The band's debut
albumLove Peace & Fuck was hammered by the press for its gratuitous soloing and guitar heavy production. But with the recent return of heavy metal values to underground music via re-appraissals of Blue Cheer and Sir Lord Baltimore, Love Peace & Fuck has since come to be regarded by the new American Underground as something of a classic,}[8] and a US
compilation album of the band was released in 2005, on San Francisco's Mister E. Records. The same year, a song entitled "Messages" from the second Brain Donor album, Too Freud To Rock 'n' Roll, Too Jung To Die, appeared in the American film, The Lost.
Bales was replaced by new drummer, known as Mr. E,[9] for the band's last two albums. Brain Donor has been inactive since 2009's Wasted Fuzz Excessive.
Too Freud to Rock 'n' Roll, Too Jung to Die (Brain Donor Records, 2003)[11] (2-CD set; CD 1 features studio material from 1999-2002, CD 2 contains a 2000 live recording)[12]