Five days before the 2016 election, Melania told a crowd of supporters in Pennsylvania: "Our culture has gotten too mean and too rough, especially to children and teenagers. It is never okay when a 12-year-old girl or boy is mocked, bullied, or attacked. It is terrible when that happens on the playground. And it is absolutely unacceptable when it is done by someone with no name hiding on the Internet".[2] Regarding the contrast of her platform with
her husband's use of social media during his campaign, Melania said shortly after the election that she had rebuked him "all the time", but that "he will do what he wants to do in the end".[3]
On March 13, 2018, Trump scheduled a March 20, 2018 meeting with policy executives from technology companies — including
Amazon,
Facebook,
Google,
Snap, and
Twitter — to address online harassment and Internet safety, with a particular focus on how those issues affect children.[4] Trump's office avoided the use of the term "cyberbullying",[4] and she came under criticism for championing Internet civility while her husband's Internet behavior had been noted as uncivil.[4][5] Trump attended the roundtable event, focusing on how children are affected by modern technology. Trump said: "I am well aware that people are skeptical of me discussing this topic", but "that will not stop me from doing what I know is right".[6]
Campaign
Melania Trump made the initiative and came up with the name "Be Best". Trump said she was prepared for criticism.[7][8]
On May 7, 2018, Trump formally started the Be Best public awareness campaign, which focused on well-being for youth and advocated against
cyberbullying and
opioid abuse.[9][10] She made the announcement in the
White House Rose Garden, a space more typically used for major political announcements from the president.[11] Instead of creating new programs like previous first ladies' projects, Be Best promoted existing initiatives and organizations that worked toward the cause. Public awareness of the initiate remained low, and it was often regarded solely as an anti-cyberbullying campaign.[12]
The initiative began with a very slow start, as Trump underwent kidney surgery one week after the campaign was launched. She made no public appearances for the next several weeks.[17] On July 24, 2018, she visited the
Monroe Carell Jr. Children's Hospital at Vanderbilt in
Nashville, Tennessee and talked about children with
neonatal withdrawal.[18] On August 6, 2018, she tweeted: "It's #Backtoschool for many youth this month. As you begin a new year, how will you be the best you? #BeBest".[19] She spoke at a cyberbullying summit outside
Washington, D.C., on August 20, 2018.[20]
During the initiative's first year, she also promoted Be Best in-person at events in Oklahoma, Washington state, and Nevada. She also promoted Be Best abroad in trips to Ghana, Malawi, Kenya, and Egypt.[21]
In 2020, when scholars and historians were asked during the
Siena College Research Institute's first ladies study to assess the signature initiatives of the then most-recent ten first ladies (those from
Lady Bird Johnson onward), "Be Best" was ranked as the worst.[22]
Criticism
The slogan "Be Best" has faced criticism for having an apparent grammatical error, as it is missing a definite article, and should read as, "Be the Best."[23][24][25][26][11]The Guardian noted Mrs. Trump's native language,
Slovenian, does not use definite articles, and speculated whether the name constituted one-upmanship after
Michelle Obama's call to "Be Better".[27] Mrs. Trump's senior advisor,
Stephanie Winston Wolkoff, called the slogan "illiterate" and pushed for an alternative slogan, "Children First", which the First Lady rejected due to the similarities with her husband's "
America First" branding.[28] She commented to her staff that "at least they won't say I plagiarized it".[10]
Trump faced accusations of plagiarization of a Michelle Obama speech when, as part of her "Be Best" campaign in 2018, she gave a speech that appeared to closely echo remarks by Michelle Obama in 2016 and also distributed a written pamphlet that was nearly identical to one published under the
Obama administration in 2014.[29][30]
The Be Best campaign drew criticism over perceived hypocrisy for its goal of challenging cyberbullying as her husband Donald Trump was well known for attacking people online.[31] The comparison was noted upon by Donald Trump prior to his campaign's launch that the contrast could provoke criticism.[12] She acknowledged the discrepancy but insisted that she would continue because she felt it was a good cause.[31] On December 12, 2019, Melania Trump's 'Be Best' hashtag trended on
Twitter after the President sent a critical tweet directed to then 16-year-old climate activist
Greta Thunberg.[32][33][34][35][36] Several media outlets noted that Melania Trump criticized legal expert
Pamela Karlan the previous week after Karlan mentioned the Trumps' teenage son,
Barron, during testimony as part of the then ongoing
impeachment inquiry.[32] The first lady's office responded that spouses can communicate differently and that Barron was not "an activist who travels the globe giving speeches".[37]
Caroli, Betty Boyd (2019). "Chapter 11: The Ever-Changing Role of First Lady". First Ladies: The Ever Changing Role, from Martha Washington to Melania Trump. Oxford University Press. pp. 333–348.
ISBN978-0-19-066913-3.