Reimer played four seasons with the
Wisconsin Badgers, 2008–2012, and scored 214 points in 152 games in that period. She won two
NCAA championships with the Badgers and was twice named to the
NCAA Frozen Four All-Tournament Team.[4][5] She is the fourth-highest scorer in the programme's history, and was named 2010 WCHA Preseason Player of the Year.[6][7]
Upon the creation of the
NWHL in 2015, she signed with the Metropolitan Riveters for the
2015–16 season. She scored the franchise's first-ever goal off of an assist from
Lyudmila Belyakova in the inaugural game of the NWHL. The goal was the third goal scored in league history and Belyakova's assist was the first point earned by a European player. With the Riveters, Reimer posted 14 points in 15 regular season games and one point in two playoff games.
After one season with the Riveters, Reimer returned to Germany. She signed with the
ERC Ingolstadt women's team for the
2017–18 DFEL season. Her husband,
Jochem, signed with the ERC Ingolstadt men's team in 2017 also.
^Rosen, Dan.
"Breaking the Ice"Archived January 24, 2023, at the
Wayback Machine, copy of article from The Record, March 4, 2005. Accessed May 6, 2020. "The skating didn't give the truth away, the motion was fluid, compact and strong. A freshman wasn't supposed to handle the puck with such flair either. At only 14 years old and enlarged by layers of pads, the 5-foot-7 player looked like everyone else on the ice. But when Brooke Ammerman, playing her first varsity game for Pascack Valley in December, was about to break into the clear for a glorious scoring opportunity, the defenseman did what he needed to do to avoid being beaten.... Without a girls varsity league in New Jersey, the other dozen or so females competing in North Jersey high school hockey continue to play with and against boys because they enjoy the challenge."