James J. Braddock is an
Irish-Americanboxer from
New Jersey, formerly a
light heavyweight contender, who is forced to give up boxing after breaking his hand in the ring. This is both a relief and a burden to his wife, Mae. She cannot bring herself to watch the violence of his chosen profession, yet she knows they will not have enough income without his boxing.
As the United States enters the
Great Depression, Braddock does
manual labor as a
longshoreman to support his family, even with his injured hand. Unfortunately, he cannot get work every day. Thanks to a last-minute cancellation by another boxer, Braddock's longtime manager and friend,
Joe Gould, offers him a chance to fill in for just one night and earn cash. The fight is against the number-two contender in the world,
Corn Griffin.
Braddock stuns the boxing experts and fans with a third-round knockout of his formidable opponent. He believes that while his right hand was broken, he became more proficient with his left hand, improving his in-ring ability. Despite Mae's objections, Braddock takes up Gould's offer to return to the ring. Mae resents this attempt by Gould to profit from her husband's dangerous livelihood, until she discovers that Gould and his wife also have been devastated by hard times.
With a shot at the heavyweight championship held by
Max Baer a possibility, Braddock continues to win. Out of a sense of pride, he uses a portion of his prize money to pay back money to the government given to him while unemployed. When his
rags to riches story gets out, the sportswriter
Damon Runyon dubs him "The Cinderella Man", and before long Braddock comes to represent the hopes and aspirations of the American public struggling with the Depression.
After wins against
John Henry Lewis and
Art Lasky, a title fight against Baer comes his way. Braddock is a 10-to-1
underdog. Baer is so destructive that the fight's promoter, James Johnston, forces both Braddock and Gould to watch a film of Baer in action, just so he can maintain later that he warned them what Braddock was up against, as Baer had reportedly killed
2men in the ring.
Braddock demonstrates no fear. The arrogant Baer attempts to intimidate him, even taunting Mae in public that her man might not survive. When he says this, she becomes so angry that she throws a drink at him. She is unable to attend the fight at the
Madison Square Garden Bowl or even to listen to it on the radio.
On June 13, 1935, in one of the greatest upsets in boxing history, Braddock defeats the seemingly invincible Baer to become the heavyweight champion of the world.
An epilogue reveals that Braddock would lose his title to
Joe Louis (who would later call Braddock "the most courageous man I ever fought") and later worked on the building of the
Verrazzano Bridge, owning and operating heavy machinery on the docks where he worked during the Depression, and that he and Mae used his boxing income to buy a house, where they spent the rest of their lives.
During filming in
Toronto, several areas were redressed to resemble 1930s New York. The Richmond Street side of
The Bay's Queen Street store was redressed as
Madison Square Garden, complete with fake store fronts and period stop lights. A stretch of
Queen Street East between Broadview and Carlaw was also made up to appear to be from the 1930s and dozens of period cars were parked along the road.
Maple Leaf Gardens was used for all the fight scenes, and many scenes were filmed in the
Distillery District. Filming also took place in
Hamilton, Ontario at the harbour for the dock workers' scene.[4] The main apartment was shot north of
St. Clair Avenue on Lauder Avenue on the west side. An awning was put up for a dress shop, later turned into a real coffee shop.
In a campaign to boost ticket sales after the film's low opening,
AMC Theatres advertised on June 24, 2005, that in 30 markets (about 150 theaters nationwide), it would offer a refund to any ticket-buyer dissatisfied with the film.[5] The advertisement, published in The New York Times and other papers and on internet film sites, read, "AMC believes Cinderella Man is one of the finest motion pictures of the year! We believe so strongly that you'll enjoy Cinderella Man we're offering a Money Back Guarantee." The promotion moderately increased box office revenue for a short period, while at least 50 patrons demanded refunds. Following suit,
Cinemark Theatres also offered a money-back guarantee in 25 markets that did not compete with AMC Theatres. AMC had last employed such a strategy (in limited markets) for the 1988 release of Mystic Pizza,[6] while
20th Century Fox had unsuccessfully tried a similar ploy for its 1994 remake of Miracle on 34th Street.
Reception
Critical response
Rotten Tomatoes reported an approval rating of 80% based on 215 reviews, with an average rating of 7.4/10. The website's critics consensus reads: "With grittiness and an evocative sense of time and place, Cinderella Man is a powerful underdog story. And Ron Howard and Russell Crowe prove to be a solid combination."[7]Metacritic assigned the film a weighted average score of 69 out of 100, based on 40 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews".[8] Audiences polled by
CinemaScore gave the film a rare average grade of "A+".[9]
Roger Ebert of The Chicago Sun-Times gave the film three-and-a-half out of four stars. He wrote that while Cinderella Man was effecting as a boxing movie, its true genius was in Giamatti's "home run" portrayal of Gould and Crowe's
against type performance as a "level-headed, sweet-tempered" family man: "You'd have to go back to actors like
James Stewart and
Spencer Tracy to find such goodness and gentleness".[10]
The film earned $61 million at the US box office and $108 million worldwide.[3]
In April 2018, Crowe auctioned off as part of his "divorce auction" a number of props he owned which were used by him in his various films, including a jockstrap, pair of shorts and robe which were worn by Crowe in Cinderella Man. The items from the film as well as the other items on auction were bought by the
HBO television show Last Week Tonight with John Oliver, with the jockstrap having sold for $7,000. The items purchased were then donated to the last operating
Blockbuster Video store in
Alaska.[56] The jockstrap was reported missing; however, in the final episode of season 5 of Last Week Tonight, John Oliver revealed that it had been taken back and showed a short heist parody filmed with it.
^"Winners & Nominees 2006". Golden Globes. Hollywood Foreign Press Association (HFPA). Archived from
the original on December 20, 2016. Retrieved July 21, 2022.
^過去の受賞一覧 [List of past awards]. Hochi Shimbun (in Japanese). Retrieved July 21, 2022.
^第18回日刊スポーツ映画大賞・第30回報知映画賞 [18th Nikkan Sports Film Awards / 30th Hochi Film Awards]. シアターリーグ [Theater League] (in Japanese). December 2, 2005. Retrieved July 21, 2022.