "I never imagined my life could be turned into
Old Yeller."[72] In a later essay for the New York Times, he said that the cinematic Selma had died not of cancer, but of 'Old Movie Disease'. "Someday somebody may find a cure for cancer, but the terminal sappiness of cancer movies is probably beyond remedy."[73]
Ghosty Men
Ghosty Men (2003) is the story of the
Collyer brothers. Lidz has said that he was inspired by the real-life cautionary tales that his father told him, the most macabre of which was the story of the Collyer brothers, the hermit hoarders of
Harlem.[74] The book also recounts the parallel life of Arthur Lidz,[75] the hermit uncle of Unstrung Heroes, who grew up near the Collyer mansion.[76]
In his review for the Washington Post, Adam Bernstein wrote, "The Collyer Brothers made compelling reading then, as they do now in this short, captivatingly detailed book."[77]
Fairway to Hell
Fairway to Hell is a 2008 memoir centering on Lidz' unusual golfing experiences: encountering nudists, llama caddies[41] and celebrities like the heavy metal band Judas Priest.[78][79]Bill Littlefield reviewed the book on the
National Public Radio show Only A Game, saying "His estimable wit is also evident in Fairway To Hell."[80]
Collaborations
Lidz has written numerous essays for The New York Times with novelist and former Sports Illustrated colleague
Steve Rushin.[81][82][83] Three of them appear under the title Piscopo Agonistes in the 2000 collection Mirth of a Nation: The Best Contemporary Humor.