This song displays the very prominent role played by
Danny Whitten in the sound of Young's early recordings. The vocals are a duet, with Whitten singing the high
harmony against Young's low harmony. (The 45 rpm single mix of the song, in addition to being in
mono and cutting off the guitar outro, features Whitten's vocal more prominently than the album version.) Young performed the song on his then-recently acquired
Gibson Les Paul, "
Old Black". The NME named "Cinnamon Girl" an example of "proto-
grunge".[4]
The song was written in
double drop D tuning (DADGBD). This tuning is used in several of his most famous songs, such as "
The Loner", "The Old Laughing Lady", "
When You Dance I Can Really Love", "
Ohio", and "
Cortez the Killer".[5] The music features a prominent descending
bass guitar line.[6] The song's "one note guitar solo", consisting largely of a repeating, sharply played
jangling D note, has often been singled out for praise.[7] According to Young "people say that it is a solo with only one note but, in my head, each one of those notes is different. The more you get into it, the more you can hear the differences.”[8]
Lyrics
The lyrics have the singer daydreaming for a girl to love, singing that he waits "between shows" for his lover.[9] Young has said that he wrote the song "for a city girl on peeling pavement coming at me through
Phil Ochs' eyes playing
finger cymbals. It was hard to explain to my wife."[6] The "city girl playing finger cymbals" is a reference to folk singer
Jean Ray.[9] Music critic
Johnny Rogan described the lyrics as "exotic and allusive without really saying anything at all."[6] Critic
Toby Creswell describes the lyrics as "cryptic love lyrics" noting that they are sung "over the crunching power of
Crazy Horse."[3] Critic
John Mendelsohn felt the song conveyed a message of "desperation begetting brutal vindictiveness," hinted at by the "almost impenetrably subjective words" but carried strongly by the sound of Crazy Horse's "heavy, sinister accompaniment."[3]
Introducing the song at a performance associated with Writer's Week at Whittier College (California) in April, 2015,
Los Lobos co-founder
Louie Perez said that when he first heard "Cinnamon Girl", he was sure it was about a Mexican girl.[10] People[according to whom?] have also speculated whether or not the song referred to
Jim Morrison's common-law wife,
Pamela Courson. Jim and Pamela were part of the Topanga community around this time, and Pamela had red-brown hair reminiscent of cinnamon. She was a well-known groupie on Sunset Strip prior to meeting Jim. Young has denied, however, that the song refers to her.[citation needed]
According to his autobiography, "Cinnamon Girl" was the first record played by the now-legendary British DJ
"Whispering Bob" Harris on his
BBC Radio 1 debut in August 1970.[11]
Chart performance
"Cinnamon Girl" was released as a single in 1970, where it reached No. 55 on the
Billboard Hot 100.[12] The song peaked at number 34 in Australia.[13]
Legacy and influence
British music publication NME ranked "Cinnamon Girl"'s opening chord progression at No. 47 on its "50 Greatest Guitar Riffs Of All Time".[4]
Danish band
Kashmir performed a cover version on their live CD/DVD The Aftermath.
Phish has covered the song a total of four times, once at Gallagher's in Vermont on 3/1/1989, twice during their 1997 tours, and once at Madison Square Garden on 07/29/2017.[15]