Pietro — cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Via Lata, † after 1148
21 September 1145
Guido de Crema — cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Portico, cardinal-priest of S. Maria in Trastevere (14 March 1158), Antipope Paschalis III (22 April 1164), † 20 September 1168
25 February 1149
Grecus — cardinal-deacon of SS. Sergio e Bacco, † 30 August 1149
16 December 1149
Nicholas Breakspeare, C.R.St.-Ruf — cardinal-bishop of Albano, Pope Hadrian IV (4 December 1154), † 1 September 1159
22 September 1150
Rolando of Siena — cardinal-deacon of SS. Cosma e Damiano, cardinal-priest of S. Marco (2 March 1151), Pope Alexander III (7 September 1159), † 30 August 1181
Giovanni Gaderisio, Can.Reg. — cardinal-deacon of SS. Sergio e Bacco, cardinal-priest of S. Anastasia (14 March 1158), † April 1182
2 March 1151
Gerard — cardinal-priest of S. Stefano in Celiomonte, † 1158
Cencio de Gregorio — cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Aquiro, then cardinal-priest of S. Lorenzo in Lucina (21 February 1152) and cardinal-bishop of Porto e S. Rufina (April 1154), † 1157
21 December 1151
Hugo, O.Cist. — cardinal-bishop of Ostia, † 1 December 1158
Enrico Pisano, O.Cist. — cardinal-priest of SS. Nereo ed Achilleo, † 1166
Gerard de Namur — cardinal-deacon of the Holy Roman Church, then cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Via Lata (19 December 1152), † 1155
Ottone da Brescia — cardinal-deacon of the Holy Roman Church, then cardinal-deacon of S. Nicola in Carcere (19 December 1152), † 1174
23 May 1152
Giovanni Morrone — cardinal-priest of SS. Silvestro e Martino, † ca. 1167/68
Bernard de Rennes, O.Cist. — cardinal-deacon of the Holy Roman Church, then cardinal-deacon of SS. Cosma e Damiano (19 December 1152), † 1 May 1154
Ildebrando Grassi, Can.Reg. — cardinal-deacon of the Holy Roman Church, then cardinal-deacon of S. Eustachio (19 December 1152), cardinal-priest of SS. XII Apostoli (21 December 1156), † 8 November 1178.
"Presumed cardinals"
The following other persons are also listed as cardinals created by Eugene III,[2] but they should be excluded from that list because they were never promoted to the cardinalate or are confused with another cardinals ("presumed cardinals"):[3]
Name
Alleged cardinalate
Notes
Guy
Cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Portico 1145–ca.1159
He is the same as Guido di Crema, future Antipope Paschalis III[4]
Rainiero Marescotti
Cardinal-deacon of SS. Sergio e Bacco in 1145
This cardinal appears only in the falsehoods of the 16th century[5]
Bercarco
Cardinal-deacon in 1145
He subscribed a bull on 14 March 1145[6] but this is certainly the same person as cardinal-deacon Berardo created by Lucius II,[7] whose name has been corrupted on some copies of this bull[8]
Guido
Cardinal-deacon in 1145
Guido S.R.E. diaconus card. subscribed papal bulls between 14 March and 12 May 1145, but he is the same as
Guido de Castro Ficeclo, created by Innocent II, not a separate individual [9]
He is the same as
Guido de Summa, who was created cardinal-priest of S. Lorenzo in Damaso by Celestine II in 1143; Eugene III promoted him to cardinal-bishop of Ostia in 1149[12]
Giovanni
Cardinal-priest of S. Marco 1149–1151
He did not subscribe any papal bulls.[13] The title of S. Marco was occupied by Gilberto from 1143 until 1150 and then by Rolando from March 1151.[14]
Galfroy, bishop of St.Asaph 1152–1154
Cardinal-deacon 1149–ca.1175
He did not subscribe any papal bulls[15] and the great majority of the sources doubt or ignore his alleged promotion to the cardinalate[16]
Gualterio
Cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Portico 1149–1155
The existence of this cardinal is not possible at that time because the deaconry of S. Maria in Portico was occupied by Guido di Crema from 1145 until 1158[17]
Sylvester, O.S.B., abbot of Subiaco
Cardinal-priest or deacon in 1150
Neither the cardinal nor the abbot of Subiaco with this name is attested at that time.[18] Apparently he is confused with Simone Borelli, abbot of Subiaco 1149/52–1183/84,[19] created cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Domnica by Hadrian IV[20]
Cardinal-deacon of SS. Vito e Modesto 1152–1159, joined the obedience of
Antipope Victor IV in 1159
He did not subscribe any papal bulls[25] and is not attested among the adherents of Victor IV in 1159.[26] The cardinal with this name and title lived under Callixtus II[27]
Besides, it is often claimed that cardinals
Jordan of S. Susanna, Bernardo of S. Clemente and Cinzio of SS. Sergio e Bacco were created by Eugene III, but they were all promoted by
Lucius II as "cardinal-deacons of the Holy Roman Church"; Eugene III only gave them the
titular churches.[28]
Notes
^Reconstruction based on Horn, pp. 184–188; cfr. Zenker, pp. 224-225; Brixius, pp. 53-57
^About the "presumed cardinals" in general see A. Paravicini Bagliani: Cardinali di curia e "familiae" cardinalizie dal 1227 al 1254, Padova 1972, p. 519 ff. and Elfriede Kartusch, Das Kardinalskollegium in der Zeit von 1181-1227, Wien 1948, p. 428-438. After the publications of Hierarchia Catholica by
Konrad Eubel (1st edition in 1898) and of the dissertation of Brixius (1910, printed in 1912), it is generally accepted that for 12th and 13th centuries the cardinals listed in the older literature (e.g.
A. Ciacconius, Vitæ, et res gestæ Pontificvm Romanorum et S. R. E. Cardinalivm, ed. A. Oldoini, Rome 1677; or Lorenzo Cardella, Memorie storiche de' cardinali della Santa Romana Chiesa. Rome 1792), who did not subscribe any papal bulls, should be eliminated from the catalogs of cardinals, unless other contemporary sources attest their promotion. Brixius, p. 40–60, identified only three such cardinals promoted between 1130 and 1159, one of them (Bernardo of Pisa, future Pope Eugene III) probably erroneously, cf. Horn, pp. 42-45.
^H. Tillmann: Ricerche sull’origine dei membri del collegio cardinalizio nel XII secolo, Rivista di storia della chiesa in Italia, XXIV, 1970, p. 450–452.
^Jaffé, p. 20–21. Brixius, Zenker and Horn do not mention him among the cardinals created by Eugene III. Even Cardella, p. 67, questions the existence of this cardinal
^Jaffé, p. 20–21, 89–90. Brixius, Zenker and Horn do not mention him among the cardinals created by Eugene III.
^The evidence confirming this identification by Brixius, p. 97–98
^Jaffé, p. 20. Brixius, Zenker and Horn do not mention him among the cardinals created by Eugene III
^The Cardinals of the Holy Roman Church by Salvador Miranda; retrieved on 25 September 2009. Brixius, Zenker and Horn do not mention him among the cardinals created by Eugene III.
^Brixius, p. 143; Zenker, p. 168; cf. Jaffé, p. 20–21, 89–90, 102–103.
^Jaffé, p. 20–21; Placido Lugano, L'Italia benedictina, Rome 1929, p. 146
^Placido Lugano, L'Italia benedictina, Rome 1929, p. 146
^Brixius, p. 59-60 no. 11; Zenker, p. 140–141 no. 113.
^Jaffé, p. 20–21. Brixius, Zenker and Horn do not mention him among the cardinals created by Eugene III
^MGH DDF IArchived July 19, 2011, at the
Wayback Machine, passim (see index, p. 372). He may be confused with Ardicio Rivoltella, who was created cardinal-deacon of S. Teodoro in 1156; cf. Brixius, p. 58 no. 2; Zenker, p. 157-159 no. 130.
^Cf. G. Ferri, Le carte dell'Archivio Liberiano dal secolo X al XV, Archivio della Societa Romana di storia patria, vol. 27, 1904, p. 444
^Jaffé, p. 20–21. Brixius, Zenker and Horn do not mention him among the cardinals created by Eugene III. Lorenzo Cardella, Memorie storiche de' cardinali della Santa Romana Chiesa. Rome 1792, vol. I, pt. 2, p. 81, lists him but considers his promotion doubtful. He may be confused with cardinal Ildebrando Grassi, who was at first deacon of S. Eustachio and then priest of SS. Apostoli.
^Jaffé, pp. 20–21, 89–90, 102–103. Brixius, Zenker and Horn do not mention him among the cardinals created by Eugene III